Home 零对冲(ZeroHedge)每日HackerNews

使用 Chrome 浏览器通过 Google 账号登录
Sign in with Google in Chrome

原始链接: https://underpassapp.com/news/2025/7/5.html

## 谷歌“使用 Google 登录”策略 Underpass App Company 最近发布的一篇文章指出，谷歌在其 Chrome 浏览器中对“使用 Google 登录”提示给予了优待。Safari 和 Firefox 等其他浏览器会显示侵入性的“一键登录”横幅，而这些横幅在 Chrome 中不会出现。 然而，Chrome 采用了不同的策略：一个原生“一键登录”对话框，当用户已经登录 Google 时会出现。这种对话框存在问题，因为它会阻止浏览器扩展程序运行——甚至阻止 StopTheMadness Pro 正常工作——并且只能通过 Chrome 的设置（chrome://settings/content/federatedIdentityApi）禁用。 作者认为，这是谷歌利用其主导地位来偏袒 Chrome 的又一例证，在竞争浏览器上造成了用户体验较差的情况，并在其自身浏览器中阻碍了扩展程序的功能。

## Google“使用Google账号登录”弹出框：用户体验争论 一则Hacker News讨论集中在日益普遍的“使用Google账号登录”弹出框上，引发了关于其侵入性和隐私影响的争论。用户报告称，即使在Pornhub等网站上也会出现该弹出框，经常会扰乱用户体验，并引发对数据收集的担忧。 虽然Google认为该功能简化了注册并增加了账户创建（一位开发者报告称其应用程序的注册量增加了8倍），但许多用户认为它令人恼火，并且存在潜在的隐私风险。担忧包括意外登录、不必要的数据共享以及被跟踪的感觉。 该讨论凸显了Chrome浏览器（提供禁用弹出框的设置）与其他浏览器（如Firefox和Safari，用户控制有限）之间的差异。多位用户分享了使用浏览器扩展程序（如uBlock Origin和StopTheMadness Pro）的解决方法。对话还涉及了底层的联合身份凭证管理（FedCM）标准，质疑其开放性以及Google进一步主导在线身份的潜力。最终，该帖子揭示了开发者便利性和用户隐私/控制之间的紧张关系。
相关文章
原文
Sign in with Google in Chrome

July 28, 2025
By Jeff Johnson of Underpass App Company

Many websites such as Yelp show an annoying “Sign in with Google” banner when you visit.

This is what Google calls the One Tap user experience. Fortunately, my web browser extension StopTheMadness Pro hides “Sign in with Google” banners.

What you may not realize if you use Safari or Firefox is that the banners are never displayed in Google Chrome! You can see this in macOS Safari by spoofing the Chrome User-Agent header. In Safari Advanced Settings, enable “Show features for web developers.” This setting adds a Develop menu to Safari‘s main menu bar. The Develop menu includes a User Agent submenu with a list of several web browsers. When you select Google Chrome from the list and then load Yelp, the “Sign in with Google” banners no longer appear in Safari.

Although Chrome avoids the “Sign in with Google” banners, Google’s browser still has its own custom annoyance. If you‘re already signed in to your Google account when you visit a participating website such as Yelp, Chrome will display a One Tap dialog.

This dialog differs from the “Sign in with Google” banners you see in Safari and Firefox in a couple of important ways. First, the Chrome dialog is not an element in the web page but rather a part of the Chrome native app user interface. Thus, StopTheMadness Pro cannot hide the dialog. Indeed, while Chrome is displaying the dialog, it blocks all Chrome extension popup windows from appearing. Selecting an extension in the Extensions toolbar widget does nothing. (In other words, it‘s not a bug in StopTheMadness Pro.)

The second difference is that the Chrome dialog can be disabled in Chrome‘s Settings. Enter chrome://settings/content/federatedIdentityApi in the address bar to access the setting directly.

Select “Block sign-in prompts from identity services” to stop the dialogs from appearing in Chrome.

If the courts and antitrust regulators are reading—they probably won’t read my blog, but one can dream—this is yet another example of Google advantaging its own browser Chrome over other web browsers.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com