(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43398081

Bluelegacy 创建了一个多人在线实时竞争扫雷游戏(minesweeperpro.com),游戏设有计分系统奖励正确的操作。玩家们竞争着清除棋盘并获得分数。 Hacker News 用户 latexr 批评了这款游戏,认为它更注重竞争而非合作。他们建议加入一些促进真正合作的功能,例如分配角色或回合制游戏玩法。他们还指出了手机版上旗帜放置的不清晰之处。Bluelegacy 承认了这一批评,并澄清了游戏确实是竞争性的。他们解释了旗帜放置的机制。 另一位用户 csmattryder 非常喜欢这款游戏,并建议添加一个无需登录即可输入名称的功能。georgeplusplus 赞扬了游戏的设计,并请求 Bluelegacy 提供一些关于构建多人游戏的资源。


原文
Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Show HN: I made a live multiplayer Minesweeper game (minesweeperpro.com)
10 points by bluelegacy 2 hours ago | hide | past | favorite | 4 comments
Hi everyone! For several months now I've been stuck on the idea of a Minesweeper game that isn't just single player. This is what I came up with:

• Live games allowing several people to play at the same time

• Scoring system rewarding correct moves

• Grid size, mines count, and players count set to make games as balanced as possible











> Scoring system rewarding correct moves

I felt this entirely undermined the stated goal. You didn’t make cooperative minesweeper but the exact opposite—competitive minesweeper—because despite playing in the same board you’re both competing for who is faster and can get more individual points.

True cooperation would be something like only one person being able to reveal numbers and the other only being able to place flags. Or each player having one turn at a time and all working together to not lose (currently a wrong move is nothing but a point loss, effectively removing consequences from the game).

Also, if it is possible at all, it wasn’t clear how to place flags on mobile.



This is a fair point! It is a competitive multiplayer minesweeper rather than co-op. but where everyone is rewarded for their correct contributions to clearing the board. I'm correcting the game descriptions related to this. Thanks!

Flag placements are touch & hold on mobile and right-click on PC.



Ok, that was fun. Pipped Ginko to the win by one point, they should've calculated the last square was a flag faster than I did.

It'd be cool to be able to put your own name in though, without signing in. Just a suggestion.



Looks and plays awesome. I would love to do something similar. Do you have anything to share that documents your accomplishment that could help myself and others to get started into multiplayer gaming?






Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



Search:
联系我们 contact @ memedata.com