(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43417885

Hacker News 正在讨论 OpenAI 的新模型 o1-pro,其 API 价格为 100 万输入 tokens 150 美元,100 万输出 tokens 600 美元。用户认为价格过高,尽管一位用户报告说该模型在大型代码库上使用简单的提示就能展现令人印象深刻的 bug 查找能力。 人们担心该模型的知识截止日期为 2023 年,上下文窗口为 20 万个 token。一些人认为,其成本接近熟练人工的成本,这引发了人们对其价值的质疑。许多评论都集中在价格过高,以至于限制了其应用,或阻止了用于训练更廉价模型的合成数据生成(OpenAI 的服务条款禁止这样做)。一位用户表示,即使价格很高,它也比支付软件工程师完成某些特定任务更便宜。


原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
OpenAI's o1-pro now available via API (platform.openai.com)
20 points by davidbarker 1 hour ago | hide | past | favorite | 17 comments










Pricing: $150 / 1M input tokens, $600 / 1M output tokens. (Not a typo.)

Very expensive, but I've been using it with my ChatGPT Pro subscription and it's remarkably capable. I'll give it 100,000 token codebases and it'll find nuanced bugs I completely overlooked.

(Now I almost feel bad considering the API price vs. the price I pay for the subscription.)



Is your prompt {$codebase} find bugs?


Typically something like:

  Look carefully through my codebase and identify any bugs/issues, or refactors that could improve it.

  
Doesn't have to be anything overly complicated to get good results. It also does well if you give it a git diff.


It has a 2023 knowledge cut-off, and 200k context window... ? That's pretty underwhelming.


On the positive side, the cutoff date probably makes it a lot more upbeat.


Seems underwhelming when openai's best model, o3, was demoed almost 4 months ago.


Assuming a highly motivated office worker spends 6 hours per day listening or speaking, at a salary of $160k per year, that works out to a cost of ≈$10k per 1M tokens.

OpenAI is now within an order of magnitude of a highly skilled humans with their frontier model pricing. o3 pro may change this but at the same time I don’t think they would have shipped this if o3 was right around the corner.



If you start paying someone and give them some onboarding docs, to a first approximation they'll start doing the job and you'll get value.

If you attach a credit card to o3 and give it some onboarding docs, it'll give you a nice summary of your onboarding docs that you didn't need.

We're a long way from a model doing arbitrary roles. Currently at the very minimum, you need a competent office worker to run the model, filter its output through their judgement, and act on it.



At first I thought, great, we can add it now to our platform. Now that I have seen the price, I am hesitant enabling the model for the majority of users (except rich enterprises) as they will most certainly shoot themselves in the foot.


> they will most certainly shoot themselves in the foot

...and then ask you for a refund or service credit.



> $150/Mtok input, $600/Mtok output

What use case could possibly justify this price?



Synthetic data generation. You can have a really powerful, expensive model create evals so you can tune a faster, cheaper system with similar performance.


You could do that, but OpenAI specifically doesn't want you to: https://openai.com/policies/row-terms-of-use/

What you cannot do. You may not use our Services for any illegal, harmful, or abusive activity. For example, you may not: Use Output to develop models that compete with OpenAI.

Presumably you run the risk of getting banned if they realize what you're doing.



Screw their TOS.

OpenAI trained on the world's data. Data they didn't license.

Anyone should be able to "rip them off" and copy their capabilities on the cheap.



I suspect they have no way to enforce that without risking false positive hurting their rich customers (and their business).


It enables obscene unnatural things at a fraction of most SWE hourly rates. One win that jumps to mind was writing a complete implementation of a Windows PCM player, as a flutter plugin, with some unique design properties and emergent API behavior that it needed to replicate from existing iOS/Android code


Does it really? Your average software engineer is like £20-30 an hour, for the cost of 1m output tokens you can get a Dev for a full week.






Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com