草原地带案被告今日被判处30至100年监禁
Prairieland Defendants Sentenced Today to Prison Terms Ranging from 30-100 Years

原始链接: https://prairielanddefendants.com/press-release/eight-federal-prairieland-defendants-sentenced-today-to-prison-terms-ranging-from-30-100-years-for-common-protest-activity/

2025年7月,得克萨斯州阿尔瓦拉多市草原地(Prairieland)移民拘留中心发生了一起抗议活动,八名被告因此被判处30年至100年不等的监禁。定罪罪名包括骚乱、为恐怖分子提供物质支持及爆炸物相关指控;其中本杰明·哈尼尔·宋(Benjamin Hanil Song)因被控企图谋杀警员而被判处最长刑期。 这些指控源于抗议期间示威者与警方之间的交火。在量刑听证会上,宋为其行为辩护,称那是为防止抗议者被执法人员杀害而采取的必要干预措施。包括其家人和社区领袖在内的支持者谴责这些判决“残忍”且“不成比例”,并指出审判过程中存在政府偏见、虚假信息以及未得到解决的陪审员不当行为报告。 辩护团队及支持者坚持认为,被告是因为行使对拘留中心运作表达异议的权利而遭到针对。在重审请求被驳回后,被告已表示将对定罪提出上诉,并坚称争取自由的斗争仍在继续。该案的其他被告预计将于7月接受判决。

Hacker News 上出现了一场关于北得克萨斯州一个组织八名成员量刑的讨论。这些人因袭击移民及海关执法局(ICE)设施被定罪,罪名包括谋杀未遂和共谋罪,判处刑期从 30 年到终身监禁不等。 这些判决引发了极化的争论。一些参与者认为惩罚过于严厉,并指出类似罪行的量刑准则通常会导致刑期显著缩短。裁决的批评者称这些判决——特别是针对被控销毁证据人员的 30 年刑期——是“对司法制度的嘲弄”,且可能违宪。 相反,另一些人则为量刑的严厉程度辩护,理由是这些罪行性质严重,包括枪击警官和使用爆炸物。这一派人士强调,被告是由陪审团定罪的,他们的行为,包括在暴力袭击后销毁或隐瞒证据,理应受到严厉的法律制裁。讨论帖中还出现了对该组织性质的分歧,一些人将其贴上“恐怖分子”的标签,而另一些人则驳斥这种说法,突显了围绕此案持续存在的政治分歧。
相关文章

原文

Family Members, Faith and Community Leaders, Rally in Support of Defendants, Vow to Continue Fight for Freedom, Justice for Loved Ones

FORT WORTH, TX – Eight Prairieland defendants were sentenced in federal court today, three months after their convictions on a variety of federal charges, including riot, material support for terrorists, attempted murder, possession and conspiracy to use explosives, and conspiracy to conceal documents. Family members and supporters, who sat stunned as US District Judges Mark Pittman and Reed O’Connor delivered sentences ranging from 30-100 years in prison, called the punishment cruel, callous and starkly disproportionate to the defendants’ actions. In a rally and press conference held after the sentencing, supporters expressed defiance and vowed to continue fighting for the Prairieland defendants’ freedom.

The eight Prairieland defendants sentenced today are Savanna Batten, Zachary Evetts, Autumn Hill, Meagan Morris, Maricela Rueda, Daniel Rolando Sanchez Estrada, Benjamin Hanil Song, and Elizabeth Soto. All defendants, with the exception of Sanchez Estrada were convicted of rioting, providing material support to terrorists, conspiracy to use an explosive, and use of an explosive device, which referred to the consumer grade fireworks used on July 4. Sanchez Estrada was convicted of concealing a document—political literature—and, along with Rueda, conspiracy to conceal documents. Song was additionally convicted of attempted murder of an officer and discharging a firearm in furtherance of a crime.

Eight Prairieland defendants were sentenced today to consecutive prison terms as follows:

  • Savanna Batten: 50 years
  • Zachary Evetts: 50 years
  • Autumn Hill: 50 years
  • Meagan Morris: 50 years
  • Maricela Rueda: 70 years
  • Daniel Rolando Sanchez Estrada: 30 years
  • Benjamin Hanil Song: 100 years
  • Elizabeth Soto: 50 years

Ines Soto will be sentenced on July 1, along with Joy “Rowan” Gibson and Rebecca Morgan, who took non-cooperating plea deals, and five defendants who took cooperating plea deals.

Song, the most harshly sentenced Prairieland defendant, having received a 100-year prison term, gave a moving statement in response to their sentence, explaining for the first time the motivations for their actions the night of the noise demonstration at the Prairieland ICE Detention Center. “What we all saw happen to Renee Good and Alex Pretti is my worst nightmare,” said Song. “What happened on July 4th, 2025 was that exact same nightmare – when I saw Lt. Thomas Gross point his gun at the back of a running, unarmed protestor, and assuming an aggressive firing position, leaning forward hard into the recoil of his gun.”

“As a firearms instructor and a United States Marine Corps Veteran, I knew exactly what was about to happen. I knew another protestor was about to be murdered right in front of me,” continued Song. “Should I have done nothing? Should I have looked the other way? Should I have just allowed yet another innocent person to be slaughtered?,” Song asked the court rhetorically. “I was forced to use…the minimum defensive force possible,” in order to “prevent what happened to Alex Pretti,” and to “prevent what happened to Renee Good.” The last thing Song wanted to do was hurt anyone, according to their prepared statement. “And I am so, so happy that no one had their life stolen from them that day. By anyone.”

“This case has relied on lies and misinformation from the start,” said Amber Lowrey, the sister of Savanna Batten, who was sentenced today to 50 years in prison. “While these absurd sentences are no surprise based on the bias of the court, it is heartbreaking nonetheless. But we will keep fighting to overturn these unjust convictions and to free Savanna and all the Prairieland defendants. We will not rest until they are free!”

“As a congregation, we decided that this case was a fundamental test of our right to dissent against authoritarian regimes,” said Ana Marie Thorne, Chair of the Social Justice Committee at All People’s Church Unitarian Universalist in Fort Worth. “These defendants are not militant monsters out to kill,” continued Thorne. “They are everyday people who saw our country literally interning people in concentration camps and decided to show up at Prairieland Detention Center to let those incarcerated there know that they mattered. We leave here today knowing that the outcome of this trial is not the end. It is the beginning.”

Before the sentencing, Judge Pittman dismissed numerous motions to overturn the convictions without providing written rulings and with little-to-no explanation. All nine trial defendants filed motions for a new trial, detailing how the government failed to provide the necessary evidence for a conviction and instead put on a trial that was “saturated with evidence designed to evoke fear, political bias, and guilt by association,” according to one of the motions. Another motion details potential juror misconduct. Prairieland defendants have vowed to fight their convictions and will be filing appeals in the following weeks.

The Prairieland cases, involving 22 people charged with both state and federal charges, stem from a noise demonstration in solidarity with detainees at the Prairieland ICE Detention Center in Alvarado, Texas, on July 4, 2025. After the protest, an officer with the Alvarado Police Department became involved in an exchange of gunfire soon after arrival. The officer allegedly sustained minor injuries, and was reportedly released from the hospital shortly afterwards, but authorities have never provided hospital records to justify these claims. Alvarado police arrested ten people that night, and a dozen more were arrested over the following several months.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com