格陵兰岛冰盖今年有所增长
Greenland's Icecap Grew This Year

原始链接: https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/greenlands-icecap-grew-year

保罗·霍姆伍德(Paul Homewood)在《每日怀疑论者》(The Daily Sceptic)上撰文称,有关格陵兰岛冰层快速融化的报道被夸大了,且缺乏历史背景。尽管欧盟的《2025年欧洲气候状况报告》强调了冰层的大幅流失,但霍姆伍德认为,当前的融化是始于1900年左右的长期自然周期的一部分,并指出1920年至1970年间的冰层流失水平与近期观察到的情况相当。 他强调,格陵兰岛在19世纪经历了极端严寒,而在罗马和中世纪等温暖时期,冰盖在历史上曾更小。此外,霍姆伍德指出,最新数据显示融化趋势正在放缓,2025/26年度冰层质量甚至出现了轻微增长。他还对数据的可靠性提出质疑,指出由于冰层流失是通过计算机模型而非直接测量计算得出的,其误差范围可达1000亿吨(Gt)。最终,他认为有关“惊人且前所未有的崩溃”的说法具有误导性,从地质历史的角度来看,该冰盖依然稳固。

相关文章

原文

Authored by Paul Homewood via The Daily Sceptic,

Greenland's icecap is melting away thanks to global warming, at least that is what we are told. According to the EU's European State of the Climate 2025 Report, the ice sheet lost 139 Gt last year. They say that is equivalent to about 1.5 times the amount of ice stored in all the glaciers in the European Alps, and raised global mean sea level by 0.4 mm. (A gigatonne is one billion tonnes.) Since 1972, losses have amounted to 5,747 Gt. The rate of ice loss has increased by around five times since the 1980s and is expected to continue increasing beyond the end of the century.

These amounts sound terrifying, which is of course the object of the exercise - at least until you realise that at present rates it would take Greenland 27,000 years to melt away.

I am always suspicious when 'scientists' present trends since the 1970s, a time when the Earth had gone through three decades of cooling and there were genuine fears among both scientists and world leaders about the return of the Little Ice Age. I am even more suspicious when I discover that official data about the Greenland ice sheet is publicly available back to 1840.

In 2021, a peer-reviewed study calculated the annual changes in the ice sheet mass balance since 1840. (The heavy black line represents the net changes, which is of relevance to this discussion):

The graph confirms that the ice sheet has been losing mass since the 1980s. But crucially, we can see that the melting began around 1900. During the period 1920 to 1970, ice loss was running at similar levels to the last three decades - this is hardly surprising, as temperature records across Greenland show that it was just as 'warm' then as now. In between times, there was a sharp decline in temperatures in the 1970s and 80s.

In other words, this is not a new phenomenon, as we are expected to believe. It is part of a much longer process, which began long before so-called man-made global warming began.

Scientists have long established, with the help of ice cores and other evidence, that the 19th Century was probably the coldest era in Greenland since the Ice Age. During warm eras, such as the Middle Ages, Roman times and earlier millennia, the ice cap was smaller than it is now. Any reduction in the ice cap in the last century must be viewed as part of these longer-term cycles.

Ice mass data is still regularly published and provisional data is now available for the year ending August 2026 - Greenland ice data is normally presented by "hydro-year", September to August.

Since the 2021 study, ice loss has continued to slow down and is back to 1920s levels. The 2025/26 season actually saw a small increase of 6 Gt in ice mass. Greenland never really had a summer this year. Whereas the summer melt usually begins in early June, cold, snowy weather persisted well into July. As a result, summer melt was around 200 Gt less than normal.

It is worth noting that the poor summer in Greenland was part of the wider jet stream setup, which brought our hot summer. While we had a summer dominated by high-pressure systems, the rainy weather stayed out in the Atlantic, battering Greenland.

6 Gt is of course a tiny amount, given the massive uncertainty in how these things are calculated. There is no way to directly measure ice cap changes; instead, the numbers are calculated from computer models fed with data such as precipitation and temperature. The experts accept that they can often be wrong by as much as 100 Gt.

Nevertheless, it is abundantly clear that Greenland's icecap is doing just fine. It is still much larger than it has been for most of the last 10,000 years and, if it is shrinking at all, it is doing so no faster than a century ago.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com