业余研究者可能破解了困扰学术界 120 年的线形文字 A
Amateur may have cracked Linear A, a 120-year-old puzzle

原始链接: https://aiclambake.com/clamtakes/linear-a/

自学成才的AI工程师汤姆·迪米诺(Tom Di Mino)声称已经破译了线性文字A(Linear A)。这种神秘的青铜时代米诺斯文字曾令语言学家困惑了一个多世纪。通过利用Claude AI分析祈祷铭文中反复出现的模式,迪米诺发现线性文字A与一种已灭绝的闪米特语之间存在关联,并暗示其可能是圣经希伯来语的前身。 迪米诺的方法论核心在于破译该文字独特的符号(包括13个在已破译的线性文字B中未发现的符号),将其映射到闪米特语的三辅音词根上。他的研究成果包括一份包含383个词汇的词库,以及对线性文字A和此前未识别的线性文字B符号的全新解读。 虽然迪米诺并非首位提出线性文字A具有闪米特语起源的学者,但他声称自己系统性的方法和具体的翻译在过去的研究失败之处取得了突破。他的研究成果目前正在接受罗格斯大学和剑桥大学专家的评审。如果得到证实,这一发现将成为语言学领域的一个重要里程碑,并可能验证AI在破解古代未破译文字系统方面的应用价值。

一位名叫汤姆的业余研究员兼人工智能工程师声称,他在解读有着120年历史、至今未被破解的线形文字A(Linear A)方面取得了重大突破。与以往许多未经证实的说法不同,据报道,这项工作目前正在接受罗格斯大学和剑桥大学语言学专家的评审。 该研究员利用 Claude Code 对该文字进行了分析,成功翻译了300多个单词,并据称解决了线形文字B(Linear B)中长期存在的不一致之处。尽管这些成果在黑客新闻(Hacker News)上引发了关注,但一些社区成员仍持怀疑态度,指出目前尚未有公开的、经过同行评审的论文。批评者认为,在方法论和研究结果接受正式审查之前,这一突破的有效性仍未得到验证。
相关文章

原文

Tom Di Mino, a self-taught AI engineer and an amateur linguist, claims to have accomplished a feat that has eluded linguistics experts for over a century: deciphering a Bronze-age Minoan writing system known as Linear A.

His claims are currently being reviewed by linguistics experts at Rutgers and Cambridge. While I’m caveating, I will also mention that I know Tom socially.

Di Mino, who is based in the Hudson Valley, began to work on the problem in January this year, and says the major insight came to him on May 22.

If Tom Di Mino has deciphered Linear A, it would be an earthquake in the field of linguistics. When a related Minoan script, Linear B, was deciphered in 1952, it made the front page of the New York Times.

Linear A maps to an extinct Semitic language

Di Mino believes that Linear A belongs to an extinct Semitic language that was a precursor to biblical Hebrew, the way that Latin is a precursor to Italian.

Di Mino is not the first to argue that Linear A was Semitic. Prior attempts to prove it, however, including a 1957 article published by Cyrus Gordon in the journal Antiquity, did not unlock translations the way that Di Mino’s solution appears to, and Gordon’s work did not gain widespread acceptance in the field.

Some background on Linear A and Linear B

Linear A is a Minoan script that appeared sometime around 1800 BC and was used until 1450 BC, when Crete was conquered by Mycenaean Greeks. The Mycenaeans adopted the Minoan symbols as their own, with some minor revisions. The Mycenaean-Greek version of the symbols are known as Linear B. Both scripts were found on various tablets, vases, and other artifacts from the era.

Both scripts use syllables, not letters, as their core elements. The syllables are generally consonant-vowel pairs.

The two systems have 60 core syllables in common, and they both also use logograms – symbols that represent a whole word (“cow”), not just a syllable.

Linear B was deciphered and identified as Greek in 1952 by Michael Ventris, a British architect, cryptographer, and amateur linguist, like Di Mino. Ventris’s breakthrough may not have happened without prior work on Linear B by Alice Kober, a professor at Brooklyn College.

Kober and Ventris used grammatical and statistical analyses to look for patterns in the location of the symbols (e.g. the first syllable was more likely to be a vowel) and how the symbols shifted.

There are many more inscriptions associated with Linear B than Linear A, however, which made it easier to decipher. Also, many Linear A inscriptions are inventories cataloging the trade of different commodities, so they don’t tell us much about the language.

Because Linear A and Linear B have 60 symbols in common, and because Linear B has been deciphered, experts could guess what the overlapping Linear A symbols sounded like but didn’t know what the sounds meant. And there were 13 additional symbols in Linear A that did not appear in Linear B. For those, no sound values have been accepted.

The key that unlocked Linear A

  • On May 22, Di Mino was analyzing a series of Linear A prayer inscriptions that adhered to a formula. (Don’t worry, you don’t have to understand the formula, but I’m including it for the nerds.)

    IOZa2 (Iouktas): A-TA-I-*301-WA-JA · JA-DI-KI-TU · JA-SA-SA-RA-ME · U-NA-KA-NA-SI · I-PI-NA-MA · SI-RU-TE · TA-NA-RA-TE-U-TI-NU · I

    (Also see Figure 1 below.)

  • In the formula all of the words in each line of the inscription were known (based on their overlap with Linear B syllables) except for the first word.

  • The first word was the same verb, but with different conjugations.

  • The verb contained 5 known Linear B signs and “*301”, which appeared to be a Linear A-only sign, “na,” which Di Mino used to unlock the root “nawaya,” which means “to dwell.” In Hebrew, Akkadian and other Semitic languages there is a 3 syllable consonant system. N-W-Y is used for verbs and nouns meaning “to dwell or build a pasture”.

  • Once deciphered, Di Mino saw that the prayer was similar to subsequent Hebrew prayers but was addressed to a Goddess.

  • While Cyrus Gordon had previously proposed links between dedication tablets in Linear A and similar tablets in Akkadian and Phoenician that he had translated, Di Mino claims to be the first person to identify the links between the Linear A inscriptions and Hebrew prayers.

  • This insight not only unlocked the verb in the prayer inscriptions, but it may also shed a broader light on the use of logograms in Linear A.

  • Di Mino claims that his insights into logograms in Linear A additionally help to resolve problems with some translations of Linear B, which validates his findings.

  • Di Mino used Claude Code to build an engine and methodology to systematically organize and categorize symbols, and to test hypotheses. He believes that he might not have been able to do the work without Claude and thinks the techniques he used may unlock other undeciphered writing systems.

Artifacts

Di Mino’s research has led to:

  • Proposed readings for 37 of the script’s 102 signs, including all 13 symbols unique to Linear A that have no counterpart in Linear B. He also resolved the sound values for 3 Linear B signs which were unknown to this day.

  • A lexicon of 383 Linear A terms translated into English

  • A 9-page draft of a manuscript titled Ya Diktu: Grammar of the Minoan Peak Sanctuary Libation Formula, which may form the foundation for a submission to a peer-reviewed scientific journal

A summary of the symbols in line 1 of the Minoan prayer inscription.

Figure 1. A summary of the symbols in line 1 of the Minoan prayer inscription. Credit: Tom Di Mino, Ya Diktu: Grammar of the Minoan Peak Sanctuary, June 2026.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com