人工智能正在毁掉 All About Berlin
AI is killing All About Berlin

原始链接: https://nicolasbouliane.com/blog/death-by-ai

All About Berlin 的作者表示,他自2017年运营、自2020年起以此为生的网站因 Google AI Overviews 流量下降了70–75%。Google 现在把广告和AI生成的答案放在链接之前,减少了访问量和收入。影响不仅是经济上的:政府办公室会推荐这些指南,移民局也使用其中的数据,并且它启发了门户网站和类似网站。其他网站所有者也报告了类似困境,有的对内容收费或放弃更新。Google 计划让AI答案完全取代搜索结果,包括广告。作者正在准备另一种支付房租的方式,并邀请受影响者联系他。

一篇 Hacker News 帖子讨论 Google 的 AI 概览如何减少对“All About Berlin”(一个 niche 移民指南)及类似创作者网站的流量。作者表示,随着 AI 答案总结他的内容,搜索带来的收入下降,威胁到网站的全职维护。评论者意见不一:有人认为 AI 是有用的进步,创作者必须适应;有人则认为大公司正在无偿占用他人创作,破坏搜索与内容生态系统,并在来源消失后冒着信息过时、质量下降的风险。主题包括版权、垄断力量、平台衰败、广告支持型网页衰落、付费墙、本地 AI、监管,以及 AI 公司是否会补偿创作者。有人建议替代收入(咨询、新闻简报、资助、直接社区),也有人指出 Google 的 AI 摘要可能适得其反,因为它同时减少了点击和广告收入。总体而言,该帖子反映了对 AI 影响独立网页发布以及更广泛劳动岗位替代的焦虑。
相关文章

原文
Posted on
All About Berlin traffic: 7 years of growth, then a sharp decline after Google AI Overviews

This is the traffic to All About Berlin, the website that I run since 2017, and live from since 2020. After 7 years of growth, it has lost 70% 75% of its traffic to Google AI Overviews.

When you Googled something, you used to get a link to my website. Now you get a page of ads, then an AI-generated answer trained on my content, then finally a link to my website. This has a devastating impact on traffic.

First result on Google Search, below sponsored results
What it means to be first on Google

It’s hard to fund my work with only a quarter of my audience. Soon, I will need another way to pay my rent. Instead of writing new guides, I already spend my days preparing for that future.

It’s not just about the money. I have poured 8 years of my life into making something good and useful. Strangers’ faces light up when they learn that I run All About Berlin. Local and federal government offices refer people to my guides. The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves. It inspired two government portals and a few similar websites in other cities.

If my work just get mixed into an AI-generated answer, I lose my voice and my audience. My carefully chosen words lose their meaning. No one shakes my hand and buys me a beer. No one tells me how their citizenship application went.

This is not an isolated case. Many website owners have reached out in private to commiserate. Some have paywalled their work. Others have given up and moved on. They keep the websites online, but they no longer update them. It’s just not worth it.

It will get worse. Last week, Google has made two announcements: AI-generated answers will replace search results entirely, and they have ads in them. This is the future of the internet. No websites, just a chat box with ads.

I don’t know where All About Berlin fits in that future.

AI-generated responses with ads

This was also discussed on Mastodon, Hacker News, LinkedIn and Twitter. If you are affected, reach out. Let me know how you are doing. You are not going through this alone.


Mentions:

Similar stories:

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com