过程才是关键,蠢货。
It's Always the Process, Stupid

原始链接: https://its.promp.td/its-always-the-process-stupid/

不要指望人工智能来修复有问题的流程——它只会加速现有问题。目前对“人工智能战略”的关注是错误的;真正的进步在于**业务流程优化 (BPO)**。人工智能不是关于*增加*智能,而是关于*提高*速度。自动化一个有缺陷的流程只会让这些缺陷发生得更快。 人工智能的独特优势在于处理非结构化数据——电子邮件、PDF、图像——这是以前的技术无法做到的。然而,这暴露了一个关键问题:依赖这些数据的流程通常没有文档记录且是临时的,存在于员工的知识中,而不是标准程序中。 在应用人工智能之前,你*必须*构建这些工作流程。定义触发器、转换和结构化输出。人工智能擅长*速度*——快速执行定义的任务——但需要人工管理来提供潜在的智能和上下文。 最终,成功采用人工智能需要先绘制你的价值链,识别低效之处,并简化流程。然后,并且只有那时,人工智能才能用于加速这些优化的工作流程。这不仅仅是关于技术;它始终是关于流程。

## 人工智能无法修复有缺陷的流程 最近的Hacker News讨论强调了人工智能实施的一个关键点:**人工智能不是一种策略,而是一种最好在优化核心业务流程*之后*使用的工具。** 核心论点是,仅仅将“人工智能粉末”应用于有缺陷的工作流程只会加速错误的产生,而不会改善结果。 许多评论者表示赞同,并将这种情况与软件开发相提并论,在软件开发中,组织问题(“组织债务”)常常伪装成技术问题。人工智能擅长处理非结构化数据,但*依赖*于这些数据的流程通常本身就缺乏结构,首先需要进行根本性的改进。 讨论指出了一种反复出现的模式:领导者错误地认为新技术是降低成本的措施,未能认识到真正发挥其潜力的更深层次的投资。最终,信息很明确:在追求最新的AI趋势*之前*,专注于业务流程优化(BPO)。
相关文章

原文

Let’s rip the Band-Aid off immediately: If your underlying business process is a mess, sprinkling "AI dust" on it won’t turn it into gold. It will just speed up the rate at which you generate garbage.

In the world of Business IT, we get seduced by the shiny new toy. Right now, that toy is Artificial Intelligence. Boardrooms are buzzing with buzzwords like LLMs, agentic workflows, and generative reasoning. Executives are frantically asking, "What is our AI strategy?"

But here is the hard truth:

There is no such thing as an AI strategy.
There is only Business Process Optimization (BPO).

The "Magic Wand" Fallacy

Too many enterprises treat AI like a magic wand. They believe that by implementing a sophisticated neural network, their structural inefficiencies will vanish. They think AI brings intelligence.

It doesn’t.

Like every major technological shift before it—from the steam engine to the spreadsheet—AI does not inherently make an organization smarter. AI, like any other tool, only makes faster.

If you automate a stupid decision, you just make stupid decisions at light speed. If you apply an agentic AI workflow to a bureaucratic nightmare of an approval chain, you haven't fixed the bureaucracy; you’ve just built a robot that hates its job as much as your employees do.

The Unstructured Data Trap

There is, however, one superpower AI possesses that previous tools lacked: It is the first technology that is truly useful for handling unstructured data.

For decades, traditional software demanded structure. Rows, columns, booleans, and fixed fields. If data didn't fit the box, the computer couldn't read it.

AI changes this. It can read messy emails, interpret vague Slack messages, parse PDFs, and analyze images. But this capability exposes a massive, hidden problem in most enterprises.

Processes that rely on unstructured data are usually unstructured processes.

Because computers couldn't handle the mess, humans handled it (before AI). And humans don't always follow a flow chart. These processes—like "handling a complex customer complaint" or "brainstorming a marketing campaign"—are often ad-hoc, intuitive, and completely undocumented. They live in the heads of your senior staff, not in your SOPs.

You Can’t Automate What You Haven’t Designed

This brings us back to BPO. You cannot apply AI to these "hidden" processes until you drag them into the light.

If you want to use AI to process unstructured data, you must first bring structure to the workflow itself. You need to improve your process design to account for the ambiguity that AI handles.

Ask yourself:

  1. What is the trigger? (Where does the unstructured mess come from?)
  2. What is the transformation? (What exactly is the human—or now the AI—supposed to extract or deduce from that mess?)
  3. What is the structured output? (How does this flow back into your rigid ERP or CRM systems?)

Speed vs. Intelligence

Let’s clarify the distinction between "smarter" and "faster."

Intelligence implies wisdom, context, and nuance. While AI models are simulating reasoning better every day, in a business context, they are fundamentally pattern-matching engines. They excel at acceleration.

  • The Old Way: An analyst reads 50 contracts (unstructured), highlights risks based on gut feeling (unstructured process), and summarizes them in 3 days.
  • The AI Way: An AI scans 50 contracts and extracts specific risk clauses based on defined parameters in 3 minutes.

The process (Review Contracts -> Identify Risk -> Summarize) hasn't changed, but it had to be rigorously defined for the AI to work. The intelligence (knowing what a "risk" actually means) still requires human governance. What has changed is the velocity.

The Bottom Line

Stop chasing the hype. Stop looking for a specialized "AI Savior."

Go back to the whiteboard. Map out your value chain—especially the messy, human-centric parts involving unstructured data that you previously ignored. Find the bottlenecks. Identify the waste.

Once you have a streamlined, logical, and robust business process, then apply AI to hit the accelerator.

Technology changes.
The rules of business efficiency do not.
It’s always the process, stupid!

And that's where actual AI Tools are missing that point, because they weren't build for that

The Great IT-Divide: Why AI-Adoption in enterprises is failing

IT innovation moved from business tools to social tech, creating two distinct IT worlds: Business-IT (compliance, efficiency) and Social-IT (social interaction). Grasping this divide is crucial for enterprise adoption and explains why businesses struggle with AI uptake.


Live long and prosper 😉🖖

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com