纽约刚刚终止了其自动驾驶出租车计划。真正的问题不在于技术。
New York Just Killed Its Robotaxi Plan. The Real Problem Isn't the Technology

原始链接: https://www.phyware.io/blog/ny-robotaxi-trust-gap

纽约州州长霍楚尔最近撤回了一项提案,该提案本将允许Waymo等商业机器人出租车服务在全州范围内运营,原因是缺乏立法支持。问题不在于*技术*本身——Waymo已经在多个城市成功运营——而在于监管机构与自动驾驶(AV)公司之间存在严重的**信任缺失**。 目前,监管机构必须*信任*自动驾驶公司自行报告运营数据,缺乏对安全性的独立验证。 拟议的保障措施,如费用和审批,并不能解决核心问题:理解车辆在公共道路上每时每刻的决策。 这个问题不仅限于机器人出租车,而是延伸到所有自主系统。 PhyWare正在开发一种解决方案:一个数据平台,为机器人创建可验证的“飞行记录器”。 他们的系统PhyTrace & PhyCloud,捕获并不可篡改地存储全面的运营数据,允许独立审计,并将对话从许可转向数据驱动的评估。 这种方法旨在建立信任,并促进自动驾驶技术的更安全部署。

纽约市暂停了其机器人出租车计划,引发了关于根本原因的争论。一些人建议采用技术解决方案,例如防篡改的数据记录(可能通过区块链),以提高透明度和问责制,但许多评论员认为核心问题不在于技术本身,而是缺乏针对自动驾驶车辆的标准化、独立的测试和认证。 担忧集中在确保在*所有*条件下安全运行,包括传感器退化和紧急情况(例如Waymo在旧金山停电期间出现的问题)。一位评论员强调需要一个中立的第三方,例如UL,在公共部署*之前*验证车辆性能。 对于该计划失败的理由,存在怀疑,一些人认为其中存在政治动机和潜在的“贿赂”。一家推广用于自动驾驶系统的数据平台的公司(Phyware)参与了讨论,认为需要独立的数据验证,以建立利益相关者(如保险公司和运营商)之间的信任。
相关文章

原文

Yesterday, New York Governor Kathy Hochul withdrew her proposal to amend the state's vehicle and traffic laws, effectively shelving any near-term path for commercial robotaxi services outside New York City. The plan would have opened the door for companies like Waymo — which already provides over 400,000 paid rides per week across six US cities — to expand into the state. But legislative support simply wasn't there.

This isn't a story about technology that doesn't work. Waymo's robotaxis operate daily in Phoenix, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Austin, Atlanta, and Miami. The technology has arrived. What hasn't arrived is a way for regulators, legislators, and the public to independently verify that these systems are operating safely. And that's the gap that keeps killing proposals like this one.

The trust deficit

Look at the safeguards Hochul's proposal included: a $1 million application fee, $5 million in financial security, approval from the state transportation commissioner, and a ban on deployment in cities over a million people. These are reasonable guardrails. But they're all before-the-fact requirements — financial barriers and bureaucratic checkpoints. None of them answer the question legislators actually care about: what is this vehicle doing, moment to moment, on our roads?

Right now, the answer to that question lives inside the AV companies themselves. Operational data — sensor readings, AI decision-making, speed, routing, near-miss events — is captured by proprietary systems, stored on company servers, and shared at the company's discretion. Regulators are asked to trust, not verify. And as New York just demonstrated, that's not enough.

This isn't unique to robotaxis, either. Autonomous mobile robots are being deployed in warehouses, on university campuses, in hospitals, and across factory floors. The same trust deficit exists everywhere autonomous systems operate alongside people.

What we're building

PhyWare is a data platform for autonomous systems, and we're building it specifically to close this gap.

The core idea is straightforward: every autonomous system should have a verifiable record of what it did, when, and why — like a flight recorder for robots. We're starting with two products:

PhyTrace is a lightweight telemetry agent that captures comprehensive operational data directly from the robot — sensors, speed, location, AI reasoning, battery state, everything available — and streams it in real time. PhyCloud stores that data immutably with cryptographic provenance, meaning every data point is tamper-evident and traceable back to its source. No one — not the operator, not us — can alter the record after the fact.

Together, they create a trusted, independently verifiable audit trail for any autonomous system.

Back to New York

Imagine the conversation New York legislators could have had if every robotaxi ride generated a cryptographically signed, tamper-evident record of the vehicle's behavior — independently verifiable by any regulator, auditor, or safety agency. The debate shifts from "should we allow this?" to "here's the operational evidence — let's look at the data."

That's the world we're building toward. Not just for robotaxis, but for every autonomous system that operates in the physical world alongside people.

Follow along

PhyWare is in active development. If you're an operator, OEM, or integrator working with autonomous systems and the trust problem resonates, we'd love to hear from you.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com