``` 提示他人 ```
Prompting People

原始链接: https://kuber.studio/blog/Reflections/Prompting-People

最近结束考试后,作者意识到自己由于频繁使用人工智能,说话风格发生了微妙的改变。与一位老朋友的对话突显了这一点——他们说话的方式高度结构化,像是在编写提示词,用定义、描述和可能的后续问题来呈现信息,留不下自然交流的空间。 这并非有意识的选择,而是认为这是一种沟通效率的提升。虽然有些人觉得这种方式过于密集(“小型讲座”),但也有人欣赏这种全面的背景信息。作者想知道这是否反映了沟通技巧的提高,还是仅仅是提示词工程能力的增强,并注意到人类变得更加结构化的讽刺之处,而人工智能却在努力实现类似人类的互动。这种习惯很难改掉,让作者质疑它对现实世界交流的影响。

这个Hacker News讨论围绕一篇博文,详细描述了作者的沟通方式转变为更像“提示词”的结构——一开始就提供大量背景信息——以及对话伙伴们出乎意料的负面反应。 许多评论者认为作者的惊讶是多余的,认为未经请求的讲授和缺乏对话互动通常不受欢迎。 几个人指出这种风格类似于与大型语言模型(LLM)的互动,导致猜测人们是否会采用LLM的沟通模式,形成一种反馈循环。 关于博文是否夸大了这种现象存在争论,一些人认为这是花更多时间上网和与人工智能互动的结果。 另一些人承认自己已经开始以这种方式说话,并担心被认为像机器人。 讨论还幽默地引用了新兴的“提示工程师”职位以及相关的、有趣的专业。 最终,这场讨论强调了沟通媒介——包括人工智能互动——如何塑造我们*如何*相互沟通。
相关文章

原文

I just gave my final end semester exam a couple days ago when I bumped into an old friend and we got into talking and discussing some important topics for the test.

I was midway through explaining a concept he hadn’t covered when he stopped me. He pointed out that my way of speaking had completely changed and how it was unusually structured and didn’t give him the opportunity to ask follow up questions.

and that’s when it hit me - I think the more often I use AI, the more I start talking to people like how I engineer prompts for LLMs and not just over messages or text - even in person.

even the concept I was explaining - definition, descriptions, potential follow up questions and edge cases in that order.

What’s funny is that this isn’t even intentional - it’s what I believe in my head is the more “efficient” way to express my thoughts and ideas than entirely separate, broken up conversations.

The more surprising part is the unusual reactions of the other people getting a better picture and context of what I’m explaining without the usual back and forth - which has landed me my fair share of complaints of having to hear mini lectures, but not more than people appreciative of the fuller picture.

It made me realize that while we’re training AI to be more human, the conversations might be training us to be more structured and honestly I’m not sure if this makes me a better communicator or just a better prompt engineer, but it’s a hard habit to break.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com