(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43633288

Hacker News 上的一篇帖子讨论了一篇关于AI编码强制令的文章,该文章指出AI编码强制令正将开发者逼到“崩溃的边缘”。用户表达了对强制使用AI的担忧,害怕代码质量下降,以及对自身工作的信任度降低,尤其是在大型、已有的代码库中。 许多人认为管理层不应规定开发工具,但也有人承认必须使用公司资助的资源的压力。一位用户将AI强制令与更广泛的投资不当和领导力不足的问题联系起来,认为这些问题最终都变成了员工的问题。几位用户强调了普遍存在的低信任度领导力问题,其中一条评论特别指出Y Combinator的负责人Gary Tan助长了这个问题。


原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
AI coding mandates are driving developers to the brink (leaddev.com)
23 points by bluefirebrand 31 minutes ago | hide | past | favorite | 9 comments










Just anecdotally, I recognize and dread working with AI code nowadays. In the past when I see something stupid being done, my thought was "I wonder if there's a good reason they did it this way" but now it's increasingly "I wonder what other AI written problems are in this module".

Being forced to use AI would be a nightmare, as it means I would have to turn that same distrust onto my own code. It's one thing to use AI to basically just customize a scaffold like people do when using it to bootstrap some Next.js website or something. It's a completely different matter to have it writing code in huge and data driven existing codebases.



Management should not be telling dev the tools to use. Tell me why I'm wrong.


Couldn't agree more, but when the company is paying big money for a tool you can bet they're going to make sure people are using it


Is that the RTO mandates because we have so many unused 5 year office leases?

I see, it's part deux.



"We made a poor investment and now we're making it our employees problem" is absolutely a common outcome from business leaders yeah

The only thing that trickles down is bullshit unfortunately



I mean, ideally, management should not be telling me anything and should let me do my job in splendid, peaceful isolation. In practice, however, management tells me how to do all sorts of things, all the time, and they're responsible for me continuing to get paid, so I have to listen.


You're also responsible if they get paid so if the product sinks it's game over. So they have to listen too.


This pattern is maybe 20% about AI specifically and 80% about low-trust leadership.


YC has a big role to play in this mess. Gary Tan really needs to step down. This is what happens when you put a non hacker in charge of building tech.






Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com