你想学习物理学(第二版,2021年)
So you want to learn physics (second edition, 2021)

原始链接: https://www.susanrigetti.com/physics

这份指南概述了如何有效地进行物理自学。 **准备工作:** 在开始之前,请确保你已经牢固掌握了高中水平的数学知识(代数、几何、三角学)。推荐使用可汗学院(Khan Academy)或 R.D. Driver 的《为什么是数学?》(*Why Math?*)等资源。无需具备先前的科学背景。 **学习方法:** 学习物理的关键在于解决问题,而非仅仅阅读理论。确定你独特的学习方式——无论是记笔记、总结概念,还是利用视觉辅助工具——并以此构建你的学习结构。由于自学缺乏直接反馈,请利用在线资源核对答案,但前提是你必须先进行认真且多次的独立解题尝试。 **心态:** 为了保持动力,可以阅读一些高质量、非推测性的科普物理书籍(例如理查德·费曼或弗兰克·克洛斯的著作),以保持对“大局”的把握。 **课程现实:** 物理学主要通过严谨的教科书学习和解题来掌握,而非通过实验工作。所提供的课程大纲映射了顶尖大学的核心课程,使你能够独立获得世界一流的教育。通过专注于这些核心材料,你无需满足传统的院校要求即可精通该领域。

Hacker News 上的讨论帖“你想学物理吗”引发了一场关于自学最佳途径的热烈辩论。 一种观点认为,对于非学生群体而言,结构化、大学式的自学方式效率低下且过于刻板。持此观点者建议采用“零散式”学习法:即在物理概念与个人职业或特定兴趣相关时再进行学习。他们认为,“小步快跑”式的成就感比漫长的线性课程更能提供动力。 相反,许多参与者则维护全面自学的必要性,指出结构化的路径对于建立深刻且连贯的世界认知模型至关重要。他们认为,零散学习可能导致“未知的未知”,即学习者会错过对称性或守恒定律等将不同主题联系在一起的基础框架。支持者还强调,学习的目标应是拓宽视野,而不仅仅是解决实际问题。 最终,各方达成共识,认为两种方法各具价值。无论是偏好深入的基础钻研,还是以好奇心为导向的应用式学习,这场讨论都凸显了一点:自学需要极强的自律,以及在没有传统学术监督的情况下驾驭复杂内容的能力。
相关文章

原文

Before You Begin

Popular Books on Physics

When you're solving problems, working through textbooks, and getting into the nitty-gritty details of each topic, it's so easy to lose the forest for the trees and forget why you even became inspired to study physics in the first place. This is where really, really good (and non-speculative) popular books on physics come in handy: they inspire, they encourage, and they help you keep the big picture in mind. 

One big problem is that many popular physics books (especially those written by famous physicists) are incredibly speculative and tend to present an unrealistic view of what the study of physics is all about. When you're learning physics, it's best to avoid these types of speculative books and stick to the ones that talk about the real physics that we know exists (in general, anything by Frank Close or Richard Feynman is a safe bet!).

Here are a handful of my favorite popular physics books, ranked in order of difficulty:

Mathematical and Scientific Preliminaries

Before you begin studying physics and working through the topics in the sections below, you need to be familiar with some basic mathematics. A high school education — which should include pre-algebra, algebra 1, geometry, algebra 2, trigonometry, and pre-calculus — is sufficient. If you need a refresher, I recommend either working through the Khan Academy math courses (https://www.khanacademy.org/) or the book Why Math? by R.D. Driver. There's no need to be familiar with calculus before starting, because you’ll learn it as you work through the undergraduate-level courses.

There are no scientific prerequisites for this curriculum. You don’t need to be familiar with biology or chemistry at either the high school or college level in order to understand, although doing some studying on the side can’t hurt. Khan Academy has some great high school science refresher courses that are perfect for this (https://www.khanacademy.org/science).

How to Study

Everyone learns very differently, and knowing your learning style is important: do you learn by reading, by taking notes, by talking, by watching, by doing, or by a combination of some or all of these? For example, I learn by reading and by note-taking, so I read through textbooks very carefully, take copious notes, and summarize each concept in my own words before moving on to something new. Think about this before you begin so that you'll know how to structure your studies. 

Regardless of your learning style, you'll still need to solve the physics problems in each textbook. Solving problems is the only way to understand physics. There's no way around it. Even though it can feel tedious at times, there's nothing more rewarding than figuring out a really difficult physics problem and realizing that you figured it all out all by yourself!

One tough thing about learning on your own is that you may not know whether you are solving the problems correctly. Some of the textbooks listed below have answers to selected exercises in the back of the book, but these aren’t always adequate for two reasons: (1) they often only show the solutions to the problems, and not the steps taken to get there; and (2) it’s much better to do all of the exercises rather than just a select few. The good news is that many of the solutions (and step-by-step ways to solve them) can be found online with a simple Google search. If you are going to Google the answers, however, please first try to solve the problems on your own, and try multiple times (you’re not in school trying to get a perfect grade — you’re trying to learn and understand).

And, finally, a note on learning in a laboratory vs. learning from textbooks. Physics is both an experimental and theoretical science, and while research happens in laboratories and on blackboards and computers, the majority of any physics education does not take place in a laboratory but in lecture classes that teach from textbooks and assign homework problems that are found in textbooks. Yes, there are some laboratory classes (usually at the very introductory levels, and their only purpose is to show that oh, look, Newton’s laws work in the real world after all) and some — some — undergraduates are allowed to participate in research on the side, but physics is taught through textbooks, lectures, and homework problems. Don’t believe me? Take a look at the undergraduate physics curriculum at any university that offers a physics major. Graduate programs in physics are largely the same — both M.A. and PhD programs in physics require two years of core classes — with one key difference: to get a PhD, students need to complete several years of research, a thesis, and — at many programs — take an exam to prove they have mastered the graduate core curriculum. The graduate core curriculum is all textbooks and lectures and homework problems. The textbooks listed in the curriculum I’ve written below are the same textbooks that are used in the top undergraduate and graduate physics programs in the world. Studying them will give you the same education that you would receive at one of these programs — no painfully-annoying-introductory-mechanics-laboratory-class-with-inane-group-projects required.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com