歌曲因由人工智能创作而被瑞典排行榜禁播。
Song banned from Swedish charts for being AI creation

原始链接: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cp829jey9z7o

瑞典音乐排行榜已禁止风靡一时的歌曲《我知道,你不是我的》(“Jag vet, du är inte min”),因为该歌曲主要由人工智能创作。这首民谣流行歌曲由数字艺术家“Jacub”演唱,尽管该艺术家缺乏传统的公众形象,但在Spotify瑞典排行榜上获得了超过五百万的播放量,并登顶榜首。 调查显示,这首歌是由Stellar Music团队使用人工智能作为关键工具制作的,引发了关于人类创造力作用的争论。虽然制作人坚持认为人工智能只是由人类主导的过程中的“工具”,但瑞典IFPI还是阻止了这首歌进入排行榜,理由是主要由人工智能生成的音乐不符合进入排行榜的资格。 这一决定反映了人们对人工智能可能对音乐人收入产生的影响的担忧——预计瑞典的音乐人收入将下降25%。虽然其他排行榜,如Billboard,侧重于听众参与度,无论其来源如何,但瑞典正在采取更坚定的立场,在快速发展的AI音乐产业中,优先考虑其官方排名中的人类艺术创作。

人工智能创作的一首歌已被瑞典唱片工业协会(IFPI Sweden)从瑞典排行榜上移除。这一决定源于对人工智能音乐可能大幅减少人类音乐创作者收入的担忧——未来两年内可能减少高达25%。 Hacker News的讨论引发了关于排行榜排名是否应等同于“好”音乐的争论,并将其与快餐甚至非法物质进行比较,以说明受欢迎程度并不等同于质量。许多评论者认为消费者应该自由选择他们听的内容,而另一些人则支持保护艺术家的生计和音乐创作的基础。 一些人指出,音乐产业历史上一直抵制新技术(如MP3和流媒体),并将此视为反对无偿劳动而非创新本身。少数异议人士将这一禁令称为对人工智能的“种族歧视”。
相关文章

原文

A song which has been streamed millions of times in Sweden has been banned from that country's music charts because it was created by Artificial Intelligence (AI).

Called I know, You're Not Mine - Jag vet, du är inte min - it is currently top of the Spotify playlist of Sweden's most popular songs. But the singer is a digital creation and the country's music industry body has blocked the track from its official chart listings.

It's a folk-pop song telling a melancholic story of lost love.

Backed by a finger-picked acoustic guitar melody, it weaves a tale of late-night heartbreak, broken promises and shattered hopes.

"Your steps in the night, I hear them go," sings the artist known as Jacub in a haunting voice.

"We stood in the rain at your gate and ran out and everything went fast. Now I know you are not mine, your promises came to nothing."

It quickly became Sweden's biggest song of 2026 so far, amassing more than five million Spotify streams in a matter of weeks, putting it at the top of the platform's Swedish Top 50.

However, journalists who began investigating Jacub's identity found that the artist had no significant social media profile, media appearances or tour dates.

When investigative journalist Emanuel Karlsten began digging deeper, he found that the song was registered to a group of executives connected to Stellar Music, a music publishing and marketing firm based in Denmark. Two of the individuals work in Stellar's AI department.

The producers – calling themselves Team Jacub – issued a lengthy email to Karlsten, insisting their creative process had been misunderstood.

"We are not an anonymous tech company that just 'pressed a button,'" they wrote.

"The team behind Jacub consists of experienced music creators, songwriters, and producers who have invested a lot of time, care, emotions, and financial resources."

They described AI as a "tool" or an "assisting instrument" within a "human-controlled creative process". To Team Jacub, they said, the five million Spotify streams were proof of the song's "long-term artistic value."

As to whether Jacub was a real person, Team Jacub gave a philosophical response.

"That depends on how you define the term," they said.

"Jacub is an artistic project developed and carried by a team of human songwriters, producers, and creators. The feelings, stories, and experiences in the music are real, because they come from real people."

That response has not impressed the IFPI Sweden music industry organisation, which has blocked the song from appearing in the country's official national charts.

"Our rule is that if it is a song that is mainly AI-generated, it does not have the right to be on the top list," said Ludvig Werner, head of IFPI.

Sweden is positioning itself as a global laboratory for the AI economy, amid concerns that AI could cut revenues to the country's music creators by up to a quarter within the next two years.

Music rights society Svenska Tonsättares Internationella Musikbyrå (STIM) launched a licensing system last September, allowing tech firms to legally train their AI models on copyrighted works in return for royalty payments.

At the launch, Lina Heyman from STIM described the framework as "the world's first collective AI licence". She said it would "show that it is possible to embrace disruption without undermining human creativity."

Sweden's chart ban on Jag vet, du är inte min is tougher than the approach taken by international organisations like Billboard, regarded as the world authority on music rankings.

AI-generated tracks have featured in some of its specialist charts. Billboard says that its charts reflect the tastes of listeners. Tracks qualify if they meet its criteria for sales, streams and airplay, even if they have been generated by algorithms.

Bandcamp, a platform known for supporting independent artists, has taken a stricter position, however.

It has prohibited music that is "generated wholly or in substantial part by AI." That includes tracks composed or produced by AI or using voice clones.

AI-generated music is forecast to explode in the coming years into an industry worth billions of pounds. As the needle drops on a new era of digital music creation, the controversy in Sweden over Jacub suggests that for now at least it is human musicians not machines who still call the tune.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com