幻灯片更少,龙更多
Fewer slides, more dragons

原始链接: https://www.breakingchange.blog/p/fewer-slides-more-dragons

作者不再花数小时与幻灯片 decks struggle;作者禁止使用幻灯片,并用 AI 构建用于演示和破冰的交互式、氛围编程网页。例子包括:包豪斯主题策略解释器、用于高管简报的行星系统、协作式技术负责人村庄和交互式节日交换。这些形式比传统幻灯片更能吸引注意力,让会议更有趣、更高效,并允许观众会后探索内容。协作也得到改善,因为贡献者可以用智能体添加想法而不破坏模板,而 AGENTS.md 文件帮助他人理解并扩展项目。工作流程很简单:从一个想法开始,向智能体请求概念选项,选择一个,完善视觉风格,构建并迭代,然后让贡献变得容易。作者总结,AI 可以让演示和破冰游戏这类常规任务比幻灯片更富创意、更具吸引力、更高效。

一篇 Hacker News 讨论帖围绕用多彩、AI 辅助的交互式演示替代传统幻灯片展开。评论者看法分化:一些人认为趣味性与吸引人的形式能改善团队协作与观众注意力,尤其在非技术或混合语境的场合;另一些人警告,炫目的演示可能遮蔽信息、暗示优先级混乱,并变得噱头化或成为 AI 生成的“垃圾内容”;还有人捍卫简单的幻灯片或文本,认为清晰、结构与演讲者准备比装饰更重要。总体结论是,演示格式应契合观众与目的,新奇性应谨慎使用,而非替代清晰沟通。
相关文章

原文

Here’s a familiar sight that could send a typical tech manager into hours of procrastination and avoidant behavior:

It starts with a simple ask for a meeting or a presentation. No matter how pretty the template is, as soon as you decide you need “some slides,” you find yourself slinking down a path of obsessive pixel-pushing.

And it gets worse when inevitably you need a coworker to contribute some content. One understandably tries to cram as much text as possible into their space in 6pt font, while another (maybe a designer) prefers short sentences with bold words. You now get to make these look like they belong in the same presentation.

Five hours later, you have the perfect build, with diagrams and animations to make your slides more compelling, educational, and memorable. As you gaze upon your mediocre masterpiece, you wonder whether those hours were worth it.

You still need to communicate information with clarity, but maybe the medium has to change.

At Stripe, I have been accused of saying that we should ban slides. I may have said these words in anger after the fourth meeting of the week where my slides’ colors were slightly wrong because someone had pasted them in and had “matched styles in this presentation.” Most of the time, this may be an eyesore but doesn’t really matter; in this case, my green “on track” status badge had morphed into a dull yellow in the new theme.

I may not have meant it, but it’s an interesting provocation, especially when AI makes the alternatives much cheaper. Sometimes you have to take away the rotary phones to get people to use new technology.

So, I decided to try banning myself from creating slides for any reason, forcing myself to use AI to create interactive presentations instead.

Without much effort (and in under 30 minutes), you can create a Bauhaus-themed interactive strategy explainer…

Or a planetary system explaining what your team does…

This experiment has been surprisingly successful. Tired and busy Zoom brains might immediately check out when they see a slide deck, but a planetary system! Wow! That catches their attention long enough to get your point across, making meetings much more fun and efficient. And after the meeting, you can send them a link to explore the solar system on their own time. They may accidentally internalize your key points as they’re playing around with it. 🙂

With traditional slide decks, collaboration feels like a burden. Someone might mess up your template, or use the wrong font. At the end of the day, despite your efforts, slides made by different people who own just one section will likely result in a jarring experience (or at best a “mid” experience).

On the other hand, everyone has fun building low-stakes, vibe-coded webpages together. I can ask my agent to fix the layout instead of moving everything around myself. I found that after folks see others doing it, they do it themselves because it saves time while allowing them to be more creative.

Moving towards the extreme end of collaboration, I created a village of cross-org tech leads as an icebreaker exercise for an onsite. I was nervous about how it’d go given how many humans and their agents were contributing, but folks seemed to enjoy vibe-adding themselves to our tech lead village, and an old, non-AI innovation called git kept everyone’s contributions manageable.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com