MeshCore 开发团队因商标纠纷和 AI 生成代码而分裂。
MeshCore development team splits over trademark dispute and AI-generated code

原始链接: https://blog.meshcore.io/2026/04/23/the-split

MeshCore项目,一个快速增长的网状网络社区,自2025年1月以来已拥有超过38,000个节点和100,000+应用用户,正面临内部冲突。核心开发者安迪·柯比秘密利用人工智能(Claude Code)重建了MeshCore生态系统的许多部分——包括固件、应用程序和工具——并且现在在未告知团队的情况下申请了MeshCore商标。 这导致了分裂,最初的开发团队感到被背叛,并担心项目的完整性。在安迪控制了原始网站和Discord后,他们推出了meshcore.io作为官方信息来源。他甚至复制了新网站的外观和感觉。 剩余的核心团队——斯科特、利亚姆、Recrof、FDLamotte和Oltaco——致力于继续使用人工编写的代码进行开发,并通过他们的新网站和Discord服务器专注于透明度。他们强调,官方MeshCore位于GitHub仓库中,安迪尚未对此做出贡献。

黑客新闻 新的 | 过去的 | 评论 | 提问 | 展示 | 工作 | 提交 登录 MeshCore 开发团队因商标纠纷和 AI 生成代码而分裂 (meshcore.io) 10 分,wielebny 发表于 37 分钟前 | 隐藏 | 过去的 | 收藏 | 1 条评论 帮助 Trannosaur 4 分钟前 [–] 网状项目和这些极其严厉的商标执行者有什么关系?Meshtastic 也是如此。我开始对 MeshCore 感兴趣的主要原因之一是阅读了 Meshtastic 的商标规则,并发现它们……真的非常过分。回复 考虑申请 YC 2026 年夏季项目!申请截止至 5 月 4 日 指南 | 常见问题 | 列表 | API | 安全 | 法律 | 申请 YC | 联系 搜索:
相关文章

原文

Since inception, the MeshCore development team have been working hard to build MeshCore.

We’ve released more than 85 versions of the MeshCore Companion, Repeater and Room Server firmwares with support for more than 75 hardware variants. All of this has been hand crafted, by humans.

We have always been wary of AI generated code, but felt everyone is free to do what they want and experiment, etc. But, one of our own, Andy Kirby, decided to branch out and extensively use Claude Code, and has decided to aggressively take over all of the components of the MeshCore ecosystem: standalone devices, mobile app, web flasher and web config tools.

And, he’s kept that small detail a secret - that it’s all majority vibe coded.

We ran a poll recently, and asked in the MeshCore Discord about AI and trust, and these are the results:

The team didn’t feel it was our place to protest, until we recently discovered that Andy applied for the MeshCore Trademark (on the 29th March, according to filings) and didn’t tell any of us. We have tried discussing this, and what his intentions are, but those broke down and we now have no communication with Andy.

It’s been a stressful few months trying to sort this out, and is now a sad day to bring this out to the public. It’s been a slap in the face to the team that have worked so hard on this project, to have an insider team up with a robot and a lawyer.

“Official” MeshCore

The use of the ‘official’ status is what is currently being contested. Andy is adamant that he owns the brand, and is using the word very heavily with his MeshOS line.

Meanwhile, in reality, the only ‘official’ MeshCore is the github repo. It’s the source of truth in terms of what is MeshCore, and Andy has never contributed to that.

Since the internal split, we launched the meshcore.io site, as Andy controls the meshcore.co.uk site and original discord server. We’ve been left with little other recourse. And, since launching the site, Andy copied the look and feel (again, using Claude) even though we asked him not to.

Project Growth

The MeshCore project has been on an incredible journey.

Having only started in January 2025, we have grown extremely fast!

As of this post, the official MeshCore Map shows 38,000+ nodes around the world, and the official MeshCore App has more than 100,000+ active users across Android and iOS.

It’s pretty epic how we’ve all built such an incredible community in such as a short time!

As the project grows, so does our need for a dedicated space that provides you with official information from the core team.

In recent times, we’ve seen an explosion of growth in MeshCore web sites dedicated to specific countries and mesh communities.

To name a few, we’ve seen:

Andy Kirby did do an amazing job helping to promote the MeshCore project on his personal YouTube, but only promotes his own products now.

Where To From Here?

So, the core team are pushing ahead with the meshcore.io website, the ongoing work of firmware feature development, bug fixes, managing PR’s and developer discussions, etc.

We now release change logs, blog posts and technical documentation for all of our new firmware and app releases here.

You’ll also find some familiar faces on our blog posts, such as:

  • Scott our project founder, lead firmware engineer and developer of the Ripple firmware!
  • Recrof our official MeshCore Map developer and Firmware Flasher guru. He has shared some insights into the early development of the MeshCore Map.
  • Liam Cottle the official MeshCore App developer who will be posting useful guides for getting started with the MeshCore App.
  • FDLamotte who has done epic work on the Python tooling for MeshCore, as well as the STM32 firmware variants.
  • Oltaco (Che Aporeps) who has done amazing work on the new OTA Fix bootloader that makes firmware updates much more reliable.

The Core Team

The MeshCore team, now consisting of Scott, Liam, Recrof, FDLamotte and now Oltaco remain committed to designing and developing high quality, human-written software.

Our New Home

Please update your bookmarks!

This is where we will be hosting all official releases, technical documentation, and community discussions moving forward.

With the new website, we are also starting fresh with a new Discord server!

This is where you can interact directly with the MeshCore developers, get help with your projects, and contribute to the future of MeshCore.

Thanks for being a part of this journey!

The MeshCore Team

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com