创意之终结
The End of Creativity

原始链接: https://hugodaniel.com/posts/the-end-of-creativity/

在最近的一场婚礼上,作者观察到一个引人注目的现象:两组互不相识的人各自利用人工智能制作了致敬视频,结果成品几乎如出一辙。尽管主题不同,但两段视频都采用了相同的“国家地理”式叙事风格、一致的旁白语调,以及森林和星空等千篇一律的库存素材。 虽然观众起初觉得有趣,但作者认为这种诡异的相似性反映了一个更广泛的问题:“日常创造力”正在剧烈地趋于平庸。对生成式人工智能工具的普遍依赖,似乎正在使人类的表达方式变得同质化。作者质疑这种趋势背后的动机——是源于对失败的恐惧、智力上的懒惰,还是我们对待创造性任务的方式发生了更深层次的转变?最终,这篇文章发出了警示:尽管人工智能让内容创作变得更简单,但它也冒着磨平人类创造力中那种独特、不可预测本质的风险。

这段 Hacker News 讨论探讨了人工智能生成内容与真实人类创造力之间的张力。参与者的共识是,在婚礼礼物或致辞等需要表达个人心意的场合依赖 AI,往往被视为缺乏诚意、懒惰,甚至是失礼。用户认为,此类作品缺乏人类的意图,给人的感觉更像是空洞的批量生产商品,而非有意义的礼物。 虽然一些评论者认为 AI 的新鲜感终将褪去,并引发社会反弹,使“纯手工”成为真正价值的标志,但另一些人则认为,AI 只是反映了现有趋于平庸的社会风气。少数观点认为,AI 工具让业余爱好者无需经历艰苦的专业训练也能参与创作,并获得乐趣,而不必追求专业技能。归根结底,这篇讨论反映了一种日益增长的焦虑:在一个充斥着“AI 垃圾内容”的世界里,尽管人类深思熟虑的原创作品在海量信息中变得愈发难以辨别,但其价值反而会随之提升。
相关文章

原文

A story on AI median regression

This past weekend I went to a wedding and something (extra)ordinary happened that I cannot stop thinking about, up to the point of having to write it down in this post.

The bride is an old school friend of our group, so we decided to make a video of her, the traditional wedding video with photos of her. The person of our group that championed it used AI for the script/narrative, the audio and the cutscenes. Our focus was to make a video of three special gifts we decided to offer them.

Our video played, they laughed, they cried, and enjoyed it.

A short moment after that came another video, this time from the groom group of friends which we did not knew or had any contact with.

Their video was focused on the love story that culminated in the wedding. They also used AI for it, the script/narrative, the cutscenes, the audio, etc...

Now the thing

Both videos were the same

Two videos, with different stories, shared so many similarities that most people thought they were roughly the same.

Same similar tone of voiceover with cadence. Same cutscenes of flying over empty beaches, and navigating forest trees and stars/universe, and same narrative: after years of evolution scientists have yet to discover the power of such love with a national geographic tone in both (one of the videos even started with that logo).

People loved them

Everyone was super excited, it was like the euromillions/lottery struck down on the event with such a random casuality. "If we had decided to make the same both videos they wouldn't turn out to be so similar to each other!".

Conclusion

Everyday creativity is aggressively regressing to a mean. What is driving us towards these tools? is it fear of making something bad? or just slack? or something else im not quite sure?


联系我们 contact @ memedata.com