比尔·马赫对使用“受害者或加害者”还原论的“进步”迎合感到愤怒
Bill Maher's Pissed Off At 'Progressive' Pandering Using "Victims Or Victimizers" Reductivism

原始链接: https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/bill-mahers-pissed-progressive-pandering-using-victims-or-victimizers-reductivism

喜剧演员兼电视主持人比尔·马赫 (Bill Maher) 在他的 HBO 节目《实时》(Real Time) 最近的一集中对有关西方文明及其明显缺陷的当代叙事提出了挑战。 马赫特别反对过度简单化,这种过度简单化在评估社会对现代价值观的贡献时经常将社会描绘成受害者或施害者,并批评进步的专家和学术学者忽视或忽视西方社会发展起来的利益和原则,包括个人自由、宗教自由、 妇女权利、人权、民主制度、法治和科学。 此外,马赫将以色列国家视为与西方核心价值观紧密结合的国家的例子,表明全球拥有更多这样的国家将改善全世界的社会状况。 最后,马赫敦促听众采用更全面的视角,考虑整个西方历史中存在的优点和缺点,而不是仅仅关注其所谓的缺点。

相关文章

原文

In his characteristic blunt and provocative style, Bill Maher recently tackled the apparently contentious topic of Western civilization and its role in shaping modern values, during a segment on his HBO show "Real Time."

He passive aggressively challenges the increasingly negative narrative surrounding Western culture, particularly among progressives and academics, arguing that Western civilization has been instrumental in developing liberal values:

"Western civilization is what gave the world pretty much every goddamn liberal precept that liberals are supposed to adore."

His position - as he has repeatedly done over the past few years - is a stark contrast to the current trend, from so-called progressives, of demonizing Western history and achievements including "Individual liberty, scientific inquiry, rule of law, religious freedom, women's rights, human rights, democracy, trial by jury, freedom of speech."

Focusing on Israel, Maher highlighted it as an exemplar of Western values in the Middle East, suggesting that the world could benefit from more nations embracing the Western ideals that Israel represents. Sure to stir the blood of every pandering political activist, Maher calmly stated that:

"...since one can find all these concepts in today's Israel and virtually nowhere else in the Middle East, if anything, the world would be a better place if it had more Israels."

Maher swiftly moves on to destroy the current socio-political movements that often view Western civilization solely through the lens of oppression and colonialism, lamenting that the oversimplified categorization of nations and cultures as either "victims or victimizers", arguing that this viewpoint ignores the positive impact of Western ideals, "so Israel is lumped in as the toxic fruit of the victimizing West."

Challenging this binary and idiot-level reductivist narrative prevalent in today's mainstream media and 'protests', Maher exclaims:

"The irony being that all marginalized people live better today because of Western ideals, not in spite of them."

Going further back in time, Maher points out that Western Enlightenment ideals have profoundly influenced global human rights and governance, mentioning figures like Thoreau, Rousseau, and Locke, and challenges the notion that Western history is predominantly negative with a controversial example:

"The cop who murdered George Floyd got 21 years for violating his Fourth Amendment rights, an idea we got directly from John Locke, who no one in college would ever study anymore because he's so old, and so White, and so dead."

Finally, given the increasing refusal to recognize Western historical figures and their contributions, Maher calls for a more balanced view of Western civilization, criticizing the tendency to overlook its contributions while magnifying its flaws. He questioned the double standards in historical assessments, asking, "Why is it that every other culture gets a pass, but the West is exclusively the sum of the worst things it’s ever done?"

We suspect his calls for a more nuanced understanding of Western history, that acknowledges both its achievements and failures, will fall on deaf ears. And as he concludes, it appears he thinks so too...

"America only ever overcorrects, and so we're at this place now where the words 'Western Civ' became kind of a shorthand for 'White people ruined everything'..."

But, he pauses amid the crowd's cheers and applause, "they didn't ruin everything..."

"Why is it that every other culture gets a pass, but the West is exclusively the sum of the worst things it's ever done? You think only White people colonized?"

Watch the full monologue below on X (since we would not be surprised if such blasphemy has been removed from other 'less free' social media platforms):

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com