欧盟即将把我们最敏感的数据出售给美国,以换取免签旅行。
The EU is about to sell our most sensitive data to the US for visa-free travel

原始链接: https://edri.org/our-work/the-eu-is-about-to-sell-our-most-sensitive-data-to-the-us-for-visa-free-travel/

美国正向欧盟成员国施压,要求其加入“加强边境安全伙伴关系”(EBSP)。该机制将维持免签待遇与向美国政府开放各国生物识别及敏感个人数据库挂钩。 目前,双方正就此数据交换框架协议进行谈判。然而,包括欧洲数字权利组织(EDRi)在内的批评人士指出,谈判过程缺乏透明度,且达成的新协议对美方要求让步过多。泄露的草案显示,该协议缺乏欧盟法律及《欧盟基本权利宪章》所要求的必要保护措施。外界持续担忧,此类数据传输将助长过度监控和侧写,可能针对政治异见者、活动人士及边缘群体,并使旅客在美边境面临歧视性待遇和拘留。 EDRi认为,欧盟为了满足美方对不受限数据访问的需求,不惜牺牲隐私保障,未能确保同等水平的数据保护,这无异于屈服于“勒索”。倡导团体敦促欧盟领导人拒绝上述条款,认为该协议损害了欧洲的法律标准和人权。他们呼吁欧盟委员会和理事会将公民个人数据保护置于美方要求之上。

EDRi 最近的一份报告指出,欧盟可能在压力下被迫向美国共享敏感个人数据,以换取维持免签旅行的待遇。这一消息在 Hacker News 上引发了激烈的争论,主要焦点包括以下几个方面: * **必要性与隐私:** 一些用户认为,美国边境已在采集生物识别数据(照片/指纹),因此这种数据传输更像是一种实际的调整,而非监控规模的扩大。 * **“免签”的幻觉:** 批评者指出,当前的 ESTA 系统实际上就像签证一样,涉及大量的数据采集和繁琐的官僚程序,使得“免签”一词名存实亡。 * **治理与问责:** 争议的焦点之一是欧盟能否保护好公民数据。尽管一些用户担心外国势力会进行不受约束的数据访问,但也有人认为当地政府在隐私侵犯方面同样难辞其咎,欧盟表现出的担忧只是在作秀。 * **政治犬儒主义:** 许多评论者对欧盟领导层表示极度怀疑,认为官员们缺乏抗衡美国要求的筹码,而这场辩论只是为了掩盖欧盟在公民自由方面的内部政策失误。
相关文章

原文

US requires access to biometric databases to keep visa free travel

In 2022, the US government announced that it would require access to biometric databases of countries if they wish to keep visa exemption for their citizens travelling to the US, including European Union (EU) Member States. These new “Enhanced Border Security Partnerships” (EBSP) involve the automated exchange of personal data for the purposes of screening and identity verification of travellers.

While the European Commission started discussing the scheme with the US administration in 2022, it received the official mandate by the Council of the EU to lead the negotiations on behalf of Member States only in December 2025. The goal of these negotiations is to establish a “Framework Agreement” which would set out the modalities of the information exchange and general rules on processing of personal data between the US and Member States. It is on this basis that EU countries would then adopt their own bilateral EBSP agreements directly with the US (or adapt their existing arrangements).

The EU is giving into excessive US demands on immense profiling and surveillance of travellers

The US’s excessive demands for travellers’ profiling and surveillance in order to stay in its Visa Waiver Programme are nothing less than blackmail. The EU accepting the terms of this power struggle is extremely worrying for the rights of Europeans and any third country nationals registered in European databases.

The scheme implies systematic transfers of biometric data and other highly sensitive and subjective “indications of risk” based on European national databases to the US government, which has shown a blatant disregard for basic human rights in its harsh and inhumane treatment of migrants and visitors. In that regard, the draft text does nothing to protect from discrimination based on political opinions, which is worrying because the US is already cracking down political dissent, including its unlawful practice of screening travellers’ social media profiles. The sharing of individual risk assessments to supposedly protect “public security and public order” under the EBSP could further target opposition to the Trump administration, support to transgender people’s rights or protests against the genocide in Gaza expressed (publicly) on social media, with potentially significant impacts, including detention at the borders.

Furthermore it is very difficult to know the terms of the negotiations as the talks are shrouded in secrecy. However, in May 2026, EDRi member Statewatch leaked a “revised version” of the draft Framework Agreement, revealing the direction the future deal has taken.

According to EDRi’s analysis, the negotiated text seems to almost entirely reflect US demands for unfettered information access. This poses two major problems: (1) the text departs significantly from the Member States’ negotiation mandate; (2) its provisions are, in large parts, not compliant with EU primary and secondary law, notably the Charter of Fundamental Rights. Notably, they fall short of meeting EU fundamental requirement of reaching an essentially equivalent level of protection for international data transfers – something that the Court of Justice of the EU would have no doubt of and declare the agreement incompatible with EU law.

Our call to the EU: resist US pressure, protect key safeguards

EU leaders must fight to protect our fundamental rights against yet another instance of the US bullying the EU into dismantling key safeguards. A strong Europe needs a strong rulebook and our lawmakers must be focused on strengthening core protections against data exploitation and privacy violations – rather than acquiescing to the whims of the US.

EDRi recommends the Commission and the Council to push back against the US government’s blackmail and refuse to sell people’s personal data to a country with a very worrying human rights violations record and rapid democratic backsliding.

Read the open letter

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com