Open Office 正在给你二手注意力缺陷多动症。
Open Office Is Giving You Secondhand ADHD

原始链接: https://floustate.com/blog/open-office-secondhand-adhd

## 开放式办公室的隐藏成本:一位开发者的深度数据分析 为期四周的实验追踪编码时间揭示了一个惊人的事实:作者**在家中比在办公室更有创造力三倍**。通过FlouState,他们发现“创建”代码的比例存在显著差异——办公室为18%,而家中为56%——尽管项目和截止日期保持一致。 关键问题不是缺乏生产力,而是由持续中断引起的**神经功能受损**。办公室环境导致49%的时间用于“探索”(因失去上下文而重读代码),而在家中则为14%。这源于大脑在繁忙的办公室中持续的“威胁检测”,消耗认知资源并阻碍深度专注。在家中平均不间断编码时间为87分钟,而在办公室仅为11分钟。 将这些数据展示给他们的经理后,成功地试行了专门的远程“深度工作”日,显著提高了产出。作者强调这并非普遍问题——有些人可以在办公室环境中茁壮成长——但提倡**数据驱动的自我认知**,以优化个人工作方式。最终,追踪显示,专注力问题并非个人缺陷,而是环境问题,理解这一点可以释放出显著增强的创造力。

## 开放式办公室与专注:一则黑客新闻讨论 一篇最近的黑客新闻帖子引发了关于开放式办公室环境对开发者生产力的影响的争论,源于floustate.com的一篇文章。作者声称在家中更有创造力,效率是办公室的三倍,这归功于更少的中断——在办公室编写新代码的时间占比为18%,而在家中为56%。 讨论很快分化。一些评论者分享了类似的经历,回忆起过去重视安静专注的工作场所,并对令人分心的开放式布局的兴起表示遗憾。另一些人则警告不要滥用“注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)”一词来简单地描述分心,强调该疾病的复杂性。 许多人强调了无论地点如何,都需要专注的时间,并批评了现代工作场所常见的持续中断。一些用户指出,由于文章推广生产力跟踪软件,数据可能存在偏差。一个反复出现的主题是,雇主需要优先考虑员工的专注度,并允许进行深度工作,同时也要兼顾社交互动。最终,这场对话强调了生产力的个体性以及寻找最佳工作环境的挑战。
相关文章

原文

I tracked every second of my coding for 4 weeks. The data revealed something shocking: I'm 3x more creative at home than in the office. Here's why.

10:47am - Slack notification. Lost 30 seconds.

10:52am - Coworker laughs at a meme. Lost 30 seconds.

10:58am - Someone starts their standup behind you. Lost 30 seconds.

11:03am - Phone buzzes on nearby desk. Lost 30 seconds.

By lunch, you've lost 47 minutes to interruptions you don't even remember happening.

The Number That Changed Everything: 18% vs 56%

I've been tracking my coding for a month using FlouState. In the office, I create new code 18% of the time. At home? 56%.

Same projects, same deadlines, same me. Three times more creative output at home.

Creative Output by Location

3x more creative output at home

This isn't about being “less productive” in the office. The data reveals something far more disturbing: I literally become a different developer.

The Data That Made Me Question Everything

After 4 weeks of automatic tracking (since July 15th):

  • 187 hours logged automatically
  • 1,248 work sessions categorized
  • 42,000 lines of code analyzed
  • Split between office (3 days) and home (2 days)

The pattern emerged within the first week and held steady.

The Discovery That Changed How I See Myself

After my last post about the debugging perception gap went viral (turns out we only debug 2% of the time, not 40%), I kept tracking with FlouState to understand my other patterns. Within the first week, I noticed something even more disturbing in my daily summaries.

Every Monday/Wednesday/Friday - my office days - showed massive “exploring” time. Just clicking around files, reading the same code repeatedly, losing the thread. Tuesday/Thursday looked like a completely different developer's profile.

Work Type Distribution: Office vs Home

49% of office time spent “exploring” (re-reading the same code)

At first I thought it was coincidence. Bad week at the office. So week two, I deliberately moved my complex feature work to office days.

The pattern held:

  • Office days: still ~20% creating
  • Home days: still ~55% creating

By week three, I accepted the truth: The environment was changing who I was as a developer.

See YOUR Actual Coding Time Breakdown

Stop guessing. Start knowing. FlouState automatically tracks and categorizes your coding activity in VS Code.

No credit card required • Works with your existing workflow • Private by design

What The Data Actually Shows

Office Days (Mon/Wed/Fri)

🚀 Creating:18% (1.4 hrs)

🐛 Debugging:2% (10 mins)

🔧 Refactoring:31% (2.5 hrs)

🔍 Exploring:49% ← Half my day

🚀 Creating:56% ← 3x more (4.5 hrs)

🐛 Debugging:2% (10 mins)

🔧 Refactoring:28% (2.2 hrs)

🔍 Exploring:14%

That “exploring” time haunted me. I wasn't learning new frameworks or studying documentation. I was re-reading the same file for the fifth time because I'd lost context. Again.

