弦理论的炒作不会停止。
The string theory hype machine will never die

原始链接: https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=15407

炒作机器永远不会消亡。这周,我记录这种荒谬的炒作已经超过二十年。它对公众理解科学和科学家信誉造成了巨大的损害。它也没有帮助其他物理学家对弦理论的看法,以至于弦理论家现在几乎无法找到工作,除非他们能弄清楚如何把自己重新包装成机器学习专家。弦理论家曼基·金报道说:“弦理论正处于快速收缩阶段,也许我太蠢了,坚持了一匹死马太久。早该放弃了。” 没必要深入探讨这种炒作及其持续存在。世界正在超越它,转向新鲜的、新的恐怖。这篇文章发表在“本周炒作”中。请收藏此链接。

一场 Hacker News 的讨论围绕着哥伦比亚大学的一篇文章,该文章助长了人们对弦理论的“炒作”。用户质疑该文章是否准确地反映了研究内容,指出链接的论文*使用*了为弦理论开发的数学工具,但实际上并非*关于*弦理论本身——并且成功地做出了经过实验验证的预测。 对话涉及批评弦理论的困难,提到了罗杰·彭罗斯因其技术复杂性和封闭的社群而犹豫不决。一个关键点是弦理论缺乏可检验性,这使得炒作可以无限期地持续下去。一位评论员开玩笑地将持续的宣传归功于科普者米奇奥·卡库。最终,该帖子表达了对将利用弦理论数学的进步归因于对该理论本身验证的怀疑。
相关文章

原文

The string hype machine will never die. This week we have

I’ve been documenting this sort of ridiculous hype for more than twenty years now. It has done a huge amount of damage to the public understanding of science and to the credibility of scientists. It also hasn’t helped the perception of string theory by other physicists, with string theorists now virtually unemployable unless they can figure out how to rebrand as machine learning experts. String theorist Manki Kim reports here that “string theory is in a very fast contracting phase, maybe I was dumb enough to hold on to a dead horse for too long. Should’ve given up long time ago.”

There’s no point in going into more detail about this kind of hype and its continued existence. The world is passing it by, moving on to fresh, new horrors.

This entry was posted in This Week's Hype. Bookmark the permalink.
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com