我的 AI 代理发现了一个未被标绘的玛雅遗址
My AI agents found an unmapped Maya site?

原始链接: https://pietromiotti.com/latest/maya-site

在秘鲁旅行时,作者让AI代理利用公开激光雷达搜索未发现的玛雅遗址。代理扫描了约1200平方公里,发现一个山丘顶部遗址,包括广场、金字塔、庭院和可能的水库,并发现它不在INAH登记册中。作者发送报告;INAH回复那里没有登记遗址。作者最初以为是新发现,但后来得知考古学家已在Estrada-Belli等人2025年的研究中绘制了该遗址;只是尚未录入INAH登记册。该遗址可能是一座古典期玛雅城市中心。作者认为,自主AI能加速编码之外的研究,且缺乏经验的外部人员加算力可以重新发现或补充专家工作。

一篇 Hacker News 帖子强调一位 Google 软件工程师使用 48 个 AI 代理扫描 NASA 激光雷达数据,据报道在 72 小时内发现一座未被记录的玛雅金字塔。评论者对 AI 在海量数据集中发现模式的能力及其跨学科潜力感到兴奋,而另一些人则呼吁谨慎:发现需要专家考古验证,AI 输出可能产生幻觉,公开具体地点可能吸引盗掘者并给有限的发掘资源带来压力。一些人指出激光雷达和 AI 工具已在考古学中开始出现,且仅检测本身有价值,但需要逐层仔细研究。怀疑者质疑作者的验证过程和自我宣传语气,而另一些人则认为这是 AI 的真正有用应用。总体而言,该讨论串反映了在验证、保护和负责任披露方面的担忧下被调和的热情。
相关文章

原文

Update (11 November): it turns out the site had already been mapped in Estrada-Belli et al. 2025. The agents missed it while going through the literature, so they rediscovered it rather than discovered it (it just wasn't in the register of Mexico's National Institute of Anthropology and History, INAH, yet). Still work to do then! The rest of the story still holds.

By analyzing NASA lidar data, my AI agents found a Maya site in Mexico that wasn't in the official register. (It turned out archaeologists had mapped it already, more on that at the end.) It took less than 72 hours to go from a random thought while traveling to an official reply from the Mexican government. This is by far the best time ever to be alive.

Drag the slider. The same hilltop today from a satellite (just trees) and in lidar (no trees). Colours show height. Satellite © Esri, Maxar, Earthstar Geographics.

Disclaimer: I'm not an archaeologist.

I'm going to tell this story as a diary, because the timeline is probably the best part.

18 October

I was traveling in Peru, Gemini-ing about the history of the place, when I learned about Hiram Bingham, the American explorer who "discovered" Machu Picchu in 1911. "What luck!" I thought. He was actually looking for a different city, Vilcabamba, the last refuge of the Incas, when a local farmer in the valley below guided him to the ruins. "Imagine if Bingham had our tools," I thought. "What would he do?"

Left: Bingham at his tent, 1912. Right: Machu Picchu, photographed by Bingham the same year. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons (left, right).

I brainstormed a bit with a few agents (Gemini, ChatGPT, Claude and Grok), and they all said lidar. From above, a ruin in the jungle is just a bunch of trees (like Machu Picchu before it was cleared), so satellite photos don't help much. Lidar, instead, fires laser pulses through the gaps in the canopy and maps the ground underneath.

So the agents went looking for lidar data. Peru isn't well covered, and hiring a company to do a survey meant permits, costs and bureaucracy, so I gave up on that. Then I thought: why not the Maya? Their region is much better covered by public lidar.

That night, I asked the agents to analyze it and went to bed.

19 October

I woke up and checked the agents' reports. 'DAMN!' They had found lots of villages and other regular shapes that looked like structures or houses.

Grid of eight bare-earth lidar views of Maya sites flagged by the agents
A few of the sites the agents flagged overnight. Keep an eye on the bottom-left one.

So how did they do it? They turned the lidar strips (about 1,200 km² of jungle) into images, and 48 agents went through them one by one like very patient archaeologists, looking for pyramids, platforms, and plazas while filtering out natural hills, sinkholes, and roads. There was no special model or classifier involved: the agents literally looked at the pictures, following a precise guide.

