把机器人赶出健身房
Keep the Robots Out of the Gym

原始链接: https://danielmiessler.com/blog/keep-the-robots-out-of-the-gym

随着人工智能的快速发展,2026年及以后一个关键策略是 сознательно区分“工作”和“健身”任务。“工作”任务侧重于*结果*——让人工智能处理繁重的工作以实现结果。“健身”任务则侧重于*过程*——批判性思维、解决问题和技能发展,其中努力*本身*就是目标。 作者提倡识别你的核心“健身”技能——那些对你的身份和成长至关重要的技能——并积极防止人工智能使其萎缩。虽然承认人工智能不可避免地会协助这些任务,他们正在构建一个系统,与他们的人工智能助手“Kai”一起运作,充当导师。 Kai会审查完成的“健身”工作,并就人工智能决策背后的*如何*和*为什么*向作者提问,从而促进更深入的理解。建议要么尽量减少人工智能对关键技能的帮助,要么实施类似的“导师”系统,以确保持续学习并在人工智能驱动的世界中保持认知“肌肉”。

这次黑客新闻的讨论围绕着人工智能既能增强也能阻碍人类技能的潜力。发帖人(danielrm26)描述了一种平衡“增强”工作(借助人工智能辅助,简称“AUG”)与刻意“未增强”工作(简称“NAUG”)的个人系统——本质上是一种精神“健身房”,以保持批判性思维等核心技能。 评论者们同意人工智能在某些方面加速了学习,但担心如果完全依赖人工智能,基础的、实践驱动的技能会下降。一个观点区分了“快”(本能)和“慢”(理性)的决策,质疑了人工智能决策解释的价值,因为这些决策反映了本能过程。 对于夸大人工智能能力的观点也存在怀疑,一位评论员认为,对该技术的投资可能导致偏见。最终,这场对话强调了有意识地整合人工智能的必要性,确保它*提升*而非*取代*基本的人类能力。
相关文章

原文

No Robots in the Gym

AI is getting so good now (at the end of 2025) that I now have a new, primary recommendation going into 2026:

Think very carefully about where you get help from AI.

I think of it as Job vs. Gym.

  • If we're working a manual labor job, it's fine to have AI lift heavy things for us because the actual goal is to move the thing, not to lift it.
  • This is the exact opposite of going to the gym, where the goal is to lift the weight, not to move it.

In the first case we just want the output, and in the second the whole point is to do the work ourselves.

Going forward, and especially as AI improves, it's critical that we don't confuse these two things.

Step 1 is figuring out which are which for you.

For me, any sort of:

  • Critical thinking
  • Problem solving
  • Creating arguments for or against a given position
  • Etc.

...are all Gym tasks.

These are core to my how I see myself, and I want to not only maintain my skills with doing these things, but I want to get better at them over time.

That beign true, because my work is largely cognitive, and the whole point of AI is to magnify my ability to do that work, I inevitably will use AI to do many of these Gym tasks in a given day/week/year.

I've started building a system into my customized AI stack that functions not just as a worker, but also as a tutor.

Currently this takes the form of a weekly session where my Digital Assistant, Kai, can look at all the Gym tasks that he performed for me and can interrogate me on how I think it was done, how I think the code was generated, what I think the architecture was, why I think he made those decisions, etc.

Okay, so over this last week, you had me do x, y, and z.

Now it's time for me to show you how I did it and hit you with questions to ensure that you fully understand what was done and why I made the decisions I did.Kai

From there, we can go into an interactive back-and-forth, getting to first principles all the way down to code-level specifics or whatever.

This is currently done via a Claude Code skill, but I'm experimenting with some other interfaces and interaction modes as well.

So here's what I practically recommend going into 2026 and beyond.

  1. Think about once you want to be, as your core identity, in a world where AI can do most things better than us.
  2. Take a look at all the different skills you want to or need to be good at.
  3. Divide those into Job skills and Gym skills.
  4. Take note of when you are having AI do Gym work for you.
  5. Either reduce that work, if possible, or build a system similar to mine in which you work with your AI to make sure you maintain those muscles.

Keep the robots out of the gym.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com