Nvidia 在 Jensen Huang 事件之前就已陷入困境
Nvidia was in trouble before the Jensen Huang mess

原始链接: https://www.wired.com/story/nvidia-was-already-in-trouble-before-the-jensen-huang-mess/

黄的倒台部分源于其与中国的关系,包括与 Megaspeed(一家被怀疑是中国情报资产的公司,曾进口数十亿美元的英伟达芯片,并可能将这些芯片转给中国 AI 公司)的中国高管黄乐的浪漫关系。 分析师 Babak Minovi 为黄在华市场准入上的务实立场辩护。与此同时,英伟达面临新的威胁:它所助力发展的 AI 模型现在正在自动化芯片设计,更关键的是,能够快速将代码移植到竞争对手的硬件上,从而削弱英伟达的 CUDA 软件护城河。创业公司 Wafer 通过在更便宜的 AMD 芯片上快速运行开源模型,体现了这一趋势。 芯片分析师 Dan Hutchinson 警告称,英伟达可能正在经历其“英特尔天鹅时刻”——从工程导向转向销售导向、官僚体系膨胀、收入下降——并与英特尔 2019 年的领导层变动相呼应。Hutchinson 结论是,英伟达正在成为“一个等待发生的英特尔”。

Hacker News 的讨论围绕一篇 Wired 文章展开,内容是 Nvidia 在黄仁勋个人丑闻之前就已面临困境。评论者争论 Nvidia 的主导地位是否会随着专用 AI 芯片(ASIC、TPU、Trainium)的改进而削弱,类似于加密货币挖矿。一些人认为 Nvidia 的护城河不仅在于 CUDA,还在于已安装的产能、台积电带宽以及缺乏真正的竞争;另一些人则指出 Google 的 TPU 更高效但未公开提供。讨论还涉及 Taalas 将模型“印刷”到硅片、Cerebras 的晶圆级方案,以及模型变化是否过快而不适合 ASIC。许多人认为股价下跌反映的是泡沫担忧和获利了结,而非技术威胁,还有人指控循环融资和 GPU 闲置。其他人则为 Nvidia 的强健地位辩护,指出芯片设计需要数年,且竞争对手面临制造约束。董事会治理和继任规划失败受到批评,还有人指控该丑闻被用来在权力斗争中把黄仁勋排挤出去。总体而言,意见在 Nvidia 的长期主导地位与即将来临的颠覆之间分化。
相关文章

原文

Huang’s dealings with China played a major role in his downfall. He had a romantic relationship with Huang Le, also known as Alice Huang, a Chinese executive at a Singaporean company called Megaspeed who the US government suspects of being an asset of China’s Ministry of State Security. Megaspeed and its subsidiaries have reportedly imported between $4.6 and $7.5 billion Nvidia chips into southeast Asia. Reports suggest that the company may have provided access to the chips to Chinese AI firms.

Babak Minovi, a senior analyst at the Eurasia Group, a consultancy that focuses on technology and geopolitics, says Huang was right to point out that cutting off access to China would empower domestic rivals. “Huang was taking a pragmatic line, and he knows competition,” he says.

Even in markets that it dominates, Nvidia may turn out to be a victim of its own success. The AI models built using Nvidia’s chip are automating the very elements of coding, data analysis, and scientific research that help design chips.

Most chip design firms use specialized AI models to arrange components on processors—something that traditionally required deep engineering expertise and experience. And both OpenAI and Anthropic have recently touted the ability of their newest models to design electronics from scratch.

Moorhead says the shift towards AI chip design may not pose a huge threat to Nvidia because it’s riding the same wave. “They have access to AI too,” he notes.

But Moorhead says the way AI models can now quickly rewrite code to run on different hardware may prove a problem. For years, Nvidia has attracted developers by providing software that makes it easy to write programs and build models for its silicon. Its Compute Unified Device Architecture, or CUDA, has long been seen as a moat to ensure AI companies continue to rely on Nvidia chips.

But AI models are now so good at reading and writing code that they can port an AI model over to a competitor's silicon at speed.

Wafer, a startup that uses AI to port models to AMD and then serves them more cheaply, has seen revenue grow spectacularly in recent months, boasts CEO Emilio Andere.

Every time a major new open weight model is released Wafer can have it running on AMD hardware at least 80 percent as efficiently within hours, he says. Andere says AI is getting so capable that his engineers barely have to edit or review the code.

Dan Hutchinson, a veteran chip analyst, says Nvidia may be entering its “Intel swan moment,” referring to the 2019 replacement of engineering-focused CEO Brian Krzanich with its CFO Bob Swan. (Sound familiar? Krzanich also resigned after a relationship with an employee; Huang is alleged to have had multiple.) From there, the company’s focus shifted to sales more than technical progress. Bureaucracy ballooned and revenue tanked.

“Nvidia is now an Intel waiting to happen,” he says.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com