你有三分钟逃离永恒的底层 – geohot
You have three minutes to escape the perpetual underclass – geohot

原始链接: https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2026/01/17/three-minutes.html

这篇帖子是对在亚马逊等强大科技公司工作的优秀人才的警告,他们将自己的工作视为构建一个新的“新封建”体系。作者认为,在这个体系内积累财富最终是徒劳的。随着自动化使劳动力边缘化,即使拥有可观的收入也无法抵御集中资本的控制——以一种假设的、极其昂贵的AI(“GPT$$$”)为例。 与历史上劳动具有*一定*价值的封建主义不同,完全自动化的未来将使人们在经济上变得无关紧要。仅仅投资于这个体系并不能提供保障,因为当权者会贬低大众持有的任何资产。核心信息是呼吁考虑为这个未来做出贡献的伦理影响,并质疑参与一个最终会使除少数人之外的所有人都处于劣势的体系。作者认为,集体拒绝参与是避免普遍贫困下层阶级的唯一途径。

## 黑客新闻讨论摘要:人工智能、自动化与未来工作 一篇最近由“geohot”在黑客新闻上发布的帖子引发了关于先进人工智能和自动化潜在负面后果的争论,将其描述为一种新的“新封建主义”形式,在这种形式下,劳动被贬值,并出现一个永久的下层阶级。作者建议避免参与这些技术的发展。 评论者们在很大程度上不同意作者放弃在科技行业工作的呼吁,理由是实际问题,例如需要收入。许多人指出,自动化在历史上一直在*增加*整体繁荣,并认为政治解决方案和保障措施比个人抵制更有效。 一个关键的争论点是AGI/ASI是否是一个现实的威胁,一些人认为这是夸大的,而另一些人则认为有可能完全取代劳动力。一些评论员批评了作者的虚伪,指出他过去曾在大型科技公司工作。 最终,这场讨论凸显了对未来工作、科技权力集中以及潜在经济破坏的焦虑,但对于超越适应和要求开发这些技术的人承担责任的可行途径,几乎没有达成共识。
相关文章

原文

I had a dream last night I went to work at Amazon. Joining the Bezos neofeudal empire. This post is directed at anyone with talent who works at a tech company ushering in this future.


Have you thought about how this is going to play out? I understand you may be at a place where you are insecure about money, and that insecurity is what drives you. But why do you think having more money will fix that insecurity?

In the future, when labor is fully marginalized and capital is the only force, you will not be able to afford GPT$$$ (it’s $1B per month), only the billionaires will. GPT$$$ is surely smart enough to separate you from whatever you have, be that with targeting advertising, a scam you fall for, or lobbying your government to take it from you.

A pile of money will buy you nothing in the neofeudal world.


Historically, there has been some loyalty to the subjects of a feudal empire because labor had some value. You needed the peasants to grow the grain so you could tax it and take it and have leverage over others by having grain to offer them. When the grain is produced by machines, the peasants are cut out of the loop.

The solution to this is not to accumulate grain, buy shares in a granary, or anything else like that. They will find a way to make whatever you have worthless. Because the feudal world didn’t operate on capitalist principles, and neither will the neofeudal world.


If you work at a large company, if you work according to the principles of modern capitalism, where all the fish will be eaten by the bigger fish, and all will be eaten by the sharks, and all the sharks will be eaten by bigger sharks, you are actively bringing about the system that will kill you.

Have you considered not participating? If you participate, we all lose. We will either all be in the underclass together or not.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com