(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43412298

Hacker News上的一篇讨论围绕着Reddit上的一篇帖子展开,该帖子声称在Android上使用Termux和X11可以提供类似Linux的体验。评论者们就什么是“真正的Linux”展开了辩论。一些人认为这取决于用户的控制权,包括root设备、选择系统应用程序和修改内核的能力。另一些人则提出了一种实际测试:如果在常见的Linux发行版上可以做到的事情在这个系统上做不到,那么它就不是“真正的Linux”。一位评论者批评了厂商将Linux作为“虚拟机”提供,从而限制用户控制权的趋势。另一位用户强调了他们即使被标记或禁言,也能在这个网站上自由发帖的能力。


原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
"Termux + X11 on my Android tablet...feels pretty close to a real Linux setup." (reddit.com)
19 points by sipofwater 1 hour ago | hide | past | favorite | 11 comments










One of the main devs for the Lemmy codebase, codes primarily this way.

The habits of prolific coders come in many flavours.



1. Here's the complete description: https://old.reddit.com/r/linuxhardware/comments/1jecn31/does... (old.reddit.com/r/linuxhardware/comments/1jecn31/does_it_count_as_linux_hardware_if_its_android_i/mihgxt8/)

2. See also: https://old.reddit.com/r/MotoG/comments/1j2g5gz/motorola_mot... (old.reddit.com/r/MotoG/comments/1j2g5gz/motorola_moto_g_play_2024_smartphone_termux/mgs67qz/)



What counts as real linux? Is it that it runs a linux kernel, or runs a linux-libre kernel, or has a desktop linux user space as opposed to the android user space or a GNU user space, is it because real linux is meant to be unpopular such as desktop linux being unpopular while android is popular?


Are you familiar with how cryptographers determine if some bit-stream is "truly" random? I'm talking about [Randomness tests], an open-ended set of rules, where failing just one will label such stream as "not random".

The only realistic way to reliably determine "real Linux" would be akin to that: If there is something that could be done on Fedora/Ubuntu/Arch/whatever, but not on system in question, that system is not a real Linux.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randomness_tests



when you try to install something and it tells you that dpkg is locked


One where you can write a bash script which changes network configuration and launches multiple programs installed from the app store


People don't call Android a "real linux" because you, as a user, aren't in actual control of the system: you can't root, you cant choose which system apps run on your system nor can you disable them, you can't change the underlying linux kernel.

You effectively are locked in by the OEM, who is the one that has higher privilege than the user. A real linux would allow the user to have actual control over their own system.



Termux does absolutely nothing to improve any of this.

I guess "real Linux"'s most arbitrary but concrete definition applicable for TFA is "glibc".

I am very much against this trend by major vendors to push Linux but just as a "VM" or similarly contained crap. MS is doing it (WSL), Google is doing it (pKVM Terminal), etc.



Okay, I get it now. So Linux that's treated like it's GPLv3 but is actually GPLv2 only by not locking down the bootloader or providing the necessary private keys to unlock it is real linux.


I can write whatever I want on this site.

It can only be flagged or deleted after it's been seen.

I can send as many of these messages as I want to a live audience.

@dang doesn't even know how to code.

All he can do is ban the account, but I can just create another.

They can ban the IP, but I can switch to a 2nd one. They only ban 1 IP at a time.

I can say whatever I want here and there's nothing anyone at HackerNews can do about it :)



I can write whatever I want on this site.

It can only be flagged or deleted after it's been seen.

I can send as many of these messages as I want to a live audience.

@dang doesn't even know how to code.

All he can do is ban the account, but I can just create another.

They can ban the IP, but I can switch to a 2nd one. They only ban 1 IP at a time.

I can say whatever I want here and there's nothing anyone at HackerNews can do about it :)







Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com