我厌倦了人工智能的语气。
I'm Tired of the AI Tone

原始链接: https://sagivo.com/blog/im-tired-of-the-ai-tone

作者批评了互联网上日益泛滥的一种通用的“AI 生成”写作风格。这种语调——以过多的破折号、诸如“切入点(wedge)”和“解锁(unlock)”之类的企业流行语,以及绝对对称、可预测的结构为特征——虽然看起来精致,却空洞无物。 尽管人工智能是提升清晰度的强大工具,但作者认为,它对技术完美的追求抹去了定义人类表达的怪癖、不连贯和凌乱的脆弱感。通过对中立、“通用”语气的优化,我们正趋向于一种乏味、千篇一律且缺乏个性的交流方式。 作者并未建议放弃人工智能,而是主张将其作为起点,然后在写作中夺回主导权。要在自动化内容的时代脱颖而出,我们必须剥离机械的人造感,剔除企业黑话,并重新注入独特的个人声音。归根结底,这篇文章提醒我们:随着机器听起来越来越聪明,真正的竞争优势——以及优秀写作的标志——在于展现出人性。

最近 Hacker News 上的一篇讨论《我厌倦了 AI 的语调》引发了广泛共鸣,人们对现代 AI 模型那重复、充满“营销味”的风格感到沮丧。参与者认为,目前的 AI 输出充斥着企业行话、过度的专业术语,以及一种阿谀奉承的“科技男”式交流口吻。 讨论者提出了造成这种现象的几个原因: * **训练与人类反馈强化学习(RLHF):** 用户认为,通过人类反馈进行的强化学习使模型过度拟合,从而模仿了硅谷工程师和营销文案的特定沟通风格。 * **默认行为:** 由于大多数用户会直接接受 AI 给出的第一条回复,“默认”的 AI 个性已成为了互联网上的标准。 为了改善这一点,用户建议通过严格的提示词(Prompt)来“驯服”模型。一个热门建议是要求 AI 使用“简化技术英语”(ASD-STE100)——该标准优先考虑简短、直接的句子,使用主动语态,并剔除冗余词汇。其他人则指出,通过明确要求不同的写作风格或角色设定,用户可以迫使 AI 跳出其平庸的企业腔调。总之,人们的共识是:虽然默认的“机器感”语调很普遍,但这并非底层技术的固有缺陷。
相关文章

原文

I'm tired of the AI tone.

Not AI writing itself. AI is incredibly useful. I've probably used ChatGPT more this week than I'd like to admit.

I'm talking about the weird, increasingly recognizable way everything on the internet now sounds like it was written by the same extremely articulate 27-year-old who has never had a bad day.

You know the tone.

Everything is a wedge.

Every idea is not just X, but Y.

Every paragraph contains an em dash — like this — because apparently the comma has been deprecated.

Everything is "a powerful shift."

Something doesn't just solve a problem. It "unlocks a new way to think about the problem."

A product isn't useful. It "sits at the intersection of X and Y."

A company doesn't build something. It "reimagines how we..."

And every post somehow ends with:

The future is already here.

Thanks, Claude.

The AI vocabulary

There are certain words that have become suspicious.

"Wedge" is probably the biggest one.

Every startup now has a wedge.

"We're starting with X as our wedge into Y."

Nobody talks like this in real life.

I've been in startups for a long time. I've sat in hundreds of product meetings. I've talked to founders, engineers, customers, and investors.

I have almost never heard someone say:

«"This is our wedge."»

But put the same person in front of ChatGPT and suddenly they're building a "land-and-expand wedge into the enterprise."

Other suspicious words include:

  • unlock
  • leverage
  • ecosystem
  • paradigm
  • transformative
  • seamless
  • robust
  • thoughtfully
  • empower
  • foster
  • nuanced
  • landscape
  • intersection
  • fundamentally
  • increasingly
  • reimagine
  • accelerate
  • journey

None of these words are bad.

That's what makes it worse.

They're perfectly normal words that AI has managed to make feel like corporate spam.

And then there are the em dashes

Why are there so many fucking em dashes?

Seriously.

AI loves an em dash.

It uses them to connect thoughts that a normal human would separate into two sentences.

Or a comma.

Or just leave disconnected because humans don't actually write with perfect transitions all the time.

AI writing has this strange obsession with making every sentence flow beautifully into the next one.

Real people don't do that.

Sometimes we start a sentence badly.

Sometimes we use parentheses.

Sometimes we repeat ourselves.

Sometimes we say "and" four times.

Sometimes we write:

«"I don't know. Maybe I'm wrong."»

And move on.

That's writing.

The perfect structure

AI also loves structure.

You can usually recognize an AI-generated post from about 50 feet away.

It starts with a provocative sentence.

Then:

Here's the thing:

Then three or five perfectly balanced points.

Then a counterargument.

Then a thoughtful conclusion.

Then a sentence about how "this isn't about X. It's about Y."

Then the inspirational ending.

It's like every LinkedIn post has gone through the same screenwriting course.

And God forbid you make a list.

AI will give you exactly five bullets.

Not four.

Not six.

Five.

Because five feels comprehensive.

The fake vulnerability

My favorite is the AI version of vulnerability.

"I used to think X.

I was wrong.

After spending years working on Y, I've come to realize Z."

That's not how people talk.

That's how a machine imagines someone talks after analyzing 40,000 LinkedIn posts.

Real vulnerability is messier.

"I completely screwed this up."

"I thought this was going to work. It didn't."

"I don't really know what I'm doing here."

"I changed my mind."

"I have no idea if this is right."

Those sentences are interesting because they're actually human.

The problem isn't that AI writes well

Ironically, the writing is often technically better.

That's the problem.

AI removes all the little imperfections that tell you a human wrote something.

The weird phrasing.

The unnecessary joke.

The sentence that goes on too long.

The opinion that doesn't quite fit the rest of the argument.

The typo.

The "I don't know how to explain this, but..."

Those things give writing a personality.

AI optimizes them away.

And when everyone uses the same model, everyone optimizes toward the same mean.

We are slowly converging on one universal Internet Voice™.

Polite.

Clear.

Structured.

Nuanced.

Optimistic.

Slightly corporate.

Occasionally profound.

And completely fucking interchangeable.

Please sound like yourself

I'm not arguing that we should stop using AI to write.

Quite the opposite.

Use it.

Have it rewrite your terrible first draft.

Have it fix your grammar.

Have it make your argument clearer.

Have it turn your 2,000-word ramble into something people can actually read.

But then put some of yourself back into it.

Delete the em dashes.

Remove "unlock."

Kill the "not X, but Y."

Delete "wedge" unless you are actually talking about a wedge.

Say what you mean.

Use shorter sentences.

Have an opinion.

Be slightly weird.

Don't make every paragraph perfectly symmetrical.

And for the love of God, occasionally write a sentence that sounds like something you would actually say out loud.

AI is getting incredibly good at sounding intelligent.

The competitive advantage now might be sounding human.

Post draft is ready, do you want me to make it shorter?

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com