(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43478091

Hacker News 的讨论总结如下: 中央情报局局长透露该机构电脑安装了 Signal 应用,引发了关于其在政府部门使用情况的讨论。评论员 jandrewrogers 指出,美国情报界几年前就已转向使用 Signal,用它取代 Gmail 来进行非机密甚至某些机密通信。他们强调,对许多美国政府人员来说,使用 Signal 是一种现实需求。 其他评论者也分享了相关信息:czk 提供了约翰·拉特克利夫提及 Signal 的视频链接;gsibble 指出 Signal 已获得联邦政府批准用于通信;treetalker 警告不要将 Signal 用于敏感信息或未经授权的接收者,并强调了意外加入群聊的风险;ceejayoz 进一步澄清,拥有安装 Signal 的手机并不意味着可以随意在其上讨论机密信息。


原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
CIA Director Reveals Signal Comes Installed on Agency Computers (theintercept.com)
27 points by jbegley 28 minutes ago | hide | past | favorite | 7 comments










A lot of tech people here are obviously unfamiliar with the history of this. They used to use Gmail for nominally unclassified communication. Several years ago they unceremoniously dropped Gmail for all purposes, without much explanation. It was mostly replaced with Signal.

I originally started using Signal almost entirely as a side effect of this transition. It was blessed as a preferred choice of the US intelligence community for unclassified comms many years ago. And a lot of classified comms if we are honest. If you worked in the US government, you needed Signal.

This isn’t a value judgement, just an acknowledgement of reality. Given this, it would be weird if they didn’t have Signal installed.





ciafiles.org

password:

DRH^i9y2rW!CD(1N



Which means it is approved by the federal government for communications.


… but not approved for communicating certain information, such as advance battle plans, no matter to whom that information is communicated; nor communicating any information permitted on that channel to people who should not be included on that channel, such as journalists — and it seems that "accidentally" adding someone who should not be on the channel would be much easier to do in a group-messaging app, as opposed to, say, the Situation Room or some other in-person, secure location.


The existence of a phone on your desk does not mean you’re approved to discuss secrets on it.


Sure, up to and including top secret?






Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com