最伟大的智力成就是什么? (2017)
What have been the greatest intellectual achievements? (2017)

原始链接: https://www.thinkingcomplete.com/2017/09/what-have-been-greatest-intellectual.html

这篇帖子发起了一场关于公众常常忽略的最具影响力的智识成就的讨论,克劳德·香农——信息论的创始人就是一个例子。作者想知道还有多少奠基性的思想仍然鲜为人知,尤其是在人文和社会科学领域。 他们整理了一份广泛的、按时间顺序排列的清单,涵盖了数学(泰勒斯、毕达哥拉斯、欧几里得)、历史(希罗多德、修昔底德)、哲学(苏格拉底、笛卡尔、康德、福柯、帕菲特)、科学(伽利略、牛顿、达尔文、爱因斯坦、居里)、经济学(斯密、马克思、科斯)等等——包括进化论、相对论和DNA结构等突破性进展。 作者积极寻求对这份清单的补充,尤其是在他们不太熟悉的领域,并询问对未来有影响的成就的预测,例如量子计算或预测神经科学。目标不是进行明确的排名,而是引发对话并突出人类智识进步的广度。已经有人提出了一些补充,显著扩展了原始清单。

一个黑客新闻的讨论询问了“最伟大的智力成就”。最初的帖子链接到一篇2017年关于该主题的文章。 评论很快就分歧了。一位用户认为现代信息论从根本上是有缺陷的,声称现实不是关于“状态”,而是“潜力”转化为状态——这与香农的最初意图相符。他们还暗示了对内在声音、不明飞行物和广泛接受的“真理”的非传统信念。 其他评论者争论分析哲学的起源,引用斯宾诺莎、弗雷格、罗素和维特根斯坦。有人承认许多公认的真理仅仅是约定俗成的信念(罗素和爱因斯坦)。 一些回复强调了像太空旅行和相对论这样的成就,而另一个人则指出使用树木来制作纸张和传递知识的简单而深刻的影响。有人指出原文中提到的“有效利他主义”已经过时。
相关文章

原文
In yesterday's post I briefly mentioned Claude Shannon, founder of information theory. It occurred to me that even most Oxford students wouldn't know who he was, despite his work being crucial for the subsequent development of the "Information Age". How many other intellectual revolutions in obscure fields haven't become common knowledge yet? Perhaps the best way of finding out is just to start listing the greatest and most influential intellectual achievements ever, and seeing if anyone else has more to add - particularly in the humanities and social sciences, where my knowledge is a little shallower. Also, is there anything you expect to deserve a place on this list in the next few years? I'm focusing on achievements which either founded or greatly influenced an entire field (also, although there are many amazing artistic and engineering achievements, to keep things relatively concise I'm not going to include either here). Of course this will be necessarily subjective and incomplete; the main point is not to have a definitive ranking but simply to spark some discussion - which it has. I've seen some very useful and thought-provoking comments both on Hacker News and my Facebook post. I've put a summary of the best additions at the end; here's my original list, ordered chronologically:
  • Thales and Pythagoras' origination of modern mathematics 
  • Herodotus and Thucydides' work as "fathers of history" 
  • Socratic method of philosophical inquiry 
  • Copernican revolution of Earth around Sun 
  • Galileo: father of astronomy and, arguably, science 
  • Descartes' launch of modern analytic philosophy 
  • Newton's mechanics and calculus 
  • John Locke's foundation of liberalism, developed more practically by French and American revolutionaries 
  • Adam Smith's foundation of modern economic theory 
  • Bentham and Mill's advocacy of utilitarianism 
  • The reconstruction of Proto-Indo-European, the common ancestor of the Indo-European languages 
  • Kant's attempted a priori derivations of knowledge and ethics 
  • Darwin's theory of evolution 
  • Germ theory, proposed by Fracastoro and proved by Snow, Pasteur and Koch 
  • Development of atomic and nuclear theory, notably by Dalton, Thomson, Rutherford, Curie, Bohr, Chadwick, Yukawa and Fermi 
  • Mendeleev's periodic table 
  • Modern medicine, pushed by Jenner's smallpox vaccine and Fleming's penicillin 
  • Frege and Cantor's inventions of modern logic and set theory, respectively, to solve the foundational crisis in mathematics 
  • Durkheim's establishment of the academic discipline of sociology 
  • Modernism across a variety of creative disciplines 
  • Einstein's special and general relativity 
  • Wegener's theory of plate tectonics 
  • Freud's identification of the subconscious 
  • Development of quantum physics in the first half of the 20th century, most notably by Planck, Einstein, Dirac, Schrodinger, Heisenberg, Born and Feynmann 
  • Probability theory: introduced by Pascal and Fermat; pioneered by Laplace; formalised by Kolmogorov; furthered by Jeffreys and Jaynes 
  • Big Bang cosmology, proposed by Lemaitre and confirmed by Hubble 
  • Population genetics: inspired by Mendel and founded by Fisher using novel statistical methods 
  • Godel's incompleteness proofs 
  • Turing/Church/Godel's models of computation, particularly Turing Machines 
  • Coase's theory of the firm 
  • Von Neumann's game theory 
  • Goddard's development of rocket science 
  • Shannon's information theory
  • Several waves of feminist philosophy, originating most notably with Simone de Beauvoir
  • Watson, Crick, Franklin and Wilkins' discovery of the structure of DNA 
  • Lewis and Chenery's structural-change theories of development economics 
  • The wider environmentalism movement, jumpstarted by Carson and others 
  • Said's foundational study of post-colonial culture 
  • Behavioural genetics, as founded by Galton and revived by Fuller and Thompson 
  • Kahnemann and Tversky's work on cognitive biases and System 1/System 2 processing 

A few areas which I think could get there, but that are still to show their full potential:
  • Predictive processing models of neuroscience 
  • "Happiness science" and cognitive behavioural therapy 
  • Quantum computing (although it's worth noting the early work of Shor and Grover)
  • Genetic engineering
  • Theories of statistical learning & knowledge representation
  • Environmental engineering
  • Agent foundations
  • Animal rights movements and effective altruism

And the most important things I originally missed:

  • Understanding of electricity due to Franklin, Volta, Faraday, Ohm, Edison, Tesla etc
  • Maxwell's theory of electromagnetism, which built on work by Orsted and Ampere
  • Norman Borlaug for the Green Revolution of massively increased food yields
  • Jevons, Menger and Walras for the “marginal revolution” in economics
  • The development of the field of Artificial Intelligence by McCarthy, Minsky, etc
  • The development of deep learning by Hinton, Bengio, LeCunn, Schmidhuber, etc
  • Euclid, for the axiomatic conception of mathematics
  • Chomsky’s revolutionary work in linguistics
  • The development of thermodynamics, particularly by Carnot, Maxwell and Boltzmann
  • Foucault on power dynamics in the construction of knowledge
  • Kuhn's theory of scientific revolutions
  • Marx's critiques of capitalism
  • Bacon's introduction of the scientific method
  • Parfit’s work on population ethics and personal identity
  • Babbage and Lovelace’s early development of computers
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com