This is a note for Assembling Desire. I will be using AI heavily for newsletters that are part of this project. More on AI Use Policy.
The discourse around taste has focused on how people develop the right intuitions and tacit skills within a particular field, but often leaves unexplained where new desires—and the fields surrounding them—come from. How, for example, did people in early modern Europe develop a desire for coffee? Imagine encountering an unfamiliar, bitter drink and learning how to prepare it, what to serve alongside it, and when its stimulation might be welcome. Wanting coffee would gradually become wanting a particular preparation, a morning ritual, or an occasion to sit and talk. How did these possibilities become legible as things worth wanting?
My explanation is that new desires develop through consumer specialization, as consumers acquire increasingly finer consumption skills and open markets to experimentation. I wrote about an example of this in the development of the market for tractors in the 1910s, where farmers experimenting with plough kits that they could attach to their Model Ts played a role in developing the market for the Ford tractor, which was iterated alongside these experiments as a specialized product.
In modern economics, specialized information is often treated as something asymmetrically available to sellers, forming part of their competitive offering. Specialization can be a form of non-price competition, allowing sellers to distinguish their offerings beyond price alone.
In the 1970s and 1980s, economist Tibor Scitovsky examined the relationship between specialization and consumer markets. In “The Benefits of Asymmetric Markets,” he argues that sellers specialize in a category while buyers must divide their attention among many. A retailer knows their products, suppliers, costs, and alternatives in a depth most customers cannot reasonably match. This asymmetry gives the seller power, but competition can also encourage the seller to put their expertise to useful work: selecting products, explaining their qualities, offering services, and anticipating what customers might want.
For Scitovsky, this last function is especially important. Markets can register demand for available goods, but they cannot straightforwardly communicate a desire for something consumers have not yet conceived of. Someone must imagine an offering and take the risk of developing it. The specialist does more than supply a known want. Through products and the information surrounding them, the specialist makes unfamiliar possibilities available to desire.
But specialization is not the domain of the seller alone. In 2026, consumers have access to far more product information than they did in the markets Scitovsky described. One of the early economic theories about the internet was that it would reduce information asymmetries through user-contributed reviews and publicly available information. The classic example is the used-car market, where sellers historically possessed information about vehicle quality that buyers could not easily verify. Online reviews, vehicle-history reports, and comparison tools have made some of that information more accessible.
Greater access to information, however, does not automatically produce greater competence. Knowing that a product exists is different from knowing how to evaluate it, modify it, or derive enjoyment from it. In markets with heavily involved consumers, buyers increasingly share in the specialized knowledge and opportunities for experimentation once concentrated among sellers. Their involvement develops through two related processes: greater playability and finer consumption skills.
Playability is the room a field gives people to experiment with its products and components. It shortens the distance between an initial spark of desire and an attempt to articulate that desire through experimentation.
Finer consumption skills are the acquired abilities to recognize distinctions and derive enjoyment from them. Someone learns to notice the way a fabric drapes or how a change in seasoning alters a dish. These distinctions help them articulate preferences that would previously have been unavailable to them.
The two can develop alongside each other. Experimenting gives consumers something to notice; learning to appreciate particular qualities gives their next experiment a direction. In skincare, someone might adjust a routine and become more attentive to texture and how products behave together. Their developing preferences then shape which formulations they seek out. In longevity, enthusiasts compare research and assemble routines around increasingly specific ambitions. The scope for experimentation varies considerably across these fields: bodily feedback can be difficult to interpret, and some interventions leave little room for recoverable mistakes.
Clusters of specialized buyers and sellers develop around these exchanges. Enthusiasts help establish which differences matter and which combinations seem worth pursuing. Influencers and tastemakers sometimes begin selling products of their own. Sellers draw on the judgments of specialized customers when deciding what to offer, while buyers rely on sellers to turn unfamiliar possibilities into accessible products.
The relationship is recursive. Experimentation creates opportunities to acquire finer judgment, while finer judgment exposes new possibilities for experimentation. A consumer who becomes more discerning may also become more dissatisfied with existing offerings. What was once a satisfactory product begins to appear incomplete or poorly suited to a newly recognizable preference.
The market develops around this moving gap between what consumers have learned to appreciate and what they can readily obtain.
