罗伯特·肯尼迪小儿子错了——历史上有很多自闭症诗人。
RFK Jr is wrong – there's a rich history of autistic poets

原始链接: https://theconversation.com/rfk-jr-said-many-autistic-people-will-never-write-a-poem-even-though-theres-a-rich-history-of-neurodivergent-poets-and-writers-255367

针对美国卫生与公众服务部部长罗伯特·F·肯尼迪 Jr. 关于自闭症的不准确且有害的言论,一位自闭症的英语教授强调了自闭症诗人充满活力的世界。肯尼迪声称自闭症人士无法进行创造性表达,尤其是在诗歌方面,这显然是错误的。历史上和现在都有许多自闭症人士为文学做出了重大贡献,例如大卫·米兹亚尼克、亚当·沃尔丰德和特拉西·尼尔等等。这位教授还提到,有学者认为像艾米丽·狄金森这样的过去诗人可能具有自闭症特征。 这些诗人探索各种各样的主题,常常表达他们在神经典型世界中摸索的经历。像克里斯·马丁这样的教育工作者通过诗歌进一步赋能自闭症人士,认识到诗歌的结构特点特别适合神经多样化思维。自闭症诗人不仅为艺术形式做出了贡献,也以其独特的视角丰富了艺术形式,拓展了诗歌表达的边界。认为自闭症人士无法写诗的说法不仅不准确,而且是对日益壮大且重要的作品群体的轻视。

这篇Hacker News的讨论线程围绕着RFK Jr.关于自闭症患者的言论展开,尤其关注他“他们永远写不出诗”的断言。许多评论者对此表示异议,认为这是有害的概括性说法。一些人则为RFK Jr.辩护,解释说他指的是重度自闭症患者,并列举了日常生活里一些他们可能无法做到的事情。然而,其他人则批评RFK Jr.,将他的言论与贬低残疾人的纳粹宣传相提并论。一些评论者指出高功能自闭症诊断的增加以及认同自闭症谱系可能带来的社会资本。一些评论者认为,对轻度病例的关注掩盖了重度自闭症患者面临的挑战。另一位用户表示,RFK Jr.的言论对于科技行业来说是疯狂的。总的来说,这场讨论突显了自闭症的复杂性、其能力谱系的广度以及有害刻板印象的潜在危害。
相关文章

原文

U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. recently declared autism a national “epidemic,” calling it a “preventable disease” that is growing at an “alarming rate.”

He went on to cast autism as an “individual tragedy” that “destroys families,” while stating that many autistic people will “never pay taxes, they’ll never hold a job, they’ll never play baseball, they’ll never write a poem, they’ll never go out on a date.”

The remarks drew widespread criticism from researchers, advocacy groups and autistic people. They objected to these scientifically unsound characterizations of autism, along with the broad strokes with which Kennedy described autistic people, who exist on a vast spectrum.

As an autistic English professor who studies literature and neurodiversity, I was especially unnerved by Kennedy’s contention that many autistic people will never write poetry.

It couldn’t be further from the truth.

Working poets

There’s a remarkable corpus of poetry written by autistic people, who have also written novels, plays and virtually any kind of literature imaginable. The Autism Books by Autistic Authors Project catalogs 133 collections of poetry authored by autistic individuals, which represents only a fraction of the work created by autistic poets throughout history.

One of the most well-known contemporary autistic poets is David Miedzianik, who in 1986 also wrote one of the earliest autistic memoirs. He’s published his poetry in the books “I Hope Some Lass Will Want Me After Reading All This,” “Taking the Load Off My Mind: Autobiographical and Other Poems” and “Now All I’ve Got Left is Myself: Autobiographical Poems, 1993-1996.”

Adam Wolfond is another celebrated autistic poet. Wolfond, who is nonspeaking, has released several books of poetry, including “In Way of Music Water Answers Toward Questions Other Than What Is Autism” in 2019, “The Wanting Way” in 2022 and “Open Book in Ways of Water” the following year. And Traci Neal is an autistic poet, advocate and spoken-word artist whose work has been featured in Newsweek and NPR’s Poetry Moment.

Autistic poets write about many topics. But their work is particularly poignant when discussing how they fit into a world that often labels them broken, incomplete or something less than human.

In writer and poet Tito Rajarshi Mukhopadhyay’s 2010 poem “Misfit,” the speaker of the poem notes that other people often ostracize him for his differences. But he doesn’t care:

  My hands, as usual, were flapping
  The birds knew I was Autistic;
  They found no wrong with anything.

Poets from the past

Beyond living writers, readers and researchers have also explored the possibility that poets from the past may have had autistic characteristics, even before autism came to be formally theorized by clinicians in the mid-20th century.

Of course, it’s important to exercise caution when categorizing people from the past, since they lived in worlds without those terms. At the same time, there have always been people whose minds and bodies worked in ways we’d now describe as autistic. So most literary scholars believe it is perfectly reasonable to discuss it as a possibility, as long as these historical figures aren’t given a formal, authoritative “diagnosis.”

In 2010, for example, literary scholar Julie Brown suggested that renowned American poet Emily Dickinson had characteristics – such as sensory issues, social quirkiness and a savant’s command of language – that align with those of some individuals on the autism spectrum. More recent readers have agreed.

In fact, many historical poets, novelists and playwrights have been tentatively associated with autism or other kinds of neurodivergence, such as William Wordsworth, Lewis Carroll, Hans Christian Andersen, George Bernard Shaw and Virginia Woolf.

Unique voices, unique perspectives

Of course, there are countless autistic people who write poetry who aren’t famous and haven’t published books. Neurodivergent poet and educator Chris Martin, who works with autistic people around the world, helps his students discover how to express themselves in poems.

He describes this work in “May Tomorrow Be Awake: On Poetry, Autism, and Our Neurodiverse Future,” a book that’s part memoir of Martin’s own journey and part poetry anthology of his students’ poetry.

Autistic poet and educator Chris Martin and autistic poet Adam Wolfond, who is nonspeaking, participate in a reading in 2023.

Martin describes the “remarkable reciprocity poetry shares with autism or autistic minds or autistic ways of moving through the world.”

“Time and again,” he adds, “I have watched my students … grasp the hand of poetry and begin dancing like they’ve been doing it their whole lives.”

In fact, he argues that “poetry’s patterned structure uniquely serves neurodivergent thinking.” Because many autistic people seek patterns with a “combination of knack and urgency,” reading and writing poetry, which is anchored in patterns of words, images, sounds and forms, is particularly well suited for their way of thinking.

In a recent interview with the magazine Mother Jones, autistic poet, educator and attorney Elizabeth R. McClellan said, “I know so many poets with various kinds of neurodivergence and that adds to the way that we see the world in our unique way, and that adds to our unique voice as poets.”

In other words, autistic people are able to expand the possibilities of poetry itself.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com