The 23-Minute Rule Nobody Talks About

Research from UC Irvine shows it takes an average of 23 minutes and 15 seconds to fully refocus after an interruption. In my month of tracking:

Average Uninterrupted Focus Time (minutes)

Office interruptions happen before recovery is possible

Average uninterrupted coding time at home: 87 minutes
Average uninterrupted coding time in office: 11 minutes

I never get 23 minutes to recover. I'm perpetually operating at 30% cognitive capacity, like a computer with too many browser tabs thrashing its memory.

The Invisible Poison: Attention Residue

Here's what's actually happening in that 49% “exploring” time:

Your brain evolved to notice tribe members' behaviors for survival. Every movement in your peripheral vision, every sound, every visual change triggers ancient threat-detection systems. Your conscious mind doesn't notice, but your brain does a status check.

In an open office with 20 people, you're running a background process consuming 60-70% of your cognitive resources just tracking potential “threats.”

You're not distracted. You're neurologically impaired.

A Typical Day: The Minute-by-Minute Reality

Focus Level During a Typical Office Morning

Never recovering to baseline focus before the next interruption

Office Day (Wed, Aug 7)

9:00am - Start deep work on auth feature

9:08am - Slack notification (2 min)

9:19am - Coworker asks about lunch

9:31am - Mechanical keyboard thundering

9:44am - Sales team celebrates

9:52am - “Hey, quick question...” (12 min)

10:15am - Finally refocused... coffee chatter

Result: 23 minutes of creating in 75 minutes

Home Day (Thu, Aug 8)

9:00am - Continue same auth feature

10:27am - First natural break to stretch

Result: 87 minutes of pure creation, feature completed

This Isn't About Productivity - It's About Identity

For the past month, every office day, I've watched myself become someone I don't recognize in the data:

  • A developer who can't finish a function without getting lost
  • Someone who reads the same code 5 times
  • A “senior” engineer producing junior-level output

The data proves it: I'm not less motivated in the office. I'm biologically impaired.

When developers say “I can't focus in the office,” we're treated like we're making excuses. But you wouldn't tell someone with lung damage from secondhand smoke to “just breathe better.”

The Secondhand Smoke Parallel Is Perfect

We spent decades discovering that secondhand smoke causes real physiological damage. The open office is causing real neurological damage - we just can't see it without data.

Your focus issues aren't a personal failing. They're environmental poisoning.

What Actually Works (Based on Data, Not Hope)

After discovering this pattern, I tried everything:

What Didn't Work:

  • Noise-cancelling headphones (visual interruptions still trigger)
  • “Focus time” blocks (ignored by colleagues)
  • Earlier hours (maintenance staff, security, early birds)

What Actually Worked:

  1. Presented the data to my manager - Numbers don't lie
  2. Negotiated “deep work” days - Tue/Thu at home for complex features
  3. Office days became “collaboration days” - Meetings, reviews, pairing

My manager was skeptical until I showed three weeks of data. Hard to argue with 3x creative output.

The Conversation Script That Works

“I've been tracking my work patterns to optimize my productivity. The data shows I complete complex features 3x faster at home due to fewer interruptions. Could we trial having my feature work on remote days and collaboration on office days? I'll share the metrics after a month.”

Not: “I hate the office.”
But: “Here's how we maximize my output.”

Some Developers DO Thrive in Offices (And That's OK)

My colleague Sarah shows the opposite pattern - she creates MORE in the office. She feeds off the energy, thinks better out loud, and uses background noise for focus. Her FlouState data backs this up.

This isn't about offices being universally bad. It's about knowing YOUR pattern and designing YOUR optimal environment.

Developer Productivity Preferences (FlouState Users)

Most developers show similar patterns, but not all - track your own

The Movement Nobody's Talking About

In the past month since FlouState launched, hundreds of developers are discovering their real productivity patterns. We're not guessing anymore. We're proving that:

  • Some brains need silence to create
  • “Collaborative” and “interruptive” aren't the same
  • Pairing can be powerful, ambient noise can be poison
  • One size fits no one

Stop Blaming Yourself, Start Tracking Reality

I spent years thinking I was “easily distracted” and “lacked focus.” The data showed I can maintain deep focus for 87 minutes at home. In the office? 11 minutes on average, 23 minutes maximum.

That's not a character flaw. That's physics.

If you're reading this from an open office and feeling unproductive, you're not broken. You're swimming upstream against millions of years of evolution.

Your Next Step: Get Your Own Data

You can't fight perception with feelings. You need numbers. Track your own patterns for just two weeks - the pattern will likely be clear by then.

I track with FlouState because it automatically categorizes work types (creating vs exploring is the key insight). But even a simple time log would reveal your patterns.

The real power isn't the tool - it's finally seeing the truth about your capabilities.

The Bottom Line

After just one month of tracking, I discovered I'm operating at 30% capacity in the office. Not because I'm incapable, but because my environment is hostile to my neurology.

Track it. Prove it. Change it.

You're not asking for special treatment. You're asking to work in a way that triples your creative output. That's not accommodation - that's optimization.

I'm 3x more creative at home than in the office

The data doesn't lie: 18% creating in office, 56% at home

Discover your own patterns. Track your real productivity, not perceived.

Join hundreds tracking their actual (not imagined) creative capacity

About this post: Based on 4 weeks of personal tracking data since July 15th, 2025. Your patterns may vary, but the environment's impact on focus is well-documented. The 23-minute recovery time is from UC Irvine research on interruptions and productivity.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com