Kits and kit-making provide a particularly accessible entry into the process of consumer specialization.
Kits are commonly associated with production: assembling a model airplane, building a vibe coded project, or programming a microcontroller. But kits can also organize consumption. They provide not only the materials for making something, but the components and practices through which an unfamiliar experience becomes accessible.
Consider tea in early modern Europe. In The Industrious Revolution, economic historian Jan de Vries describes how new consumer desires developed through what he calls consumption bundles: combinations of goods that acquired qualities and uses they did not possess individually. Tea and teacups offer a simple example, but the more consequential innovation was the combination of tea and sugar. Neither tea in China nor coffee in its Arabian places of origin had conventionally been consumed with sugar. In northwestern Europe, however, sweetened tea and coffee became the basis for new patterns of consumption. By the early eighteenth century, tea or coffee with sugar and wheat bread had helped establish a new breakfast in the Netherlands, replacing older morning meals of porridge, pancakes, and beer and contributing to a shift from two daily meals to three. Across the North Sea, the British ritual of taking tea developed into a distinct social occasion, organized around imported commodities and invested with cultural meaning. What began as a new combination of goods eventually reorganized the daily meal system and created new occasions for social participation.
The significance of these bundles was not simply that one commodity increased demand for another. Their combination created new activities and experiences that consumers could learn to appreciate. The pleasure of tea came to involve its sweetness, the food accompanying it, the vessels in which it was served, and the occasion on which it was consumed. De Vries extends this logic through the Diderot effect, in which acquiring one new possession changes the perceived adequacy of everything surrounding it. Goods become parts of larger ensembles, acquiring social and aesthetic qualities through their relationships with other goods.
These consumption bundles resemble kits for consumption. They provide an initial arrangement of complementary objects and practices through which people can participate in an unfamiliar activity. Repeated participation can then generate finer preferences and further experimentation. The bundle does not merely satisfy a desire for tea; it helps establish tea drinking as an activity worth desiring, with its own equipment, routines, occasions, and standards of appreciation.
Contemporary consumption kits operate similarly. A skincare routine combines products, ingredients, and conventions about their sequence and frequency of use. A coffee setup brings together beans, grinders, brewing equipment, and preparation methods. A cocktail kit includes ingredients, equipment, and recipes that allow someone to participate in a practice before acquiring much expertise.
These arrangements do more than simplify consumption. They provide environments in which consumers learn what to appreciate. Someone who begins by following a coffee recipe may eventually become attentive to extraction, roast, and texture. The kit makes the initial experience accessible, while repeated use develops the skills necessary to recognize and pursue more specialized desires.
Kit production operates through a related mechanism, but places greater emphasis on making and modifying things. Arduino is a useful example. It combines a programmable microcontroller with standardized hardware interfaces, a development environment, and software libraries. These components make many technical operations routine, allowing users to experiment with sensors, motors, lights, and other electronic components without constructing the underlying infrastructure from scratch.
Arduino is also a platform on which further kits can be built. Shields, sensor modules, robotics kits, and educational packages bring additional components and protocols into increasingly specialized arrangements. Each layer makes previously difficult operations routine while exposing new combinations for experimentation.
Someone may begin with a vague interest in making physical objects respond to their environment, without knowing whether they want to build a musical instrument, an automated garden, or an interactive sculpture. Through repeated experimentation, possibilities acquire recognizable forms, and preferences develop around outcomes that could not have been specified at the outset.
Both kinds of kits bundle existing components and protocols, but make different forms of exploration accessible. A consumption kit makes an unfamiliar experience repeatable. A production kit makes unfamiliar combinations achievable. Both provide an initial structure through which desires can develop.
The distinction is not absolute. A person assembling a skincare routine may begin experimenting with formulations. A home bartender may invent cocktails. A coffee enthusiast may begin roasting beans. Conversely, someone who builds a synthesizer may be as interested in experiencing new sounds as in producing an instrument. Making and consuming are often different moments within the same activity.
Kits become particularly important where established arrangements create friction or where people sense possibilities they cannot yet clearly articulate. A finished product offers a relatively settled answer to a recognizable want. A kit leaves more of the answer open to discovery.
