先发制人
First Strike

原始链接: https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2026/11/13/first-strike.html

作者警告,中国十年内电力可能达到美国的十倍,因此战略必须考虑能源。他们提议美国向中国出售AI芯片,用收入快速扩大太阳能、电池和电力容量,因为算力取决于电力;结合机器人、人才、商业文化和土地,这可能使两国受益。相反,他们看到危险的短期零和AI竞赛思维。这场竞赛可能只有在超级智能实现斩首式先发制人时才会结束,作者对此表示怀疑并担心可能造成灾难。国有化英伟达增加了他们对迫在眉睫的第三次世界大战的感知风险。

Hacker News 帖子“First Strike”链接至 geohot.github.io,讨论美国能源与对华 AI 竞争。帖文主张美国应向中国出售 AI 芯片,再用所得收益购买太阳能与电池工厂,快速扩大电力产能。评论者辩论在中国人口更多的背景下其发电增长是否有意义,并列举美国扩张的障碍,如许可审批、邻避主义、关税、工会和基础设施成本。其他讨论涵盖核电、太阳能间歇性、电池、抽水蓄能、往复式发动机,以及在算力或能源约束下的创新。部分人批评对数据中心进行军事打击的言论过于鹰派,另一些人则质疑芯片出售提案的经济逻辑。总体而言,该帖聚焦能源基础设施、产业政策与地缘 AI 竞争。
相关文章

原文

Internalize this graph, we post it on this blog a lot. If trends continue, China will have 10x the electricity of the US in 10 years. Whenever you think about geopolitical strategy, always keep it in mind, because whatever your plans are must consider this.


Here’s a strategy that would make sense for America long term. Sell as many AI chips into China as possible, use the money to purchase solar panel and battery factories, and build out electricity capacity as quickly as possible. Fundamentally, compute is a function of electricity. That’s the sort of long term thinking that gives America a chance. With robotic labor, immigrants like Jensen and Elon, a business friendly culture, and an incredible chunk of land, it’s not so clear who is ahead in 50 years. Regardless, I do know this strategy would lead to massive prosperity for the citizens of both countries.

However, that’s not close to what we see happening. We see a lot of short term zero sum thinking in action. It’s very scary what the US “AI race” mentality leads to. When exactly does the race end? Whatever capabilities you have today will eventually be matched, unless…

…you believe that you can use ASI in a decapitating first strike.


I’m worried that this is what these people see as the only way out.

It probably doesn’t work, can you outthink steel and drone production? I don’t see how, see my critiques here. But I’m not totally sure, I’m not a superintelligence. And if it does work, that may be the end.

My likelihood of imminent WWIII went up a lot with the nationalization of NVIDIA.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com