高尔夫不是划船。
Golfing Is Not Rowing

原始链接: https://taylor.town/golf-vs-rowing

这篇内容将“流畅”进展的活动(如划船)与“混沌”进展的活动(如高尔夫)进行对比,以说明有效的成功策略。线性渐进式——持续的小步骤——在努力直接转化为进步时效果很好。然而,在写作、创业或高尔夫等领域,初始条件对结果影响很大,这种方法无效。 这些“高尔夫式”过程受益于“重来机会”——重新开始的能力——因为在面对根本缺陷时,小的调整往往是徒劳的。与划船的持续微调不同,创意工作需要大量的前期规划,并且不能轻易分解为整齐的增量。作者提醒人们不要盲目地遵循“每天写作”之类的建议,而没有认识到关键的写作前阶段。最终,在应对复杂、不可预测的创意追求时,拥抱实验并接受需要重新开始是关键,因为那里没有明确的成功之路。

Hacker News 新闻 | 过去 | 评论 | 提问 | 展示 | 招聘 | 提交 登录 高尔夫不是划船 (taylor.town) 8 分,由 surprisetalk 1小时前发布 | 隐藏 | 过去 | 收藏 | 1 条评论 illusive4080 8分钟前 [–] 我打高尔夫只是为了玩得开心。我偶尔会多打两杆。我不记录我的分数。我遇到过一些水平很高的业余高尔夫球手,他们会私下告诉你他们已经不再享受高尔夫了。在那时,它从爱好变成了痴迷,而我不想越过那条线。回复 指南 | 常见问题 | 列表 | API | 安全 | 法律 | 申请 YC | 联系 搜索:
相关文章

原文

Golf makes chaotic progress

Rowing makes smooth progress

Some activities have smooth progress bars: rowing, knitting, cycling, climbing, bodybuilding, etc.

For such pastimes, investing a unit of effort reaps a proportional unit of progress. Linear incrementalism is a sound strategy when success is linear. To win at rowing, row harder/better/faster/stronger than your competition.

Golf is not so smooth. Yes, each round is a state-dependent game of error-correction (i.e. Zeno's Paradox). But golf swings are coarse actions -- few swings per game, with no recourse for fine adjustment between swings.

A golf game is 65-75 swings over ~5 hours. A rowing race is 5-10 minutes of continuous effort and micro-adjustments.

Golf-like processes are characterized by mulligans. "Do-overs" are powerful when success is chaotic, i.e. sensitive to initial conditions. Baby steps are futile when your golf ball is already at the bottom of the pond. Linear incrementalism cannot resolve fatal flaws.

Failure awaits those who confuse rowing and golfing. Golf cannot be played in tidy 1-yard increments. Brute force isn't an option -- don't attempt a one-man war of attrition.

Programs like NaNoWriMo mislead aspiring writers. "Write every day" is great advice, but the first 90% of writing a book is often not writing -- it's thinking/planning/researching. There are other golf clubs in that bag. Many writers only start "writing" once their ball is very nearly in the hole.

Many creative processes (e.g. writing, entrepreneurship, sculpting, programming) are more like golfing than rowing; they are more chaotic than smooth.

But unlike golf, creative work has no fairways, no greens, no carts, no flags. There are real tigers in those woods. You've got one life and no map.

Luckily, nobody is keeping score. Take all the mulligans you need.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com