H-1B 揭秘:人才短缺是谎言
H-1B Exposed: The Talent Shortage Is a Myth

原始链接: https://www.h1bexposed.tech/

独立调查显示,摩根大通、美国运通和资本一等三家美国主要银行利用H-1B签证项目存在劳务套利模式。对公开的联邦文件(2017-2025财年)分析表明,这些银行提交了总计7474份劳工条件申请(LCA),审批率近乎完美(98-99%)。 调查强调了一种大规模提交LCA、支付接近法定最低工资(31.8%的申请)以及赞助绿卡以留住员工的策略。 绝大多数(69.8%)的职位是“通用IT”岗位——软件开发人员、分析师和质量保证人员,这表明该项目并非针对专业人才。 数据显示,这并非对真正人才短缺的响应,而是通过地域套利和移民赞助控制工人来降低劳动力成本的 deliberate effort。 美国运通目前在其员工中拥有最高的H-1B工人比例(3.5%且正在增长)。所有数据均来自官方政府文件,旨在提高透明度并揭露这些做法。

一场 Hacker News 的讨论围绕 H1-B 签证项目及其潜在替代方案展开。最初的发帖者在最近的辩论中质疑解决方案是什么,并认为如果 H1-B 发生变化,外包将是其中一种结果。他们认为,声称有大量合格的国内计算机科学毕业生是错误的,并指出自 2015 年以来,毕业生技能水平有所下降。 评论者提出了各种观点。一些人提倡优先考虑美国工人并制定更严格的数据隐私法,同时承认外国人才的价值。一个共同的主题是,H1-B 经常被公司*滥用*以压低工资,从而损害国内和移民工人。 一些用户质疑是否可以填补国内的高薪职位,并分享了公司用低薪 H1-B 员工取代工人的新闻链接。核心争论在于平衡人才引进与公平劳动实践以及国内就业机会。
相关文章

原文

An Independent Investigation

The talent shortage

is a myth.

This is labor arbitrage.

Three of America's largest banks filed 7,474 Labor Condition Applications for foreign workers. Public records expose the playbook: file at scale, pay the legal minimum, and lock workers in with green card sponsorship.

Total LCA Filings7,474
|
Approval Rate98-99%
|
Green Card Sponsors5,142
|
Near Wage Floor31.8%
|
Commodity IT Roles69.8%
|
Companies Tracked3
|
Years of DataFY2017-2025
|
Total LCA Filings7,474
|
Approval Rate98-99%
|
Green Card Sponsors5,142
|
Near Wage Floor31.8%
|
Commodity IT Roles69.8%
|
Companies Tracked3
|
Years of DataFY2017-2025
|

The Numbers

What the public records show.

Every data point here comes from federal filings these companies made themselves — the same data they hope nobody reads.

7,474
Total LCA Filings
FY2020–2026, three banks
5,142
Green Card Sponsorships
PERM applications filed
69.8%
Commodity IT Work
Software devs, analysts, QA — not specialized talent
98–99%
USCIS Approval Rate
Rubber stamp. Virtually zero oversight.
31.8%
Near Wage Floor
Nearly 1 in 3 filings pay barely above the legal minimum
3.5%
AmEx H-1B Workforce %
And growing — highest ratio of the three banks

The Playbook

The talent shortage is a myth.

This is labor arbitrage.

01

File at Scale

Thousands of Labor Condition Applications filed per year. Volume is the strategy.

02

Pay the Floor

Nearly a third of filings cluster right at the prevailing wage minimum. Compliance minimums, not competitive offers.

03

Route to Low-Cost Cities

Workers sent to locations where prevailing wage obligations are lowest. Geographic arbitrage baked into the system.

04

Lock Them In

Sponsor green cards. The worker can't leave, can't negotiate, can't push back. Their immigration status is the leash.

Methodology

All sourced. All public.

This entire investigation runs on public federal data — filings these companies submitted to the Department of Labor, USCIS, the SEC, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

They created the paper trail. We read it.

DOL
Dept. of Labor OFLC
Every LCA filing, prevailing wage determination, and worksite location.
USCIS
USCIS Employer Data Hub
H-1B petition approvals, denials, and outcomes by employer and fiscal year.
SEC
SEC 10-K Filings
Annual workforce headcounts — the denominator for calculating H-1B penetration.
BLS
Bureau of Labor Statistics
Occupational wage data to benchmark what the market actually pays.

Note: LCA filings are not the same as H-1B petitions. One worker can have multiple LCAs across different years or locations. The data shows filing volume and patterns — which is exactly the point. The pattern is the story.

Stay Informed

This is just

the beginning.

New research published weekly. More companies, more industries, more data to go through.

H-1B EXPOSED

An independent investigation into corporate use of the H-1B visa program. Every number sourced from public federal records.

Data Sources
  • DOL OFLC Disclosure Data
  • USCIS H-1B Employer Data Hub
  • SEC 10-K Annual Filings
  • BLS Occupational Employment Statistics
Disclaimer

LCA filings are not the same as H-1B petitions. One worker can have multiple LCAs. This site presents public data for transparency. The point is the pattern.

© 2025 Dr. Josh C. Simmons. All rights reserved. | DrJoshCSimmons.comPUBLIC DATA · PUBLIC INTEREST
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com