汽车行业对“是否配备 CarPlay”的车型进行了 A/B 测试。
The car industry A/B tested selling a car with and without CarPlay

原始链接: https://a.wholelottanothing.org/the-car-industry-a-b-tested-selling-the-same-car-with-and-without-carplay-and-the-results-are-not-shocking/

通用汽车因出于隐私考量,决定在旗下车型中取消 Apple CarPlay 和 Android Auto,转而采用自家的 Android Automotive OS,此举引发了广泛争议。尽管通用汽车坚称这是正确的方向,但消费者对失去熟悉的手机互联功能反应负面。 本田发布的 Prologue 电动汽车提供了一个天然的对比实验,该车型实质上是雪佛兰 Blazer EV 的换标版本。尽管两款车在性能和机械结构上完全相同,但本田支持 Apple CarPlay 和 Android Auto,而雪佛兰则不支持。 销售数据揭示了市场对本田的显著偏好。自两款车型发布以来,本田 Prologue 的销量持续大幅领先于 Blazer EV,到 2026 年上半年,其销量已高出 165%。这些数据表明,消费者优先考虑无缝的智能手机集成,并正在主动选择提供该功能的车型。驾驶者通过“用钱包投票”,向通用汽车传达了一个明确的信息:便利性和手机连接性是影响购买决策的首要因素。通用汽车是否会正视这些市场趋势并重新审视其限制性的软件策略,仍有待观察。

一场 Hacker News 上的讨论对近期一项关于 Apple CarPlay 价值的汽车对比测评提出了质疑,认为其不能作为有效的“A/B 测试”。尽管原文暗示 CarPlay 的有无是销量增长的主要驱动力,但评论者认为,由于存在大量无法控制的变量,该比较存在缺陷。 争议的核心观点包括: * **定价与促销:** 批评者指出,特定车型的高额折扣(高达 2 万美元)会独立于功能之外影响销售数据。 * **品牌认知:** 用户指出,传统品牌忠诚度及品牌在制造质量上的历史声誉(特别是本田与本土制造商的对比)在消费者偏好中发挥了重要作用。 * **行业动态:** 一些观点认为,制造商之所以与 CarPlay 拉开距离,是因为苹果对敏感遥测数据和 CAN 总线数据的需求日益增加。 * **用户体验痛点:** 讨论还强调了人们对现代汽车“创新”普遍不满,特别是转向那种充满 Bug、容易分心且强迫驾驶员视线离开路面的触控界面。 归根结底,参与者认为,将销量差异完全归因于软件功能,忽视了定价、品牌信任和用户界面偏好之间复杂的相互影响。
相关文章

原文
cars · August 20, 2026 · 3 min read

A couple years ago, GM made waves by saying that soon, all their new cars would be completely free of Apple's CarPlay and Android Auto support, instead opting for the "Android Automotive OS" in their cars.

Admittedly, I'm a huge fan of CarPlay for basic safety reasons and how it lets you hear or send texts without ever having to look at or touch your phone, so I was not happy to hear this news. I remember when this was first announced for Chevy EVs and when it was later expanded to all their cars in the future and the resounding response was that car buyers were PISSED.

Chevy claimed they were doing this for privacy reasons, that none of your driving or phone data would go to Apple any longer, but instead it would all go to Google (who would likely share it with General Motors, the owners of Chevy).

Chevy seemed to ignore the uproar from their fans and went ahead with it anyway, and as far as I can tell, all 2025 Chevy electric vehicles shipped with the Android Auto OS and don't interface with your phone beyond bluetooth or let you see CarPlay or AndroidAuto apps on your dash.

The Honda Prologue EV

The accidental A/B test

Honda, much like Toyota and Subaru, didn't have a robust EV research and development program and kind of lagged behind their rival auto companies on selling EVs, so they partnered with other auto brands to rebadge, rebrand, and resell versions of cars made by other companies.

One case in point is the Honda Prologue EV. It's a partnership between Honda and Chevrolet, where the Prologue is basically a Chevy Blazer EV with Honda badges, slight visual differences in the sheetmetal and interior, but all the underpinnings are straight up Chevy. Even though the keys say Honda on a Prologue, it's a General Motors key design with a Honda logo over it.

But one big difference the Prologue has from the Blazer it is based on is this: it includes Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration.

The car industry accidentally did something I've always wanted to see, which was to release basically the same car under two brands and models, with one major consumer-facing difference. It's kind of remarkable how good of a experimental design this is, since the performance and driving characteristics of both cars are identical, but drivers in one model get a major phone integration the others do not.

So how did that work out for Chevy?

You can look up actual sales numbers in GM and Honda's annual reports of sales they're required to publish to investors, and here are the results for the last 2.5 years they've both been sold in the US:

U.S. Sales: Chevrolet Blazer EV vs. Honda Prologue
Period Chevrolet Blazer EV Honda Prologue Combined Honda Advantage
2024 full year 23,115 33,017 56,132 9,902 more (42.8%)
2025 full year 22,637 39,194 61,831 16,557 more (73.1%)
2026 January–June 3,166 8,407 11,573 5,241 more (165.5%)

Note: The 2026 figures cover January through June and are not full-year totals.

The last column on the right is the most telling. For the years these cars were sold together, the Honda outsold the Blazer by 43%, 73%, and 166% in each time period. Today in 2026, people are buying a Honda Prologue over one and a half times more often than the Chevy Blazer EV the Prologue is based on.

Of the total number of EV sales between the two brands, here's a graph of how many sold were Hondas (orange) and how many were Chevys (blue):

Give consumers a choice, and they'll take the best option

Drivers want more options for how they interact with their devices, and they are increasingly preferring to buy a Chevy covered in Honda badges that comes with phone integrations instead of buying the actual Chevy the Honda is based on, which lacks it.

I wonder if Chevy will ever backpedal from their choice to remove CarPlay and Android Auto? Drivers seem to be voting with their dollars on the question, and they're voting favorably in one direction on this issue.

Now that the market has spoken loud and clear, will General Motors listen?

(This post inspired by a toot my pal Pat wrote months ago that made me want to look up the latest sales figures today)

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com