法国计划对超级富豪征税以进行军事重整——英国可能是下一个。
France plots tax on super-rich to rearm – and Britain could be next

原始链接: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/france-tax-super-wealthy-fund-defence-bill-britain-next/

十月份,一场跨党派运动兴起,倡导对资产超过1000万英镑的个人征收2%的财富税,得到包括约翰·麦克唐奈和杰里米·科尔宾在内的十几位工党议员的支持。这项提案旨在解决财富不平等问题,但在资金用途上出现了内部分歧。 工党议员布莱恩·利什曼等支持者则主张利用这笔税收来加强NHS和教育等重要公共服务,但他明确反对将资金用于国防。利什曼强调优先投资于人民和社区,而不是军事支出,这与托尼·本恩“用于杀人的人力物力也应该用于救人”的观点不谋而合。 尽管工党在上次选举前曾否决财富税,但新冠肺炎疫情等先例表明,政府可以在国家紧急情况下修改竞选承诺。这增加了未来国防危机可能促使重新考虑财富税提案的可能性。

Hacker News正在讨论法国为军备重新武装而对超级富豪征税的可能性,引发了对其有效性和潜在后果的辩论。一些用户引用了类似税收的历史失败案例,例如奥朗德的75%税率,导致财富外流和收入微薄。另一些人则认为这对于自卫是合理的,并且可以重新分配财富。 人们担心拉弗曲线效应,用户指出,由于税收原因,百万富翁已经离开英国,而税收负担可能落在“专业人士”身上。一些人提出了替代方案,例如土地价值税或更高的遗产税。一位用户认为瑞士的低税率可以归因于该国低的失业率。 反驳意见认为,超级富豪的离开可能会释放住房,并且与留下并纳税的人相比,离开的百万富翁数量微不足道。一位用户批评了欧洲的“社会福利制度”,并提倡社会改革。

原文

Back in October, a dozen Labour MPs joined a cross-party campaign for a levy on the nation’s “extreme wealth”.

Politicians joined the likes of former shadow chancellor, John McDonnell, and former leader, Jeremy Corbyn, now an independent MP, in demanding a 2pc tax on those with assets worth more than £10m.

However, when contacted by The Telegraph, one of the MPs who backed the campaign scoffed at the idea of using its proceeds to fund war.

Brian Leishman, a Labour MP for Alloa and Grangemouth, said: “I am absolutely in favour of a wealth tax, but I would want to see it put towards vital public services, the NHS and education. I wouldn’t necessarily support it being used for defence, but they’ve got to invest in people and communities rather than bombs.

“To borrow the Tony Benn comment, if there’s money to afford to kill people, there’s got to be money to help people. I think we should be spending money on other things as opposed to bombs and guns.”

Prior to last year’s general election, the party specifically ruled out imposing a wealth tax.

However, previous national emergencies such as the Covid-19 pandemic have seen governments tear up campaign promises. Should a new crisis emerge around defence, it is possible this could happen again.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com