过去一年,有23,746名患者在候诊名单中死亡。
23,746 Patients Died on Waitlists in Past Year

原始链接: https://secondstreet.org/2025/11/26/23746-patients-died-on-waitlists-in-past-year/

最近,SecondStreet.org通过信息自由请求获得的数据显示,加拿大医疗保健领域出现令人担忧的趋势。在截至2025年3月31日的财政年度,**至少有23,746名患者在等待医疗服务(包括手术和诊断扫描)期间死亡**。与前一年相比,等待名单死亡人数增加了3%。 这些数据来自各省卫生部门(部分报告存在空白,特别是艾伯塔省和马尼托巴省的部分地区),显示等待时间从不到一周到近九年不等。安大略省卫生部门的数据具体显示,有355名心脏病患者死亡,其中至少90人超过了既定的等待时间目标。 自2018年以来,**超过100,876名加拿大人**在等待名单上死亡,由于数据不完整,这一数字可能被低估。SecondStreet.org认为,这凸显了医疗保健改革的迫切需要,并建议加拿大可以通过采纳成功的欧洲公共卫生系统的做法来改善结果。该组织批评缺乏对这些死亡事件的公开报告,并将其与对其他行业的严格检查形成对比。

一份来自secondstreet.org的最新报告称,过去一年有23,746名患者在等待名单上死亡。 这引发了Hacker News上的讨论,评论者质疑在没有与“发达国家”医疗系统进行国际比较的情况下,这个数字的意义。 一位用户指出,考虑到经济现实,这些死亡事件并不令人惊讶,认为个人获得的医疗保健与其支付的费用和需求成正比。 另一位用户提出了一个关键点,即确定这些患者是否无论等待时间如何都会死亡。 值得注意的是,一位评论员指出了该来源的偏见——secondstreet.org是一个“自由市场智库”,其项目名为“社会主义幸存者”,暗示数据可能存在框架问题。 虽然数字的准确性不一定因此失效,但该来源值得考虑。
相关文章

原文
  • Government data obtained through FOI shows 23,746 patients died on waitlists during the past fiscal year, bringing the total to over 100,000 since 2018 

 Canadian think tank SecondStreet.org released government data today showing at least 23,746 patients died on government waiting lists over the past fiscal year. The data was obtained through Freedom of Information (FOI) requests and covers a wide array of services – heart surgery, hip operations, MRI scans, etc. 

“What’s really sad is that behind many of these figures are stories of patients suffering during their final years – grandparents who dealt with chronic pain while waiting for hip operations, people leaving children behind as they die waiting for heart operations, so much suffering,” said SecondStreet.org President Colin Craig. “It doesn’t have to be this way. If we copied better-performing European public health systems, we could greatly reduce patient suffering.”

The data covers the fiscal year April 1, 2024 – March 31, 2025. Highlights include:

  • At least 23,746 patients died in Canada while waiting for surgeries or diagnostic scans. This figure does not include Alberta and some parts of Manitoba, while some health bodies only had data on surgeries, not diagnostic scans. Most provinces have no data on patients dying while waiting for specialist appointments;
  • Comparing data from health care bodies that provided information for both this year and last year shows a 3% increase in waiting list deaths. Patients died after waiting anywhere from less than a week to nearly nine years;
  • New data from Ontario Health suggests 355 patients died while waiting for cardiac surgery or a cardiac procedure. While many cases did not include target wait times for providing treatment, there were at least 90 cases where patients died after waiting past targets that were stated or after waiting more than 90 days; and
  • Since April 2018, SecondStreet.org has gathered government data showing more than 100,876 cases where Canadians died while waiting for care. In previous years, large portions of data were missing, so the total is likely much higher.

“It’s interesting that governments will regularly inspect restaurants and report publicly if there’s a minor problem such as a missing paper towel holder,” added Craig. “Meanwhile, no government reports publicly on patients dying on waiting lists. It’s quite hypocritical.”

 To view the report – click here 

To view the government FOI responses, see below.

British Columbia:
Interior Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Fraser Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Northern Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Island Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Vancouver Coastal Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic

Alberta
Alberta Health Services ‒ surgery, diagnostic

Saskatchewan
Ministry of Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Saskatchewan Cancer Agency ‒ click here

Manitoba
Prairie Mountain Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Southern Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic
Winnipeg Regional Health Authority ‒ click here
Shared Health ‒ click here

Ontario
Ontario Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic, cardiac surgery, cardiac procedures

Quebec
University of Montreal (CHUM) ‒ click here
CIUSSS Capitale Nationale ‒ click here
CIUSSS du Nord-de-l’ile-de-Montreal ‒ click here
CISSS Bas St. Laurent ‒ click here
Quebec Heart and Lung Institute at Laval University ‒ click here 
CISSS South Centre Montreal Island ‒ click here
CISSS Chaudiere-Applaches ‒ click here 
CISSS Outaouais ‒ click here
CISSS Abitibi-Temiscamingue ‒ click here
CISSS Laurentides ‒ click here
CIUSSS East Montreal ‒ click here
CISSS Monteregie-Centre ‒ click here
CISSS Monteregie-Est ‒ click here
CIUSSS Estrie-Centre Sherbrooke ‒ click here
CHU de Quebec, Universite Laval ‒ click here

New Brunswick
New Brunswick Health ‒ click here
Horizon Health Network ‒ click here

Nova Scotia
Nova Scotia Health Authority ‒ surgery, diagnostic

Newfoundland and Labrador
Newfoundland and Labrador Health Services ‒ click here

Prince Edward Island
Prince Edward Island Health ‒ surgery, diagnostic

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com