(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43517318

Hacker News正在讨论一起可能涉及28亿Twitter(X)用户数据的泄露事件。文章暗示泄露源于一名心怀不满的内部人士,但这尚未得到证实。许多评论者对此表示怀疑。有人指出泄露的数据(用户ID、关注者数量、位置等)似乎都是公开信息,甚至可以在archive.org上找到。另一些人强调这些数据可能并非完全来自X。文章标题的准确性也受到质疑。一位用户注意到,之前可见的发帖客户端现在已从界面中隐藏。关于泄露数据中机器人或AI账号的比例也有猜测。还有评论者预测马斯克会进行调查,同时会削弱数据保护机构的影响力。总的来说,评论语气谨慎,对报道的“泄露”事件的严重性和真实性表示质疑。


原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Twitter (X) Hit by Data Leak of 2.8B Users – Allegedly an Insider Job (hackread.com)
30 points by CHEF-KOCH 29 minutes ago | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments










Article itself says

>Their theory that a disgruntled employee leaked the data during the layoffs remains unconfirmed, and there’s no concrete evidence to support it; it is only a plausible hypothesis given the timing and internal mess at X.



This is just information that was publicly visible previously. Someone could see almost all of this on old archive.org pages. The current UI hides some of it but it’s not like this is secret.


Tl;dr:

- probably all the data isn't from X

- the data seems to be all public - e.g.

   - user ID and screen name

   - number of followers

   - number of tweets

   - source of last Tweet (e.g. TweetDeck)

   - location and timezone

   - profile is protected or verified

I'm not sure that headline is very sensible to propagate.


The posting client was removed from the UI and has not been public for a while


Oh No, what will a bot do ? Maybe we can find out what percentage of these users are either bots or an ID for use by AI.

I wonder if the public is fully insensitive to these leaks now that we seem to have a big leak every other day.



Place bet: Musk investigates while shutting down any data protection agencies.






Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com