派对气球导致埃尔帕索国际机场关闭;估计损失57.3万美元。
A party balloon shut down El Paso International Airport; estimated cost –$573k

原始链接: https://log.jasongodfrey.info/questions/The-Most-Expensive-Party-Balloon-in-History

## 埃尔帕索气球事件:代价高昂的误判 2026年2月10日至11日,埃尔帕索因将派对气球误认为贩毒集团无人机,导致航空旅行受到重大干扰。联邦航空管理局最初发布了为期10天的飞行限制,停飞包括布利斯堡的飞机,并将医疗直升机改道至拉斯克鲁塞斯。幸运的是,限制在7.4小时内解除,但在此之前,已有15个航班取消,其他航班严重延误。 对公开数据的分析估计,此次短暂关闭造成的经济影响在**36.4万美元至87.3万美元**之间。该数字包括乘客时间损失、航空公司运营成本和机场费用。成本的大部分来自乘客时间损失的价值,估计在27.9万美元至51.8万美元之间。 然而,实际成本可能*更高*,因为该分析无法量化对军事航空、医疗物资运输、货运以及更广泛的经济涟漪效应的影响。一位地方代表估计,10天的关闭可能造成4000万至5000万美元的损失,这表明尽管此次干扰时间短暂,但仍然是巨大的。

## 埃尔帕索机场关闭:气球与激光 埃尔帕索国际机场因海关与边境保护局(CBP)部署的高功率激光武器击落一个最终被确认为派对气球而关闭,造成的损失估计为57.3万美元。 事件源于对卡特尔无人机在边境附近运作的担忧。然而,Hacker News上的评论员质疑其必要性和执行情况,指出激光在联邦航空管理局(FAA)正式关闭空域*之前*就被部署了。人们对这项技术的准备情况以及气球是否可能被合理地误认为是无人机表示担忧。 报告显示,各机构之间缺乏沟通——联邦航空管理局局长在未通知白宫、五角大楼或国土安全部的情况下关闭了空域。虽然据报道至少有一架卡特尔无人机被摧毁,但该事件凸显了联邦机构内部潜在的过度反应和功能失调。
相关文章

原文

A party balloon mistaken for a cartel drone shut down El Paso for hours. Here’s what it cost.

On February 10, 2026, the FAA shut down all flights over El Paso for what was supposed to be 10 days because the U.S. military had shot down what it thought was a drone. It turned out to be a party balloon. The closure was lifted within hours, but not before 15 flights were canceled, others delayed by hours, medevacs rerouted to Las Cruces, and Fort Bliss grounded.

So, how much did it cost?

Here’s my method for answering that question. I used only public, citable data. I reconstructed the timeline, built a flight dataset, classified cancellations and delays, converted disruption into passenger-hours and labor-hours, and monetized it with USDOT value-of-time guidance. I then applied sanity checks and documented all assumptions. Below is the analysis.

1. Timeline

EventLocal (MST)UTCSource
TFR effective (closure start)11:30 PM Feb 1006:30 Feb 11FAA TFR notice, El Paso Times
TFR lifted (closure end)6:54 AM Feb 1113:54 Feb 11FAA X post (6:54 MT)
Effective duration~7.4 hours

What changed: The FAA initially announced a 10-day restriction. After coordination between federal agencies—and clarification that the threat had been addressed—the FAA reversed the restriction within hours. No partial reopening was reported; the closure was lifted in full.

2. Flight Universe

CategoryCountSourceConfidence
Canceled (true)8Business Insider / Flightradar24High
Delayed7El Paso Times, inferredMedium
Diverted1Business Insider (Sierra West cargo to Las Cruces)High
Disrupted passengers (est.)~1600Schedule + load factor 80%Low

Southwest, American, and Delta canceled 15 flights in and out of El Paso before the FAA lifted the restriction (Business Insider). Departing aircraft experienced average delays of over three hours. Specific examples from El Paso Times: 6 AM to Phoenix delayed to 5:55 PM; 5:30 AM to Dallas Love delayed to 9 AM; 6:04 AM to DFW delayed to noon.

Costs Without Public Data: Real Impact Likely Higher

The cost estimates here are based only on publicly available data. The true impact is likely higher because the following factors cannot be quantified from public sources:

  • Fort Bliss / Biggs Army Airfield — Military aviation was grounded (within 10 nm TFR). No public data on overnight military flight volume or mission impact.
  • Medevac / medical — Mayor Johnson reported medical evacuation flights rerouted to Las Cruces and surgical equipment unable to reach El Paso. No public cost or clinical outcome data.
  • Cargo — Sierra West diverted to Las Cruces; other cargo likely affected. Perishable and time-sensitive freight costs not reported.
  • Fuel / holding — Additional fuel from diversions and holding; magnitude unknown.
  • General aviation — GA within the TFR excluded; no public flight count.
  • Secondary effects — Aircraft/crew rotation cascade, crew legal/rest limits, spillover demand to nearby airports, call-center surge volume. No public benchmarks.
  • Tertiary effects — Business and supply-chain disruption, ground transport, medical outcomes, reputational impact. Not quantifiable from public data.

3. Work-Hours Wasted

BucketLowMidHigh
Passenger-hours lost578172278672
Airline/airport labor (est.)~200~400~700
Total hours (approx.)~5981~7627~9372

ASSUMPTION: Value of time from USDOT 2016 guidance inflated to 2026 (~81 business); 30% business / 70% personal mix. Canceled-passenger penalty: 4 hours (replacement travel).

4. Dollar Impact

ComponentLowMidHigh
Passenger time cost$279K$398K$518K
Airline operational cost$80K$160K$320K
Airport incremental (scenario)$5K$15K$35K
Total estimated impact$364K$573K$873K

Quantified components only. See “Costs Without Public Data” above for uncosted factors that would increase total impact.

5. Sanity Check

El Paso Rep. Chris Canales estimated a 10-day closure could cost El Paso 40–50 million dollars (El Paso Times). My estimate is for the actual ~7-hour disruption. Scaling linearly: 7.4 hrs / (10 × 24) ≈ 3.1% of a 10-day scenario → 573K falls below that estimate, as I guessed it would due to only including public data. ELP typically has ~55 departures and ~106 total daily operations; the disruption affected the overnight/early-morning bank.


Conclusion. There is no way to know if this was the most expensive party balloon in history. But I wouldn’t pay $573k for one.


Post-script: This piece is not intended to criticize or judge anyone involved. Who among us hasn’t, at some point, mistaken a party balloon for a cartel drone? Let him cast the first stone.

Finally, this analysis was vibed together quickly as the situation unfolded, using only publicly available data. It is not a substitute for professional economic analysis.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com