企业招聘网站上 28% 的职位发布已超过 90 天。
28% of job postings on company career sites have been open over 90 days

原始链接: https://unlisted.careers/ghost-jobs/report/2026-09

《2026年9月“幽灵职位”报告》基于15个求职申请跟踪系统中的607,050条招聘信息,显示近30%的招聘信息已发布超过90天。数据表明,招聘信息的中位数存续期为36天,且不同行业和平台在招聘实践上存在显著差异。 **核心发现:** * **过期招聘:** 有163,057条招聘信息(占比28.3%)发布时间超过90天,其中94,106条超过180天。 * **行业趋势:** 酒店业职位的招聘周期最长,中位存续期为65天;医疗保健业职位的流转速度最快,中位存续期为29天。 * **平台差异:** 雇主所选用的申请跟踪系统对招聘信息的存续时间影响巨大;Lever平台的过期招聘比例最高(48.2%),而Workday平台的比例最低(17.2%)。 * **流转模式:** 虽然14.6%的职位在一周内即被填补或下架,但仅有4.2%的已关闭职位会在30天内重新发布,这表明“重复发布”的招聘信息仅占整体市场的很小一部分。 该报告强调,尽管长期存在的招聘信息并不能作为“幽灵职位”的确凿证据,但它们反映了各公司在管理职业页面时所存在的系统性差异。

一份最新报告指出,28% 的招聘岗位发布超过 90 天仍未关闭,这在 Hacker News 上引发了关于现代就业市场现状的讨论。 评论者针对这些“长期挂牌”的职位提出了几种解释: * **常青岗位(Evergreen Roles):** 大型企业常因人员流动频繁或业务持续增长,针对高需求或利基岗位维持长期招聘状态。 * **监管与合规要求:** 公共部门和教育机构的职位通常在法律上要求必须公开招聘,即便内部人选已定。 * **招聘效率低下:** 部分岗位长期空缺是因为企业要求过高、薪资缺乏竞争力,或使用了无法有效筛选候选人的低效人力资源流程。 * **“幽灵职位”(Ghost Jobs):** 许多用户认为,一些公司发布虚假职位是为了向投资者展示增长态势或收集候选人数据,许多人认为这应被视为欺诈行为并加以监管。 这场讨论突显了求职者日益增长的挫败感,因为由 AI 筛选申请和 AI 生成简历所构成的招聘闭环已变得“低效且糟糕透顶”。尽管有人建议无论岗位发布多久都应尝试申请,但另一些人则警告称,在这些“招聘泥潭”中浪费时间已变得毫无意义。
相关文章

原文

Ghost Jobs Report, September 2026

Measured across 607,050 postings open on 15 applicant tracking systems, read directly from each employer's own careers site. Age uses the date the employer published, available on 95.0% of postings. The median open posting is 36 days old.

Computed September 23, 2026 from a sweep that began August 24, 2026, 29 days earlier. Closure figures are bounded by that window and say so below.

163,057

postings open more than 90 days

28.3% of the dated postings. 94,106 have been up more than 180 days.

36 days

median age of an open posting

Half the catalog was published more recently than this, by the employer's own date.

14.6%

of closed postings came down within a week

13,013 of 88,895 closures in the last 30 days. A posting that disappears in days was real.

4.2%

of closed postings were reposted within 30 days

3,915 of 94,333: same employer, same role, back as a new posting after the close.

How old the open postings are

Every dated open posting, by the time since the employer published it. The two right hand bands are what this report calls stale.

By category

Hospitality postings sit the longest: 43.9% have been open more than 90 days, median 65 days. Healthcare turns over fastest at 19.7%.

CategoryShare over 90 daysMedian ageOpen postingsSalary stated
Hospitality65 days23,63933.0%
Education56 days8,92851.5%
Other48 days61,53831.0%
Engineering46 days69,01732.5%
Design47 days4,73332.6%
Skilled trades37 days44,28344.2%
Product44 days6,68039.0%
Operations37 days40,04134.4%
HR & people35 days6,32332.0%
Logistics30 days28,88148.6%
Customer support32 days10,02346.1%
Marketing37 days12,26334.6%
Sales34 days51,09940.7%
Data34 days13,20532.9%
Finance33 days20,51735.1%
Legal34 days8,36739.4%
Retail24 days41,67751.0%
Healthcare29 days68,28347.6%

By applicant tracking system

The system an employer posts through says a lot about how its postings age. Lever boards carry the largest stale share at 48.2%; Workday the smallest at 17.2%. Pinpoint, Personio, Y Combinator publish no posting date, so their age cannot be measured and is not guessed.

