Biographers do not advertise themselves as mediums. Still, the fantasy is there—that a book’s subject will rise from its pages, like some stranded ghost, to clap one hand on the writer’s shoulder and the other on the reader’s. It is a fantasy that imparts romance to the work of intruding on the dead: flattering the family, interrogating the neighbors and lovers, sorting through mostly useless documents in the archive. Left unchecked, however, it can turn a biographer into a sentimental illusionist. He touches a finger’s smudge on a letter. He walks into a bedroom and sniffs the air. He seems to see the man himself: his features fine and lined, his white shirt unbuttoned at the top of his chest, his mouth open, as if about to speak.
I am looking at the photograph on the cover of Tom Overton’s “John Berger: From Life,” the second biography of the British art critic and novelist that Verso Books has published since his death, in 2017. The first, Joshua Sperling’s “A Writer of Our Time” (2018), was a brisk study that appraised Berger as a leftist popularizer of the Western tradition in art. Berger made his reputation as a critic by the age of twenty-five, asserting himself in contrast to the patrician figures of his era. A friend recalled how he would pull up to gallery openings on his motorcycle, cigarette dangling from his fingers and “lips always poised for utterance”—against private collectors, museums, and the cold, cerebral designs of abstract art, and for the people, the land, and largely realist paintings of the human body. Berger argued that art should be for everyone, rich or poor, no matter their country or creed. His low, deliberate voice could be heard over the radio and on television—most notably, in the BBC series “Ways of Seeing”—a gorgeous man with a startling impudence of gesture. In the first episode of “Ways of Seeing,” he held a knife and appeared to carve Venus’s head out of Botticelli’s “Venus and Mars.” The series united the country in the simultaneous acts of looking at him and listening to him deliver his judgments. He became known, Overton writes, as “the thrusting, tieless Marxist taking the tweedy establishment down a peg or two.”
This month marks the centennial of Berger’s birth, with numerous events arranged to celebrate his enduring influence. Overton’s biography arrives on the heels of Verso’s the Essential John Berger, thirteen reissues of various novels and essay collections. To pick through this haul is to realize that Berger’s reputation rests not on a single, incomparable novel, and not even on his sizable and varied œuvre, but on a kind of attitude, adopted since his earliest reviews were published, in the nineteen-fifties. For Berger, the artist did not simply perceive the world; the world trained the artist’s perceptions, teaching him what to look at, from what perspectives, and in what proportions. The artist, in turn, could wield his brush against the world’s accepted values, its tendency to see people from a unitary, fixed perspective. He could paint “old, tired prostitutes” (Toulouse-Lautrec), “holy humble peasants” (Millet), or “the great sexual image of the nude” (Giorgione, Rembrandt, Watteau, Courbet) so that the viewer would glimpse these subjects from an odd angle, with tenderness and clarity. Berger formulated an idiosyncratic notion of Marxist criticism: an evaluation of an artist’s greatness based on whether his creations could “encourage men to know and claim their social rights.”
In reading Berger, one discovers that his Marxist aesthetic is less a doctrine than a vague and ennobling justification for why he liked the art that he did. What makes Berger special are, as he wrote about Picasso, “not his individual works, but his existence, his personality,” his “new ways of looking at the world.” Berger was an ideologue; most charismatic people are. As they age, they risk shrivelling into preachers or bores. Berger was saved from this fate by his restless searching, among mediums and forms, for the purest expression of his way of seeing. His novels, in particular, drew inspiration from Cubism’s use of overlapping perspectives to arrive at a collective sense of reality. In “A Painter of Our Time” (1958), an artist’s enigmatic journal entries are annotated by an art-critic friend. “G.” (1972), which won the Booker Prize, is the story of a seducer, presented in a collage of memories, histories, essays, sheet music, and naughty doodles. The blind narrator of “To the Wedding” (1995) has splintered visions of a father, a mother, and their daughter, who is dying of AIDS. A woman writes anguished letters to her imprisoned lover in “From A to X” (2008). These novels concern very different characters, in very different times and places. But their common subject is human perception, in all its variousness and instability—what Berger heralded as “the functioning of sight itself.”