Me: That's awesome! Please check which of these villages haven't been discovered yet. Search both the literature and the archives.

…a few hours later…

Agent: One major village doesn't seem to have been registered.

This is the hilltop from the top of this post. It sits on the edge of a cliff, under the jungle, and it has straight edges and sharp corners. Nature doesn't really do straight lines.

Zooming in, there's a levelled plaza, an oval pyramid at least 8–12 m tall, a raised courtyard attached to it and a flat-bottomed hollow that might have been a water reservoir.

Bare-earth lidar of the whole hilltop, with a zoom into the civic centre below: plaza, pyramid, raised courtyard and possible reservoir
The hilltop with the trees removed (top), and a zoom into its civic centre (bottom).

And this is what it looks like in 3D.

Me: OK, what should I do?

Agent: You should contact INAH (Mexico's National Institute of Anthropology and History), write a report on your discovery, and check whether the site is in their register. Sometimes they have unpublished results.

Me: OK, how do I contact INAH? How does the reporting process work?

Agent: …instructions for the report… + email addresses

Me: OK, please do the report.

And I went to bed.

20 October

I iterated on the report a bit, since a few things were off, and translated it into Spanish to improve the chances of getting a reply (at least, that's what Claude suggested). I don't speak Spanish, so I had to trust the agents on that one.

The agents also checked the raw point cloud, to make sure the shapes were really on the ground and not created by the trees. Green dots are leaves, brown dots are the ground.

Point-cloud slices across the site: vegetation returns in green, ground returns in brown
Two slices through the raw lidar points. Under 10–17 m of forest, the ground (brown) traces the plaza, the pyramid and the courtyard.

Then I sent the report to INAH.

First page of the report sent to INAH
The top of my letter to INAH. The exact coordinates went in a confidential annex, not shown here.

21 October

INAH replied: they checked their records and found no registered archaeological site at that location.

INAH's official reply
INAH's reply. The highlighted part: "…no registered archaeological site was identified at the location given in your report."

At that point I thought nobody had put it on a map before. I was wrong (see below).

So what was it?

This part is speculation, from a long chat with the agents. It looks like a small Maya civic centre from the Classic period (roughly AD 250–900), basically the "downtown" of a local elite. The plaza is where people gathered, for ceremonies and maybe even a market. The pyramid was probably a temple, and the raised courtyard next to it might have been where the local ruler lived. The hollow could have been an aguada, a rainwater reservoir: Maya towns needed them to get through the dry season. Or it's just a hole. The three platforms around were probably houses.

I asked Gemini to imagine how it looked back then:

AI-generated artist's impression of the site in the Classic period: a plaza, a small pyramid and a courtyard on a forested clifftop, with thatched houses around
How it might have looked around AD 700. Generated with Gemini from the lidar layout

For similar studies, have a look at how NASA's G-LiHT instrument works (Cook et al. 2013) and how lidar collected for environmental research can be reused for archaeology (Golden et al. 2016). In 2024, archaeologists found a whole Maya city in Mexico this way (Auld-Thomas et al. 2024), others mapped settlements across the Maya lowlands, including this very site (Estrada-Belli et al. 2025), and another study found what may have been ancient Maya marketplaces (Šprajc 2026).

What's next

The site is now in the hands of the people who should have it: Mexico's National Institute of Anthropology and History (INAH) and the archaeologists who mapped it first. If anything comes out of it, I'll post an update.

What I've learned

You can just do things. I'm not an archaeologist, so I didn't know this was supposed to be hard. I just picked an old problem, tried the most obvious thing and threw some compute at it. Being a naive outsider might be a superpower now.

And it turned out professional archaeologists had already mapped the same site. I guess that's a good sign: an outsider with agents ended up in a similar place to the experts.

And I don't think this is really about archaeology. So far, most agentic AI stories have been about coding, math and physics, but it's much more general than that, and I hope this small example makes it a bit more obvious. We are on the brink of a revolution in all the sciences, and the only bottlenecks left will be curiosity and imagination (and compute).

At this point, we should probably lidar the whole planet and let the agents discover the rest.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com