SystemShare over 90 daysMedian ageOpen postings
Lever83 days1,871
BambooHR79 days64,151
Recruitee82 days596
Teamtailor64 days45,698
Rippling61 days16,339
Workable51 days5,755
Breezy55 days25,124
Ashby54 days13,899
Greenhouse47 days52,589
SmartRecruiters35 days73,024
UKG35 days51,130
Workday26 days226,520
Pinpointno posting date15,691
Personiono posting date11,018
Y Combinatorno posting date3,645

By country

The fifteen countries with the most open postings, by how their postings age and how often a salary is stated. The full thirty are in the CSV.

CountryShare over 90 daysMedian ageOpen postingsSalary stated
United States34 days334,68150.7%
United Kingdom36 days29,62936.9%
Canada36 days21,97748.8%
Germany54 days20,2863.9%
France48 days19,03015.9%
India33 days14,2871.9%
Sweden51 days11,7740.4%
Australia28 days7,87214.7%
Spain50 days6,3679.3%
Singapore37 days4,7924.2%
Brazil39 days4,15313.8%
Mexico41 days3,85817.2%
Netherlands64 days3,52527.9%
Poland42 days3,5164.2%
Italy29 days3,44642.7%

The employers with the most open postings

The twenty employers with the most postings open on their own careers site, and how many of those have been up more than 90 days. A long open posting is not proof of anything on its own: some roles are evergreen, some employers hire in volume all year. This table reports the rate and links every name to its postings so you can check them at the source. Employers appear above 50 open postings only.

EmployerOpen postingsShare over 90 daysMedian age
O'Reilly Auto Parts14,32077 days
CVS Health14,19522 days
Lowe's12,22522 days
TJX Companies10,15722 days
Accenture4,27013 days
Whataburger Restaurants4,184239 days
JLL3,76615 days
PACS Group2,78622 days
AdventHealth2,7789 days
Genuine Parts Company2,76222 days
ABB2,75721 days
Kohl's2,67023 days
Curtiss-Wright2,66723 days
Dick's Sporting Goods2,66523 days
Hitachi2,64926 days
Mercy2,63428 days
American Logistics Authority2,597308 days
Booz Allen Hamilton2,21826 days
GE Vernova2,07621 days
MUSC2,07137 days

Closures and reposts

88,895

postings removed from their employer's site in the last 30 days

14.6% came down within a week of publishing and 30.8% within two.

24 days

median time from publishing to removal

Over postings that closed in the last 90 days. Ninety percent closed within 113 days. We have watched for 29 days, so the true medians can only be longer; this is a lower bound.

4.2%

of closed postings came back within 30 days

3,915 postings closed and the same employer published the same role again. A further 4,576 open postings were closed and reopened in place.

Definitions and method

Stale
A posting the employer's own careers site has shown open for more than 90 days, counted from the date the employer published. This report never calls a single posting a ghost job. It reports rates.

Repost
A posting that closes and comes back within 30 days as a new posting for the same role at the same employer, matched on the normalized title and description.

Where the data comes from
Unlisted reads the public APIs of the applicant tracking systems employers post through, board by board, every few hours. Nothing is scraped from job boards and nothing is estimated. Every posting counted here was open on its employer's site when the report was computed.

What it cannot say
Whether an employer that keeps a posting up is still interviewing, and how long the same postings stay on LinkedIn or Indeed after they leave the source. We only see the source. Closure times are bounded by how long we have been watching, and the report says so wherever it prints one.

Download the tables

Each table on this page as a CSV, with company rows linked to their catalog page.

Quoting this report

Free to quote and reproduce with a link to this page. Suggested citation:

Unlisted, Ghost Jobs Report, September 2026. unlisted.careers/ghost-jobs/report/2026-09

Questions about the method, or a figure you want cut differently: [email protected].

The job boards show you what was posted. Unlisted shows you what is still open on the employer's own site, and tells you when it last checked.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com