(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43603111

Hacker News 上的一个帖子讨论了联邦预算削减对美国步道维护的影响,并引用了一篇关于标志性步道维修中断的文章。 评论者们就削减的意义展开了辩论,其中一人链接了一篇布鲁金斯学会的文章,认为这些削减只占整体预算的一小部分,并且是出于意识形态驱动的。其他人则强调了由此造成的赤字增加,并批评当前的政治环境脱离了实用主义。 讨论涉及军事开支、富人减税以及志愿者步道维护的重要性,一些人主张向现有的步道维护组织捐款。有人呼吁采取类似的集体行动来解决医疗保健、教育和失业问题。有人提出让使用者通过志愿工作来支付步道维护费用,并将其与道路维护作比较。最后一条评论表达了对自动化对工人的影响的担忧,并倡导政府支持的再培训项目。

相关文章

原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Federal cuts disrupt repairs to iconic U.S. trails (apnews.com)
40 points by geox 2 hours ago | hide | past | favorite | 15 comments










Brookings Institute has a good plot showing how much federal spending is being cut by this administration:

https://www.brookings.edu/articles/tracking-federal-expendit...

Turns out all the cuts are only a fraction of a percent of the federal budget. It's an ideological purge, nothing to do with efficiency at all.



And between legal costs and the farm bailout for the tariffs, it shouldn’t be surprising that this “efficiency” administration is blowing out our deficit by a few trillion dollars.


>it shouldn’t be surprising

The current flavour of politics is not pragmatic. It’s a luxury belief system.

The left wing excesses of the 2010s were luxury beliefs, the current thing is all just luxury beliefs too.

Basically, when people are economically comfortable and have no real problems, they’ll blow something out of proportion or just plain invent issues in order to feel something.

I have luxury beliefs of my own, many people do. We are free to hold them in North America. But there’s a cost, and that cost shouldn’t be surprising.



Don’t let internet memes like “luxury beliefs” do too much of the heavy lifting of actual thinking for ya


> We are free to hold them in North America

You are, as long as you're not brown.



Yeah and the military is a third of our budget and no one in politics ever wants to cut that. There’s so much excess spending there we could cut $300 billion a year from it and still be the world’s bully. China builds infrastructure in other countries as a carrot to insinuate themselves in global affairs but we just build military bases as a stick. Seems like the former is a little bit better even if both approaches have issues.


You didn't even mention the immense new tax giveaways to the rich.


These cuts are particularly nasty because federal spending on public trail maintenance is already razor thin. A ton of the Pacific Crest Trail and other scenic trails are already primarily maintained by volunteer groups doing work like log clearing, brush removal, and tread work. Trail users ourselves—hikers, mountain bikers, or trail runners—already put in hundreds of volunteer hours every season doing the basic trail work, and that's just regular seasonal maintenance. Significant work rebuilding parts of the Appalachian Trail and PCT after wildfires or hurricanes will likely not happen this year, or for years to come, unless volunteers fill in more gaps.


Can we start a non profit where people can donate for things like this so we can actually get funding without relying on government?


There are many local, and not-so-local, groups that do this volunteer trail maintenance, and they could definitely use some monetary donations. There is the PCTA, mentioned up-thread ( pcta.org ). I volunteer for Trailkeepers of Oregon, based in Portland, and is active in many parts of the state. trailkeepersoforegon.org . There is also the Washington trails Association, and many more.


Let's also pool some money to help the sick pay for health care, the young pay for education and those affected by layoffs tackle the transition. Heck, we could even start our own government.


I kind of like the idea of the people using the trails paying for them in kind.


Yeah, let’s make road users spend a couple days a year pouring asphalt as well. It’s only fair


Automation is inevitable, but we must ensure displaced workers are retrained and supported in the transition. The government should incentivize companies to invest in upskilling employees. Short-term layoffs may be necessary, but the focus should be on adapting the workforce to new economic realities.


Yeah but why do all that when those at the top could just fight over our dwindling resources.






Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com