Show HN 正在消亡?不,它正在沉没。
Is Show HN dead? No, but it's drowning

原始链接: https://www.arthurcnops.blog/death-of-show-hn/

最近对 Hacker News 的 Show HN 栏目的分析显示,动态发生了变化,但并非活动减少。虽然 Show HN 在帖子总数上比以往任何时候都更“活跃”,但单个项目正逐渐淹没在快速增长的提交量中——这种现象被称为“Sideprocalypse”(侧项目末日)。 作者观察到“工作量证明”减少——这意味着启动的项目更多,但脱颖而出的项目更少。这使得小型独立开发者更难获得关注,因为想法很快就被资金更充足的竞争对手所饱和。 数据显示,帖子很快被埋没,讨论正在减少,有趣的项目被忽视。作者重点介绍了几个这样的项目(Neohabit、OpenRun、uForwarder),并建议 Hacker News 考虑提升这些“瑰宝”的方法,以保持其作为创新技术讨论中心的地位。

最近的 Hacker News 讨论质疑“Show HN”是否正在失去其价值。核心问题在于,大量 AI 辅助项目往往开发得不够深入,导致讨论不够吸引人。用户们抱怨,项目从源于深度问题解决,转变为更简单、快速创建的演示。 虽然有些人欢迎 AI 带来的编程民主化,但另一些人则怀念过去,那时发布 Show HN 需要显著的技能和多年的专注工作。一位评论员提到一个通过 Show HN 成功启动的项目,尽管最初没有获得很多赞成票,但仍产生了数百万美元的收入,这表明价值并不总是体现在即时关注上。 改进建议包括为 AI 生成的项目创建单独的类别,或者构建一个专门用于展示新作品的替代平台,强调快速分享和分类。总体情绪表明,需要更好的内容管理,以保持 Show HN 过去所具有的质量和讨论深度。
相关文章

原文
← Back

Feb 17, 2026 · Arthur Cnops

A few days ago I posted to Show HN. I had good fun building that useless little internet experience. The post quickly disappeared from Show HN's first page, amongst the rest of the vibecoded pulp. And to be clear, I'm fine with that.

The behavior on Show HN was interesting to see though. So I pulled the data.

The Short Version

Show HN of course isn't dead. You could even say it's more alive than ever. What has changed is the volume of posts and engagement per post. It's only natural when more projects are being built in a single weekend. There's less "Proof of Work".

From the business side of this, Johan Halse recently called this the Sideprocalypse: the end of the small indie developer's dream. Every idea has been built, marketed better, and SEO'd into oblivion by someone with more money.

Some cool projects aren't getting through this noise, which is a pity. Here are a few I thought were interesting:

  1. Neohabit
  2. OpenRun
  3. uForwarder

I just upvoted them!

Now, let's look at some data.

Volume Is Exploding

HN volume over time for all posts, Show HN, and non-Show-HN

Show HN monthly share of all HN story volume

The Graveyard Is Growing

1-point share over time for Show HN versus non-Show-HN

Show HN started out better than regular submissions. Now it's significantly worse.

The Shrinking Window

How long does a Show HN post stay on page 1 before being pushed off? During peak hours (US daytime):

Estimated visibility time for Show HN posts during peak hours

Discussion Is Dying Too

Average comments per Show HN post

So Is Show HN Dead?

No. There's just more noise, and less opportunity to get attention and have a discussion with other folks on HN about your project. Some gems go completely unnoticed. Maybe something for HN to think about: how do these subjective "gems" get more spotlight? How does HN remain the coolest place to talk about the coolest tech?

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com