电网停电期间的双向充电
Bidirectional Charging During Grid Outages

原始链接: https://www.jefftk.com/p/bidirectional-charging-during-grid-outages

作者认为,利用电动车电池在停电时为家庭供电将是理想选择,但目前的V2H(车辆到家庭)方案大多只能放电,无法在离网状态下为汽车充电。通用、福特以及起亚/Wallbox系统存在局限性或供应问题,福特所需的硬件已停产。特斯拉PowerShare配合Cybertruck似乎是目前唯一支持停电期间太阳能充电的选项,但成本高昂且不想要。Enphase的双向充电器预计要到2026年底或更晚才会推出,且依赖汽车制造商的支持。由于作者希望尽快获得备用电源,且其家庭可能不适合纯电动车,他们计划安装一个仅用于应急的小型电池。他们提到目前并不拥有电动车;旧款本田Fit可能会被插电混动车或电动车取代,但有限的驾驶里程使得纯电动车的优势并不明显。

Hacker News 的讨论帖讨论了电网停电时的双向充电。一位评论者指出,Tesla 已将 PowerShare 扩展到近期的 Model Y 和其他车型,但太阳能再充电仍不确定。另一位认为电池在严重、持续多日的停电中不切实际:便携式设备只能维持数小时,而飓风后为大型暖通空调供电需要巨大且昂贵的储能;配备自动转换开关的丙烷发电机则便宜得多且更易维护。第三位评论者提出电池充放电循环衰减的问题,以及家用电池更换是否比电动汽车电池更便宜,询问长期经济性。总体而言,讨论对比了电动汽车和家用电池备份与传统发电机,在长时间、高负载停电中更青睐发电机,同时也指出电池系统持续改进。
相关文章

原文
David asked a great question on my solar battery system post: why buy a small battery just for emergencies when electric cars have a large battery you can also use for other things? [1] This would be great, and seems like the obvious way for it to work: when the grid goes down the panels can charge the car when it's sunny, and the car can power the house when it's not. Unfortunately as far as I can tell the only way I could do this today is with a Cybertruck, and other systems are a long way off.

The basic problem is that while several manufacturers support having the car power your house when the grid is down ("V2H"), they generally treat it as a separate discharging-only mode. For example, the GM V2H Bundle documentation says "During a power outage, the GM Energy Home Hub safely disconnects your home from the local power grid and enables backup power to flow from the GM Energy Inverter throughout your home" and "Once power is restored, your GM EV will automatically end the discharge session and begin charging" without any mention of recharging the car when the grid is down.

For Fords, automatically powering your house during a grid outage was a big selling point in the F150 Lightning marketing campaign, but they now say "The Ford Charge Station Pro, required for Automatic Home Backup Power, is no longer for sale", probably because the F150 Lightning has been discontinued. And it looks to me like even then they didn't support bidirectional charging during a grid outage. The only option today is V2H via a transfer switch, which doesn't let you charge an F150.

For Kia, there's Wallbox's Quasar 2. Unfortunately this is a mess where Wallbox is very enthusiastic and says V2H works, but then customers run into trouble actually trying to use it. And it doesn't work with current models, plus "Solar Charging cannot be used simultaneously with ... V2H".

The only way I can see to do this today is with Tesla Powershare + Cybertruck, which says "If the system includes a UL 1741-listed solar system and there is capacity in the backup panel, ensure the solar system is included in the backup circuit to allow Cybertruck to recharge during an outage." But I don't want a Cybertruck, and (counting the cost of a Cybertruck over a vehicle we'd normally buy) this would be way more expensive than the Enphase 10C I'm considering installing.

Another possibility is that Enphase is planning on shipping a bidirectional EV charger, but I don't see anything more recent than a 2026-02-02 announcement that they're "targeting volume production beginning in Q4 2026" and they say "projected vehicle compatibility and bidirectional functionality will depend on automaker enablement, vehicle software, applicable standards, and final product specifications." I suspect it will slip into 2027, MA availability will be even later, and when it does come out I'd need to buy a specific new EV (expensive).

I don't want to wait that long to get good backup power in place, since I want to be prepared for a world that might change quickly in the next few years. So I'll probably go ahead with the smaller emergencies-only battery.


[1] All of this assumes we have an electric car. Which we don't, but our shared Honda Fit is a 2013 and while it's been a fantastic car I don't expect it to last that much longer. A plug-in hybrid or full EV are possibilities for a next car. I think our families are unusually poorly suited for full EVs since we don't use the car much (minimal gas savings and pollution reduction) and a larger than typical proportion of our trips are long (ex: driving to play a dance).

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com