This does not mean that kits eliminate constraints. Their playability depends on the conventions and interfaces they establish. Arduino’s standardized connections are precisely what make experimentation possible. The kit absorbs complexity at one level and opens a relatively smooth space of exploration at another.
In this sense, kits do not merely satisfy existing demand. They make the edges of possibility more visible. They provide a way to act on an indistinct attraction, encounter an unexpected result, and gradually develop a preference around it.
The significance is not simply that consumers become producers. It is that consumption and production increasingly become alternating activities within the same process of specialization. Using a product develops judgment about what it could do differently. Making or modifying it exposes new possibilities for use. The resulting experience changes what the participant wants, providing a direction for further experimentation.
This movement also changes the relationship between buyers and sellers. A specialized consumer may become a supplier, while an established producer may incorporate ideas and modifications developed by users. Markets can develop around these exchanges, with new tools, components, and finished goods emerging from activities that initially had no commercial purpose.
Vibe coding offers a contemporary example of this convergence between consumption and production. Someone can begin making software without first acquiring the programming expertise traditionally required to build an application. AI coding assistants make many routine implementation tasks accessible through natural-language instructions, allowing the user to focus on what the software should do.
Someone might begin by generating a small application because seeing it appear is exciting. Changing its appearance or adding a feature offers another occasion for experimentation. What they want from the application develops alongside their growing understanding of what they can make.
Its playability gives this uncertainty somewhere to go. A passing curiosity can become a working version quickly enough to be explored. Someone who would never have commissioned custom software can begin discovering preferences through making it. The available components help produce ambitions that preceded neither the tool nor the experiment.
Building an interface can also make someone more attentive to the software they already use. They begin noticing the restraint of a familiar application, how little explanation it needs, or how reliably it handles an ordinary task. Those qualities become newly desirable just as their own experiments become easier to find disappointing.
The same person may enjoy constructing an application and then discover, through using it, that the result is cumbersome. A feature that was satisfying to produce may prove irritating in everyday use. A seemingly minor detail may determine whether the application becomes part of a routine or is abandoned.
Consumption then provides feedback for production. Using the application reveals problems and possibilities that were not apparent while building it. Returning to the build with that experience gives experimentation a different direction.
The psychologist Edith Ackermann describes a related movement in learning between “dwelling in” an experience and “stepping back” to examine it. Immersion makes discoveries possible; taking some distance allows the learner to consider what those discoveries mean. In vibe coding, this movement occurs as someone alternates between making software and evaluating it as a user.
This is one way specialization gives desire new forms. Experimentation changes what the consumer can appreciate, and appreciation changes which experiments feel worth pursuing. Sometimes the encounter produces something satisfying. Sometimes the user’s developing standards outrun the available means of achieving them. The market develops around that moving gap, offering new components, tools, and finished products to people whose experiments have taught them to want differently.
Over time, the original set of tools becomes a supply of components for projects its user could not have specified at the outset.
This process also has a less satisfying form. Consumers can keep acquiring distinctions and pursuing possibilities without finding ways to act on them or derive greater enjoyment from what they already have. Every explanation exposes another deficiency; every product promises access to an experience that remains just beyond reach. Learning sustains the pursuit while the desire itself remains difficult to articulate.
The relationship between playability and consumption skills is therefore not necessarily a progression toward satisfaction. It is an ongoing process through which people discover possibilities, acquire standards of judgment, and sometimes become dissatisfied with the results of their own experimentation.
Nor is greater playability an inevitable consequence of technological progress. The right-to-repair movement illustrates how products can become more technically sophisticated while becoming less accessible to modification by their owners. Software subscriptions, proprietary interfaces, and restrictions on replacement parts can similarly move activities that consumers once performed themselves into the domain of specialized providers. The same economy that makes it easier to build software through AI coding assistants can make it harder to modify or maintain the devices and services on which that software depends.
This raises a larger question about the economic organization of kits: which activities become available for consumer experimentation, and which remain enclosed within finished products and services? The answer depends not only on technical possibilities, but also on ownership, standards, business models, regulation, and the distribution of specialized knowledge. Kits make unfamiliar desires discoverable, but the boundaries of what can be made or modified are themselves economically and politically determined.