退休的宾夕法尼亚大学教授因阻挡 Uber Eats 送餐机器人被捕
Retired Penn professor arrested for blocking Uber Eats robot

原始链接: https://www.phillyvoice.com/philly-woman-arrested-uber-eats-robot-protest/?l

78岁的宾夕法尼亚大学退休教授卡罗琳·马文因在费城市中心人行道上反复拒绝警方要求,继续阻挡 Uber Eats 送餐机器人,而被以扰乱秩序罪逮捕。自这些机器人于3月推出以来,马文一直习惯站在它们前面,抗议企业用机器人取代人类送餐员。她计划以第一修正案为由抗辩该指控,并表示将继续抗议,将其视为公民参与和公民责任。她形容公众反应分化——有些人支持,有些人担心顾客——但认为机器人对送餐员的影响也应引起担忧。她小心不阻挡人类行人。此次事件是她持续数月抗议中警方首次介入。Uber 拒绝置评。

一名退休的宾大教授因反复阻挡 Uber Eats 送餐机器人而被费城警方逮捕,称其抗议企业取代人类工人。HN 评论者争论这是否是值得逮捕的正当公民不服从,还是非法阻塞公共人行道。有人认为第一修正案不保护干扰机器人配送;也有人认为机器人不应与行人共享人行道,或应给行人让路。讨论还涉及对紧急配送的可能影响、机器人在法律上被归类为行人的问题,以及自动化、公共空间和负外部性等更广泛关切。总体而言,该帖凸显了抗议权与商业机器人占用人行道之间的紧张关系。
相关文章

原文

On Wednesday afternoon, Carolyn Marvin was leaving her flu shot appointment when she spotted an Uber Eats robot rolling down the Center City sidewalk. So she did what she has done for months whenever she's had the time: stand in front of it.


MORE: Penn Wood High School suspends sports programs as it reviews student safety

Marvin, 78, said she's not sure how many times she's blocked the path of these robots, which hit the streets of Philadelphia in March. The University of Pennsylvania professor emeritus has made a practice of it to protest "corporations that displace human delivery workers in order to enrich their own bottom line." Her past encounters have circulated online. The Wednesday incident was the first time, however, that the police got involved. 

Officers approached Marvin after she'd been there "quite a long time," she said. They asked her to step aside and let the robot complete its delivery. When she repeatedly refused, they arrested her for disorderly conduct.

Police confirmed they had responded to a report of "criminal mischief involving a robot" on the 1200 block of Filbert Street around 1:16 p.m. on Wednesday. A woman on the scene ignored "multiple commands" to move, they said, resulting in a criminal violation notice for disorderly conduct.

Uber declined to comment.

Marvin, who plans to contest the charge on the grounds of her First Amendment right to protest, has been undeterred by the arrest. She plans to continue blocking Uber Eats robots and chatting with curious passersby who ask what she's doing.

"It allows me to talk to people about what's going on," she said. "It's always very interesting conversations that we have, and I think it's good to have those kinds of conversations in public space."

Marvin characterizes public opinion as "divided." Some people are very supportive, she said, while others view her protest as unfair to the customers who paid for delivery. Marvin usually tells them if they're "concerned about money," the robots' impact on delivery workers should worry them, too. She is careful never to block the sidewalk to human pedestrians, she added.

Before Marvin retired, she taught a course on freedom of expression at Penn. She doesn't see her actions as an extension of her academic work, however, as much as civic engagement.

"I would say it's my citizenship," she said. "I'm exercising the rights of my citizenship, so I think of it in those terms."


Follow Kristin & PhillyVoice on Twitter: @kristin_hunt | @thePhillyVoice
Like us on Facebook: PhillyVoice
Have a news tip? Let us know.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com